Making A Difference

So This Is What War Looks Like?

It's not Bob Hope or some other entertainer regaling the troops with bad jokes and worse music, while the soldiers take long drags off cheap cigarettes and fantasize about sleeping with some pinup girl as soon as they get back stateside.

Advertisement

So This Is What War Looks Like?
info_icon

Well, now we know.

War is not a high-tech video game; or grainy footage of exploding bombs as seen through night-visiongoggles.

It's not swiftly moving tanks, displaying their mechanical prowess across the Iraqi desert.

It's not like the war games the solders planned for. It's not like wrestling your unit buddy in the sand soas to "toughen you up" for duty.

It's not merrily greeted by the citizens of one's adversary. There are not crowds of grateful Iraqis liningthe streets, waving American flags and hoping for candy bars, Christina Aguilera CD's or some such shit, to bedispensed by the brave fighting men of the 3-7 infantry or 101st Airborne Division.

Advertisement

It's not Bob Hope or some other entertainer regaling the troops with bad jokes and worse music, while thesoldiers take long drags off cheap cigarettes and fantasize about sleeping with some pinup girl as soon asthey get back stateside.

It's not going as planned. It's not causing the enemy to fold like a bad poker hand.

It is not your grandfather's war.

But it has prompted a few thousand Arabs and Muslims from surrounding countries--Syria, Jordan, andpossibly even Iran--to enter the country and join the battle against those they view as American invaders.Shocking.

And it has caused hundreds of thousands in Pakistan--one of our allies--to take to the streets shouting"Death to America;" and in Egypt too. Shocking.

Advertisement

And it has prompted the utterly predictable turn to such tactics as suicide bombing and ambushes ofAmerican troops. As much as Donald Rumsfeld may whine about the underhandedness of such "criminal"behavior, it can hardly be surprising. After all, Iraq has no significant military force; no weapons of massdestruction to speak of (so much for that rationale for war); no air force; no working helicopters.

Guerrilla warfare is the only remaining option for such a people, and we would turn to it just as quicklyif invaded by a stronger foe. I mean, does anyone really doubt that all those NRA members would become snipersfrom behind windows and doors if push came to shove? Hell they promise as much.

Furthermore, this war is surely even now fueling a new round of al-Qaeda videos, brought to you by theworld's most elusive terrorist who, despite our spending billions to catch or kill him, manages to keep movingfrom cave to cave, cranking out tapes like he owns a Memorex factory.

And it has led to the deaths of hundreds of Iraqi civilians and the injury of thousands more. The onlysurprise here is that the numbers aren't higher; but give us a week or so. The siege of Baghdad hasn't reallybegun as of yet, and with U.S. troops now inclined to fire on anything that moves--since there have beenseveral ambushes by civilians or Iraqi forces dressed as civilians--who knows how high the body count mightgo? Of course, that hardly matters to American war planners. As General Tommy Franks puts it: "we don'tdo body counts."

Advertisement

And speaking of all that, we should also probably take note of another kind of body count, another kind ofdeath toll, but one that is rarely discussed; because amidst all the clamor about the need to "supportthe troops," (which apparently means sending them sappy video greetings and prayers on DVD playersshipped out by Target, or Wal-Mart, or Best Buy, or one of those places), there is a deafening silence aboutwhat this war is doing to those same troops.

And here I don't mean those who are killed or taken prisoner and tortured, for indeed we speak of themhourly it seems. I mean those who survive, at least in body, but who face the emotional and mental trauma oftheir actions, and do so without the apparent concern of a nation that views them as soldiers first, and humanbeings second.

Advertisement

Today, Londoners but not Americans will read about what just happened on a bridge in Nasariyah, which FoxNews anchor and all-around know-nothing Shepard Smith still can't seem to pronounce correctly after ten daysof war.

According to the Times of London, American troops fired on a group of civilians crossing the bridge as theytried to escape the war zone. Unsure as to whether they were friend or foe, and understandably nervous aboutfinding out the hard way, they unloaded on families: killing twelve, including as the Times reporter put it:"a little girl, no older than five and dressed in a pretty orange and gold dress, (who) lay dead in aditch next to the body of a man who may have been her father. Half his head was missing."

Advertisement

The report continued: "Nearby, in a battered old Volga, peppered with ammunition holes, an Iraqiwoman--perhaps the girl's mother--was dead, slumped in the back seat."

Elsewhere, "a father, baby girl and boy lay in a shallow grave. On the bridge itself a dead Iraqicivilian lay next to the carcass of a donkey."

Not to take the focus off of the dead Iraqis, for indeed they are the ones who paid the ultimate price inthis scenario, the Times report also indicated a more subtle, yet all too real set of casualties from thatattack; namely, the effect it had had on those who carried it out.

Advertisement

The reporter quoted a Lieutenant by the name of Matt Martin, whose wife had given birth to their thirdchild while he was headed to the Gulf.

"Did you see all that?" he asked, his eyes filled with tears. "Did you see that little babygirl? I carried her body and buried it as best I could but I had no time. It really gets to me to see childrenbeing killed like this, but we had no choice."

At the opposite end of the spectrum was Corporal Ryan Dupre, for whom this war has also brought out a heavyflood of emotions, though not ones as gentle or compassionate as with Martin. According to Dupre, "TheIraqis are sick people and we are the chemotherapy." I am starting to hate this country. Wait till I gethold of a friggin' Iraqi. No, I won't get hold of one. I'll just kill him."

