What can Adivasi filmmakers do to change how their people and customs are depicted in mainstream cinema?
How do Adivasis make true films, sell them and get them exhibited?
These were some of the issues participants grappled with at ‘Samuday Ke Saath’, the annual Tata Steel Foundation festival in Jamshedpur.
What is an indigenous film? Is it one made by a person from an Adivasi community or one that deals with their issues, even if it’s made by, say, you (assuming you are from elsewhere)? Perhaps three days of watching films screened at ‘Samuday Ke Saath’ made in Santhali, Ho, Mundari, Sumi-Naga, Gondi, Bodo, Asuri and Nagpuri, among other languages, and listening to and interacting with the makers might have some answers.
There were other questions, too. What can Adivasi filmmakers do to change how their people and customs are depicted in mainstream (think Jhinga-la-la, hmmm, hrrr-hrrr) cinema? How do Adivasi filmmakers enter the big time? Or at least be in contention?
Even in a largely good, well-intentioned film like Chak De India (Kabir Khan, 2007), Rani Dispotta and Soimoi Kerketta, or Mary Ralte and Molly Zimik, or indeed Gul Iqbal for that matter, get nowhere near the kind of game time, so to say, as Naik, Sabharwal, Chautala, Kaur, Bose and Sharma (Brahmin. Captain.) do.
Another question: how do Adivasis make films, true films, and sell them, get them exhibited? And a related query: what’s the good strategy—stories that will sell or stories that are authentic?
These were some of the issues participants grappled with at ‘Samuday Ke Saath’, the annual Tata Steel Foundation festival in Jamshedpur, highlighting, in their words, “indigenous and tribal stories, identity, and lived experiences”.
The past two decades have probably seen more Adivasi characters on the Hindi movie screen than before. But what is the shape of that representation? Horror is in. Easy to create the formulaic clash between modernity and tradition. Oh, and you can throw in Naxals too!
The films on offer at the festival were a world away from the shoddiness and exploitation of mainstream cinema. Some made without a paisa—an interview with a person talking about a local custom in the Nagpuri-language film The Trail of Phagun, by Pawan Jordan Bara, for example—or with a budget of Rs 5,000, in another case. There were few trained actors on view. Some directors were trained or experienced and had access to more resources. For many cinematographers, the films at the festival were a first attempt.
The film that won the top award at the festival was the 24-minute-long Mundari-language film Miyad Arah Gaada (A River Coloured Red) by Saurav Munda, a graduate of the Film and Television Institute of India (FTII). It’s his diploma film, shot over nine days—the jungles of Jharkhand recreated in the Bhimashankar Range near Pune—and the post-production was done over three months. The training, the budget, it shows.
The story itself is simple: a buffalo belonging to a family (woman, man, their son) is lost and then found. But, through their domestic conversation and sequences, the devastation of the forests due to insatiable human greed (mining, construction) becomes the real story. The whop-whop of a helicopter flying over the jungle, for example.
The woman’s shoulder hurts. Her husband, who prepares herbal medicines, applies a paste, but it doesn’t work as expected. “The herbs must be weak because of the mining,” the wife comforts him. It’s left there… The boy’s dead uncle—unsaid, but possibly a Naxal killed by the police—comes to him at night and says, “I don’t worry about being in the jungle at night. It’s our home. I am scared of going to the city.” Filmmaker Niranjan Kujur echoes this line when we catch up: “My mother goes to the jungle at night and isn’t scared. It belongs to us. But she was scared of going to the city when she got a job.”
A quiet scene in the movie is deeply affecting. The roof drips water onto a bowl placed underneath in a monotonous pattern. The boy sits down, catches every alternate drop, and—there’s no other way to put it—makes music. The sound design by FTII student Mayuresh Rajguru is stunning, as is fellow FTII man Wesabo Yobin’s camerawork.
“Our boys and girls need more exposure,” septuagenarian National Award-winning documentary filmmaker Meghnath, an icon in Jharkhand, says. “It’s easier than before, but they need to watch better films, watch as many as possible from around the world, they need to read… For us, creativity is lacking, but exposure and access are the main reason for it. With exposure, which you get at film institutes, remarkable things are possible.”
Remarkable is just the word that comes to mind when you watch Vito Sumi’s 20-minute film Kashopapu, about a young man’s dead father sending word from the heavens, through a bird, to help his son with the secrets of a good harvest. Sumi’s critically acclaimed 2022 film Sound from the Hollow Bamboo was funded by Films Division. He has had the exposure.
These are films about subjects close to the makers, their milieu. “People everywhere are the same, and their emotions are the same. Customs are different. We have to think about how to develop our language, how to showcase our living space,” says Ravi Raj Murmu, whose 2024 Santhali-language documentary Angen won a best debut (non-feature) National Award.
Kujur, another National Award-winning filmmaker who is an alumnus of Satyajit Ray Film and Television Institute, says, “The sound of the birds, the sound of the river, the breeze, the forest... those belong to us. Our literature has been quite vocal about our rights. But in our poetry, the anger of the Adivasis took centre stage. We need to look inwards. Across the world, people are making films about themselves. That’s what we should do.”
A thought that finds echo in the words of Sneha Mundari, visual anthropologist and filmmaker (Aabua Paika Kabu Bageya), who says, “Rootedness is very important. When I started making films, the first thing was to do something about my people, about the Adivasi philosophy. Like, when you watch a film made by an Adivasi, you will see the preponderance of nature, the landscape. It’s not just in the background. It is our world. It defines us.”
A number of films at the festival were, like the angry poetry Kujur mentioned, driven by the need to effect change. A few of those stood out, even when they lacked technical finesse. And all of them were a welcome shift in the focus and conversation around tribal culture and rights.
The Bodo-Santhal film Solobatha, which translates simply to “folk tale”, by Pranjal Gayari, is about three siblings returning to their ancestral home, where their grandfather tells them a story about healers and witches. Bimal Murmu, the film’s producer, calls it “a story about superstitions and mob influence”. Witches and healers are real here. Rahul Dhanu Hansda’s Agam, a little story about a Santhal man stealing from the local library. Magical, if a bit rough around the edges. Even simpler is Rohit Marandi’s powerful Adyari: an elder warns a group of soon-to-migrate boys from an Odisha village that they better return in time to vote. Jamuna Tudu: The Lady Tarzan, a documentary by Ranveer Bhagat and Parul Kunkal on a one-woman tree-protecting army. Hugely important, if a bit like the old newsreels.
Just pick up a camera (or even a good phone) and you can make your film.
There is imagination, creativity, voice. For the fortunate few from one of the most neglected parts of the country, there is exposure and training, too. But then we run into commerce. And we run into discrimination.
“They need to get out of their inferiority complex,” says Meghnath. “In one generation, I can promise you, things will change. Look at Dalit cinema today [Masaan, Sairat, Pariyerum Perumal, Fandry, for example]. There is a lot of change. It will happen in tribal cinema too.”
(Shamya Dasgupta writes on sports & cinema. He has curated and edited the book Ritwik Ghatak-An Anthology)



