Who's Afraid Of The BJP?

Updated on:
Published at:

A belligerent saffron brigade goes full throttle ahead with aggressive Hindutva

Whos Afraid Of The BJP?
Who's Afraid Of The BJP?

Aggression defined the mood. As Acharya Dharmendra stood up to read out the draft resolution at a closed-door meeting of the marg darshak mandal of the vhp, expressing anguish over the killings of an Australian missionary and his two sons in Orissa, he was shouted down by his own saffron-clad brethren. 'Why are we expressing anguish and pain? Why are we praying for the family of the Christian missionary?' thundered vhp sants from Chinmayanand to Ram Swaroop Vadanti. The draft resolution was promptly aborted. Instead, a one-line resolution was read out to the waiting journalists: 'No one has the right to resort to violence for religion.'

Just another behind-the-curtains scene inside the vhp which loudly announces that any attempt by the doves in the Sangh parivar to mellow down the Hindutva campaign in response to universal criticism won't be tolerated by the hawks. Let Atal Behari Vajpayee and his ilk observe fasts to express their disapproval of the attacks on the minority, let him read out messages to the nation requesting tolerance, the vhp and its saffron brigade isn't in a mood to listen.

If the prime minister and his coalition partners thought that issuing a joint statement criticising 'certain elements' for 'undermining the prestige' of the government would be enough to successfully restrain the loose cannons of the rss family, they were grossly mistaken. The finger-wagging was in vain: the statement, carrying bjp president Kushabhau Thakre's signature, has not curbed a bellicose rss.

On the contrary, the vhp's militant leadership ridicules the efforts to pacify them by a government led by their own ideological sibling. Says Acharya Giriraj Kishore, 'Let him (Vajpayee) restrain his allies first. In a democracy no one can stop anyone from speaking: I didn't even know about that joint statement, you can understand how seriously we take it. I don't think it will affect us.' The message comes through with force and clarity: We waited and watched patiently and didn't utter a word against the government. Not any longer.

But it's a painful dilemma for even the vhp and rss. After all, it was a dream come true for the Sangh parivar when Vajpayee was sworn in as prime minister. He was the 'pleasant face' of the rssóas bjp general secretary K.N. Govindacharya once commented - projected as prime minister before the general elections. And despite the longstanding Atal-Advani tiff, nobody in the Sangh parivar spoke against Vajpayee. Not openly, at any rate.

That civility seems to have melted away. Sangh parivar loudmouths now openly ridicule and criticise the very same man and party they once stood behind. A full-scale attack was launched on Vajpayee by none other than Dattopant Thengari, a senior rss stalwart who is the founder in-charge of what is now India's biggest trade union, the Bharatiya Mazadoor Sangh. As a leader of the Swadeshi Jagaran Manch - another outfit floated by the rss -Thengari challenged the Vajpayee government at Delhi's Jantar Mantar during a dharna. Even before Thengari's onslaught, fellow saffron hardliner Moropant Pingle had talked of dumping the bjp when the party faced a complete rout in three states. But then, the Sangh has made it clear time and again that no government or individual has guaranteed permanent holy cow status. Anything can be sacrificed at the altar of the 'ultimate goal'.

The rank and file rose to the cue that had been given by the luminaries of Hindutva. A senior journalist and former leader of the rss' students' wing, the Akhil Bharatiya Vidyarthi Parishad (abvp), called Vajpayee 'the most useless (nikamma) prime minister in the last 50 years' at the abvp's annual conclave in Mumbai last month. When bjp general secretary K.N. Govindacharya stepped up to the dais, he said: 'Minus the words my predecessor used, I fully agree with him.' That holds up a ruthlessly accurate mirror to what the Sangh's 'pleasant face' now looks like to the organisation. Even Madan Lal Khurana used this

incident to project himself as a Vajpayee supporter after he resigned from the Cabinet.

If the bjp is beginning to look helpless, that's because it has very little mass base on its own. This is one political party without even its own students' organisation. One of the bjp's top leaders, on deputation from the rss, once told Outlook: 'What does the bjp have barring the Bharatiya Janata Yuva Morcha? No trade union, no students' wing. Whatever is there belongs to the rss.'

A rift in the parivar, say hardliners, is not without precedent. Many find it hard to resist offering analogies from epics like the Mahabharata to put a gloss on their attack on Vajpayee and his government. Reiterating the vhp's vow to 'fight for Hindutva', Acharya Giriraj Kishore says: 'We are Hindus. We shall fight against Kauravas, whosoever they may be. Leave aside the parivar, when it comes to fighting for the dharma, we are prepared to fight even with our father. Didn't Prahlad fight with his father?' The acharya's views leave little scope for the Vajpayee government to broker peace with the rss hawks.

The vhp is also peeved at the manner in which the coalition government has put the 'burning issues of Hindutva' on the backburner. In clear disapproval of the 'Agenda of Governance' agreed upon by the government allies, Giriraj Kishore retorts: 'Hamare sab mudde murde bana diye jaate hein (All issues important to us have been made dead issues).'

The acharya's statement shows that the vhp is not yet reconciled to the fact that Vajpayee's coalition government agreed to set aside three key issues - Ram Janmabhoomi, Article 370 and the uniform civil code - under pressure from its 'secular' coalition partners. And with Big Brother - the rss - on its right side, an emboldened vhp has decided not to 'compromise' by keeping quiet. In the changed circumstances, the vhp will go full throttle ahead with its agenda of aggressive Hindutva. Mahant Avaidyanath, leading light of the Ram temple agitation and a vhp sant, told Outlook: 'We are not going to give up the issues of Ram temple, cow slaughter and common civil code. In muddon ko ham chhodenge nahin, yeh hamaare astitva ka prashn hai (It's a question of our existence).' Going a step further than Acharya Giriraj Kishore, the Mahant said: 'We helped the bjp hoping that these issues will be sorted out. But that never happened.'

Against this backdrop, the Sangh parivar doesn't seem terribly convinced with prime minister Vajpayee's contention that the government should not be dictated to, and that it should have the ultimate right to governance. Says Kishore bluntly: 'Agar sarkar sarkar hai to janata bhi phir janata hai (If the government is after all the government, then the people are also after all the people).' The implication hangs in the air: if the government is free to take decisions, then the people are also free to criticise.

The symbolism is getting more and more loaded but, unlike their swadeshi counterparts, the vhp is still refraining from making public speeches against the prime minister or the government. So far so good. But if the mood at the dharma sansad is any indication, then this might yield in order to launch a broadside against 'whoever comes in the way of Hindutva'.

Read all the latest breaking news on Outlook India and stay updated with top stories from India, Entertainment, Education, and around the world.

Tags

    ×