Are Indians Ageing Differently? Inside IISc's BHARAT Study

Updated on:
Published at:

Why India needs its own health benchmarks, what early screening reveals and why the secret to longevity may lie in some good old-fashioned advice

Professor Deepak Saini, Indian Institute of Science (IISc), Bengaluru
Professor Deepak Saini, Indian Institute of Science (IISc), Bengaluru
Summary of this article
  • India needs its own health benchmarks: Western standards may not fully reflect Indian biology, lifestyles and diversity.

  • Healthy Indians are surprisingly hard to find: Only about 25–30% of those screened meet the study’s healthy-participant criteria.

  • India’s diversity matters: Diet, environment and lifestyle vary widely, making a larger national database essential.

  • Traditional wisdom has value, but needs scientific validation: Yoga, movement and fermented foods may hold longevity lessons, while Ayurveda requires rigorous evidence.

  • Environment is a major concern: Clean air, water, nutritious food, sleep and social connections can strongly influence healthy ageing.

  • Longevity isn’t about pushing harder: The goal is not peak performance, but staying healthy, mobile and independent for longer.

Are Indians ageing differently? Or are we simply measuring Indian bodies against Western standards that may not tell the whole story?

Professor Deepak Saini of the Indian Institute of Science (IISc), Bengaluru, is trying to find answers through the BHARAT Baseline study, part of the Longevity India Initiative. The research aims to establish health benchmarks for Indians, taking into account age, gender, geography and lifestyle.

In an exclusive conversation with Outlook, he discusses the surprising difficulty of finding healthy Indians, the wisdom of our grandmothers and why treating our bodies like racing cars may not be the smartest route to longevity.

Q.

What prompted the BHARAT study? Why does India need its own longevity research?

A.

Prof. Deepak Saini: It began with a surgeon friend in the US who jokingly called me his "inflamed Indian friend". He pointed out that Indians frequently have low vitamin D and B12, high cholesterol, elevated inflammatory markers, low muscle mass and greater visceral fat. By Western standards, many of us appear unhealthy!

That made me wonder whether Western health benchmarks are necessarily appropriate for Indians. We lack reliable baseline values for many biological parameters. Everyone wants to discover new disease biomarkers, but how can we interpret them without knowing what constitutes normal health?

The BHARAT Baseline study aims to create a repository of health data from healthy Indians across different ages, genders and regions. Think of it as building India's own biological reference library.

Q.

Are Indians biologically ageing differently? What have you discovered so far and what have been the challenges during your study?

A.

Prof. Deepak Saini: We cannot conclude that yet. First, we need good data. Interestingly, one of our biggest challenges is finding healthy people! Among every 100 individuals screened, only about 25 to 30 meet our criteria for being free of conditions such as diabetes, hypertension and other significant illnesses. Beyond 60, finding eligible participants becomes even harder. These are screening observations, not estimates for India's entire population.

The second challenge is India's extraordinary diversity. Food, culture and environmental exposures change dramatically between states, sometimes even neighbouring districts.

So far, we have collected over 2,000 samples in Karnataka and hope to collect a similar number in Gujarat. But findings from one region cannot automatically represent the whole country. Actually, India needs a much larger effort to understand its biological diversity.

Q.

Could our traditional food habits and wellness practices hold lessons for longevity?

A.

Prof. Deepak Saini: In many ways, today's longevity narrative is what my grandmother used to say! Think about it. Yoga emphasised flexibility and movement. Traditional Indian exercisebuilt strength. Plant-based diets and fermented foods have been part of our culture for generations. From lassi and dhokla to pakhalabhata in Odisha, fermented foods were around long before probiotics became fashionable.

Ayurveda also emphasised building resilience and strengthening the body's capacity to cope with illness. Now the world is rediscovering these ideas and marketing them as wellness innovations. But there is an important distinction. Traditional knowledge deserves scientific investigation, not blind acceptance. Ashwagandha, triphala and other preparations are increasingly popular, but we need rigorous evidence about their benefits and limitations. Our heritage offers interesting possibilities. Science must establish what actually works.

Q.

You mention the genome, exposome and phenome as key factors influencing ageing. Which of these puts Indians at a disadvantage?

A.

Prof. Deepak Saini: The exposome, which is essentially the environment we live in is where we Indians are at a significant disadvantage. Your genome is the genetic information you inherit, while your phenome reflects how your body responds to the interaction between your genes and environment.

We cannot change the genes we are born with, but we can certainly influence our environment. And that is where Indians are at a disadvantage.

Look at Japan. They recognised the importance of clean air, safe water, nutritious food and healthy surroundings long ago. Alkaline water, clean and healthy food is standard in Japan while we in India are still struggling with these basics.

And remember, good food does not mean rich or expensive food. It means food with high nutritional value. Add to that clean air, safe water, less noise, meaningful social connections and a sense of purpose. The problem is that these choices are not equally available to everyone. The affluent can increasingly control their surroundings, but much of India cannot.

Q.

Everyone seems obsessed with pushing harder, working longer and exercising more. Is that really the secret to longevity?

A.

Prof. Deepak Saini: First, fix what is bothering you. It could be dental inflammation, digestive trouble or persistent pain. Address existing medical problems before jumping into intensive exercise or fashionable diets. Then focus on the basics: muscle mass, mobility, nutritious food, sleep, exercise and social connections. There are no shortcuts.

But don't push yourself unnecessarily. I compare the body to a sophisticated automobile. Drive your car at 150 kilometres an hour every day and it may perform beautifully, but wear and tear increases. Every machine has an optimal operating range.

Why should our bodies be different? People work all day, rush to the gym and then go partying. Constantly accelerating, braking and revving up. How long can that continue? And why compete all the time? Most of us aren't training for Olympic medals! Everybody wants the performance of a flashy German car, the reliability of a Japanese car and the running costs of an Indian car. How is that going to work?

The idea is not to push yourself to the limit every day. It is to remain healthy, mobile and independent for as long as possible.

×