Advertisement
Tuesday, Sep 28, 2021
Outlook.com
Outlook.com

Want to “get back to action” but will go by medical advice, says SC on physical hearing

Want to “get back to action” but will go by medical advice, says SC on physical hearing
outlookindia.com
1970-01-01T05:30:00+0530
New Delhi, Jan 20 (PTI) The Supreme Court, which has been conducting hearing through video-conferencing since March last year amid the COVID-19 pandemic, Wednesday said it want to “get back to the action” like earlier but it will go by the opinion of health authorities on the issue.

The apex court made the observation while hearing pleas against a recent circular issued by the Delhi High Court allowing physical hearing in some of its courts and on alternate days of the week in trial courts here "in view of the decline in the intensity of spread of COVID-19 pandemic in the national capital".

While asking the petitioners to approach the high court on the issue, a bench headed by Chief Justice S A Bobde said, “We trust that the Chief Justice of Delhi High Court will do the needful.”

When senior advocate Vikas Singh, who was representing some of the petitioners, raised the issue of resumption of physical hearing in the apex court, the bench said, “We also want to get back to the action we used to. But we want to consult the health authorities before that. We are not going to take the opinion of advocates on a health issue”.

“We have asked for medical opinion. We will take the decision after that. We know the opinion of Bar. We have been hearing them for past nine months. Everyday, we hear members of the Bar,” the bench observed.

Singh told the bench, also comprising Justices A S Bopanna and V Ramasubramanian, that common man is not getting justice in the virtual hearing.

To this, Solicitor General Tushar Mehta said, “That is not true. Our courts have not denied access to a single citizen.”

Senior advocate Kapil Sibal, appearing for some of the petitioners, sought adjournment in the matter saying that Registrar General of the high court has called lawyers for a discussion on the issue today evening.

“You withdraw the petition,” the bench said.

When Sibal requested that the matter be kept pending in the apex court, the bench said, “No no. You approach the high court.”

One of the pleas was filed by Kartik Nayar, Nancy Roy, Sachit Jolly and Amit Bhagat, who all are practicing lawyers in Delhi.

On January 14, the Delhi High Court had said it has decided to increase the number of judges who would be hearing cases physically from January 18 onwards "in view of the decline in the intensity of spread of COVID-19 pandemic in the national capital".

The high court has also issued directions to the district courts in Delhi to hold physical courts on alternate days of the week from Monday.

An office order issued by Registrar General Manoj Jain had said that the Full Court of the high court has decided that 11 benches -- two division benches of two judges each and nine single-judge benches -- shall conduct physical proceedings from January 18 and the rest would hear matters via video conferencing.

One of the pleas filed in the apex court had said that since November last year, it was submitted by various advocates that sole reliance on virtual hearing system was causing hardships and several lawyers were not able to access proper internet connectivity and therefore were lacking efficient means to appear virtually before the various judicial forums including the high court and district courts.

“The High Court of Delhi took the same into consideration, however keeping in mind the unstable situation due to the ongoing pandemic, and the representations made by several members of the esteemed bar, continued to follow the hybrid system of hearings on rotational basis, and allowing physical hearing only in 1/4 th capacity, in a phased manner,” it had said.

It had said that hybrid system of optional virtual and physical hearing was accommodating as it catered to the needs of the advocates who preferred to appear in person for their respective matters due to not being able to access proper internet connectivity and at the same time allowed the advocates, suffering from comorbidities or having someone in their family having major health concerns, appear virtually.

“However, to much shock and dismay of the advocates and the legal fraternity, the impugned notification along with the latest roster of physical sitting of courts was released on January 14-15, which mandates that a total of 11 benches, inclusive of two division benches, three single benches (Civil), three Single/benches (Criminal) and three original benches (Civil), to sit daily and take up matters physically,” it had said.

The high court had, on March 25, 2020 restricted its functioning as well as that of the district courts till April 14, 2020 and it was subsequently extended from time to time till January 16, 2021. PTI MNL ABA SJK ABA RKS

RKS


Disclaimer :- This story has not been edited by Outlook staff and is auto-generated from news agency feeds. Source: PTI

More from Website

Out Of Turn Land Allotment To Sourav Ganguly: Calcutta High Court Imposes 'Token Cost' On BCCI Chief

Out Of Turn Land Allotment To Sourav Ganguly: Calcutta High Court Imposes 'Token Cost' On BCCI Chief

Passing the order, the bench said there is a need to have a defined policy to guide on all issues so that there is no arbitrary exercise of power.

RR Skipper Sanju Samson: Sharing Information With The Team On What's Working Well For Me

RR Skipper Sanju Samson: Sharing Information With The Team On What's Working Well For Me

Sanju Samson has been in exceptional form in the second leg of the IPL. He has scored 2 consecutive half-centuries in the last two games against DC and SRH

Women's Asian Cup Football: Iran Book Historic Ticket For India Finals

Women's Asian Cup Football: Iran Book Historic Ticket For India Finals

Former champions Thailand, South Korea and the Philippines also qualified for the 12-team continental women's showpiece to be held in India for the second time after 1979.

More from Outlook Magazine

Out Of Tune: Indie Musicians Seek Protection From Heckling And Abuse At Gigs

Out Of Tune: Indie Musicians Seek Protection From Heckling And Abuse At Gigs

Performers’ safety can only be ensured through street cred and holding organisers accountable.

Smoke And Mirrors: Smog Towers To Clean Up Dirty Air Is A Polluted Idea

Smoke And Mirrors: Smog Towers To Clean Up Dirty Air Is A Polluted Idea

The concept of vacuuming air in the open is not a practical solution to combat air pollution.

Sentry Duty On High Seas: Any Move To Contain China Is Welcome

Sentry Duty On High Seas: Any Move To Contain China Is Welcome

China, Afghanistan and the Quad are the pressing issues that form the backdrop of PM Modi’s first in-person meeting with Joe Biden

Advertisement

Outlook Newsletters

Advertisement