Advertisement

It is easy to disdain such a comment, and indeed I do.

It is easy to say--as I also would--that if Corporal Dupre carries out his threat and opens fireintentionally on Iraqi civilians, he should spend the rest of his life behind bars for war crimes.

Yet something else also should be noted.

Namely, that Messrs Dupre and Martin, though assessing their actions from different vantage points, areboth considerably worse for wear than they were a few weeks ago. That something in both of them has died;something precious, something vital to the maintenance of a healthy soul has been traumatized, and all becausethey have been set up by guys who mostly never wore a uniform and who have no idea what war is really like.

Advertisement

Guys who made this sound like it would be a stroll at Disney, with overjoyed throngs of Iraqis rushing togreet them in the streets like rock stars.

For Martin, with whom I instinctively identify because I have a daughter much like his own and much likethe ones his unit killed, the loss will haunt him the rest of his days. No matter the outcome of this war; nomatter if he never has to kill again; no matter how soon he is able to return home--his life has been alteredforever. Altered in a way that only causing death possibly can, for we are not, after all, talking about alife-changing experience on par with winning the Kentucky Lottery. That's a hell of a price to pay at the ageof 22, or 25, or 30, or whatever he is.

Advertisement

His night sweats, his terror, and the unexplained illnesses and breakdowns in years to come, all of whichwill no doubt frighten his children, and possibly torpedo his marriage will be predictable, and will not bethe fault of the anti-war movement--accused of not supporting the troops. Rather, they will be the shamefulresponsibility of the United States government, which we are told does support them. Strange thing, thissupport that renders one's conscience an acceptable form of collateral damage.

For Dupre, the danger is the dropping of his defenses against the calcification of his sympathy button, orgene, or whatever it is that prevents us from becoming murderers. That he is now finding he hates Iraq andIraqis, and views them as cancer, is no small revelation. That he cannot likely understand how Iraqis couldalso hate America and Americans, for what we have done to their country--from supporting Saddam's brutality,to killing tens of thousands of civilians in Desert Storm, to burying Iraqi soldiers alive in the desert inthat same war, to maintaining deadly sanctions for twelve years--is testimony to how little our nation'selites really prepare kids like this for what they are being asked to do.

Advertisement

Without any sense of relevant history, but with a detailed knowledge of important military facts likeSherman's troop movements through the South, or the logistics of the Normandy landing--none of which meansmuch right about now--they go out to "liberate" people who despise them.

The article goes on to discuss the way many of the "coalition" soldiers have been shell-shockedby the sight of fellow troops slaughtered by RPG's (rocket-propelled grenades), their legs hanging on by acollection of tangled sinews and little else.

Or the one particular solider who is seen carrying an unrecognizable chunk of human flesh from abattlefield, sobbing uncontrollably as he returns the remains of a friend to a safe place until they canpresumably be sent home for burial. Or the soldier who is composing a war diary for his spouse but leaving outthe parts about the children he and his comrades have killed, and who turns down the reporter's offer to callhome on a cell phone for fear that his wife will tell by his voice that something is terribly wrong.

Advertisement

Indeed something is wrong, and George W. Bush is to blame for it.

Dick Cheney and Donald Rumsfeld are to blame for it.

Tony Blair is to blame for it.

And Colin Powell is too, having long ago abandoned his apparent misgivings about this escapade so as toremain the loyal soldier. Some things haven't changed since My Lai after all.

Just as then, the troops commit atrocities. And just as then, they are destroyed by the wake of theiractions, their orders, and their mission.

Just as then, we are told not to worry, and to support the troops as they engage in a soul-searing processso utterly unnatural that it requires years of training to make one a proper killer.

Advertisement

Just as then it is we who oppose this war who will be remembered as not sufficiently supporting"our" men and women in uniform, while it will be those who put them in harm's way (and for what?),and those who forced them into the untenable position where they now feel they must kill women, children andold men in order to ensure their safety, who will be considered super-patriots.

Such is a world turned upside down, where wanting to bring all soldiers home tomorrow is beingunsupportive, while placing them in the way of car bombs and RPG's is tantamount to being their best friends.

Advertisement

As the saying goes, "with friends like these..."

Heading to the anti-war rally in Boston this past week, I noticed a man on the corner, who I presume washomeless. He had a small bucket at his feet where I guess he places the paltry offerings of automotivepassersby, headed into the downtown business district. And in his hands was a sign. It read: "HomelessVeteran. Down on My Luck. God Bless."

Little did he know that there was no "luck" to it. His immiseration was calculated, and he is nowthe logical and functional detritus of a system that needs, loves and supports its troops only when they arekilling, and not when they are simply trying to live.

Advertisement

So here he was, a "troop," supported by those in power to do whatever he had to do in combat,most likely in Vietnam, guessing by his age. And who upon returning was not spat upon by any antiwarprotester--that being a historic fabrication of almost Biblical proportions--but was likely denied membershipin the VFW by old war horses who typically considered Vietnam vets to be long-haired, dope-smoking losers,unfit for membership alongside the so-called Greatest Generation.

And now he is on the streets, the same week that "supportive" right-wing Republicans and theWhite House proposed gutting the budget for veteran's pensions and disability spending.

Advertisement

Jobless, no health care, no place to live.

This is supporting the troops, I suppose.

And this is what war is like.

Tim Wise is a writer, activist and father.

Tags

Advertisement