George Bush: Thank you for the warm welcome. You know I was a Harvard
Business School graduate. This isn't exactly how I went to class when I was
there, but I am honored to be here at ISB.
Yesterday I had the honor of standing on the stage with your Prime Minister,
talking about a new relationship between the United States and India. I am
excited about our strategic partnership. I'm equally excited about the future of
India. It is in the interest of the United States to be friends with India; it's
in the interest of the United States to work for free and fair trade with India;
it's in the interest of the United States that an entrepreneurial class grow in
this great country. It's in the interest of India that an entrepreneurial class
grow in this great country, so that people can realize dreams and find good
jobs.
You know, I said something really interesting, I thought interesting --
otherwise, I wouldn't have said it -- the other day in a speech I gave in
Washington. There are ... the middle class of India is 300 million people large.
That's larger than the entire United States. And when America looks at India,
America ought to look at India as a strategic partner in keeping the peace, a
great democracy which is capable of having people from different religions live
side-by-side in peace and harmony, and [it's] a wonderful opportunity to for
trade.
One of the things that you can judge a country by is the vitality of the youth,
and one of the reasons I really wanted to come to ISB was because I understand
it's the center of excellence in education. It's a new school that is using
innovative techniques to give people the tools necessary to succeed.
Yesterday I met with some Indian CEOs and American CEOs, kind of the old folks.
Today I'm meeting with the CEOs of tomorrow, the people that are going to help
drive this great engine of economic prosperity for India -- for the good of the
world, is how I view it.
And so, thanks for letting me and the Ambassador come. Ambassador, thanks for
setting this up. I want to thank Chairman Gupta, a fellow Harvard Business
School graduate who helped form this school. I want to thank the Dean of this
school, as well as the professors and faculty, for being here, as well, and the
rest of the students -- thanks for letting me come by to say hello. I think it
would be interesting for you to tell me what's on your mind, or ask me
questions, the whole purpose of which is to help kind of foster this partnership
that is developing on the political level so that people in my own country can
see that there's folks just like themselves here in India working to realize
dreams and create opportunities.
So whoever would like to begin, we can start. And if not, I'm just going to call
on somebody -- like you.
Question: I guess I'll do the honors. Thank you for being here. I didn't
graduate from ISB, but it seems like a great place. I graduated from Carnegie
Melon, in Pittsburgh --
George Bush: That's also a good place. I will tell you something, she's
really smart to go there. You don't go there unless you're smart.
Question: Anyways, so I'm from the IT industry, so let me ask a question
relating to that -- not just IT, I guess generally outsourcing. So India and
China have experienced a lot of growth because of globalization and outsourcing,
in general -- IT outsourcing, in particular. And I live in the U.S. so I know
that there is a lot of resistance in the media and also in the industry about
outsourcing. But as entrepreneurs and as people who believe in capitalism, we
feel that there's no other way to go but capitalism and globalization and
outsourcing, et cetera. So does the government or -- does it have a political
strategy on how to manage, do a balancing act?
George Bush: I appreciate it. First of all, what do you do?
Question: I have a IT consulting company.
George Bush: Okay. One of the ... the future of any country is to make
sure women have got opportunity, and so I congratulate you for being a CEO. By
the way, I've got a strong woman who travels with me in the Secretary of State.
I'm not trying to avoid your question, by the way.
People do lose jobs as a result of globalization, and it's painful for those who
lose jobs. But the fundamental question is, how does a government or society
react to that. And it's basically one of two ways. One is to say, losing jobs is
painful, therefore, let's throw up protectionist walls. And the other is to say,
losing jobs is painful, so let's make sure people are educated so they can find
and fill the jobs of the 21st century. And let's make sure that there's
pro-growth economic policies in place. What does that mean? That means low
taxes; it means less regulation; it means fewer lawsuits; it means wise energy
policy.
So I've taken the position -- I've taken it as recently as my State of the
Union, where I said, the United States of America will reject protectionism. We
won't fear competition, we welcome competition, but we won't fear the future,
either, because we intend to shape it through good policies.
And that's how you deal in a global economy. You don't retrench and pull back.
You welcome competition and you understand globalization provides great
opportunities. And the class opportunity for our American farmers and
entrepreneurs and small businesses to understand, there's a 300-million-person
market of middle-class citizens here in India, and that if we can make a product
they want, then it becomes -- at a reasonable price -- and then all of a sudden,
people will be able to have a market here. And so -- and people in America
should, I hope, maintain their confidence about the future.
Thanks for the question. Good luck to you.
Yes, ma'am.
Question: I actually went to Wellesley College and I'm actually a student
at the ISB.
George Bush: Let me say something before you ask the question. One of the
most important things for America is to make sure our universities and colleges
are accessible to Indian students, because I find it really interesting the
first two questioners have gone to school in the United States. There can be
sometimes perceptions about our country that simply aren't the truth, but,
nevertheless, become stuck in people's minds. And one way to defeat those
perceptions is to welcome people to the United States so you can see firsthand
our good side and our bad side, and you can draw your own conclusions without
being told what to think.
Sorry to interrupt.
Question: No problem. This is actually related to the point you just made
about the market with the 300 million people. I actually run the non-profit club
and social enterprise club here at the ISB, with a lot of help from the faculty
from the Center of Entrepreneurship and the student body. And we're a fairly
active group who are very -- who believe in what we call compassionate
capitalism, through providing for venture capital funding for the small
businesses and social entrepreneurs so that they can innovate and actually
sustain themselves by providing affordable goods, and using a market-based
model, rather than the traditional aid-based model.
So my question to you, Mr. President, is what do you feel and how do you feel
that your government will support India in this sort of bilateral partnership
whereby your investors can get a financial return, as well as create social
impact in a developing country such as India?
George Bush: Well, there's two types of investments. One is private
capital, which goes to places where people think they can get a reasonable
return relative to risk. And government can help assuage some concerns about
risk by having transparency in policy, consistent law. One of the things you
don't want to do is invest in a country, and then all of a sudden, laws change,
or transparency into why people make decisions, or less bureaucratic hurdles in
order to invest.
People look around at places to invest. In my country, for example, there's
competition between the states. And if they see there's a lot of bureaucratic
hurdles you have to get over in order to invest in one state versus another,
people tend to mitigate risk in order to maximize return.
There's also public investment, and through USAID and other aspects of our State
Department, we do provide micro-financing -- small loans to entrepreneurs.
Today, I went over to the Agricultural Center and saw some of the benefits of
not only good agricultural research, but the concept of micro loans to encourage
entrepreneurship, particularly amongst women in rural India. And it's an
effective program. And micro loans have worked around the world.
And so one of the things we do through our State Department, ably led by
Secretary Rice, I want you to know, is to encourage micro loan financing.
Yes, sir.
Question: Yes, Mr. President. My company is based in the U.S., and we
deal mostly with electronic components, exports to India. My question is, after
this nuclear deal, do you think the same thing will come in the electronics
field? Like there are a lot of sanctions, export restrictions on shipping
components to India. That same product they can buy at -- they pay more, but
they get it from Europe where there's no export restrictions.
George Bush: We're constantly reviewing what's called the Export Control
List. And I thank you for bringing that up. And obviously, as this relationship
changes, as a strategic partner, the folks involved with the Export Control List
will be taking that into account.
Yesterday's energy agreement was an important agreement. It's important for the
United States, and it's important for India. It's important for the United
States because -- in that we live in a global energy market when a fast-growing
country like India consumes more fossil fuels, it causes the price of fossil
fuels to go up not only in India, but around the world, including the United
States. And therefore, the extent to which we can help nations develop civilian
nuclear power is in the nation's interest.
Secondly, India has been an excellent partner in nonproliferation over the past
decades, and therefore, I can tell the American people that this is an important
agreement to help deal with the proliferation issue.
For India, it makes sense because it will enable India to be able to meet
electricity needs in a way that doesn't pollute the air. The United States and
India and China must use technologies to do our duty to not only make sure our
economies expand, but also to be good stewards of the environment. And nuclear
energy is a -- is a renewable source of energy in which there is zero greenhouse
gases.
Yesterday was a -- as I mentioned to you, in our private meeting, yesterday was
a way to put the Cold War behind us and to move forward as strategic partners.
And I want to congratulate your Prime Minister and the Indian government for its
-- for working with me and our government to show the world what's possible when
people can come together and think strategically.
Yes, sir.
Question: Mr. President, I did my MBA -- from Johnson and Wales, Rhode
Island, and I loved every bit of it. I saw your speech on the Asia Society, and
I thought it was very spectacular.
George Bush: Thank you. You can leave it right there. No, go ahead.
Question: My question is, India was never this important. Why has it
become so important now?
George Bush: That's a really good question. I think India has always been
an important country, but the problem is, international politics made it very
difficult for previous Presidents and previous Prime Ministers to reach common
agreement. As I said, we're getting rid of the Cold War, and the truth of the
matter is, the Cold War caused the world to become pretty well divided. And if
you're on one side of the divide, it was politically difficult to work with
people on the other side of the divide. That began to change, of course. And so
I wouldn't say that India was not an important country up to now, because it
was.
(End of public portion of event. The transcript above is unedited to preserve
the full flavour of the US Prisidentisms.)