Reducing materialistic value orientation in business schools requires shifting the educational paradigm from economic maximisation to humanistic sufficiency and spiritual intelligence. Research indicates that while business environments often reinforce extrinsic goals like wealth and status, these values are strongly linked to lowered well-being, increased anxiety, and reduced self-actualisation among students. To counter this, institutions must integrate spiritual values not as religious dogma but as core frameworks for ethical leadership, creativity, and holistic health.
Placement Season Meets a Conference
Walk into the placement cell of almost any business school during recruitment season, and the air is thick with one quantifiable metric: the package. For generations, management education has run on an unspoken consensus that the purpose of an enterprise—and of the executive who steers it—is economic maximisation. Wealth, status, and upward mobility were not by-products of a career. They were the curriculum.
From 4 to 7 February 2027, a different conversation will take place in Jamshedpur. Hosted by the Centre for Spirituality & Human Development at XLRI Jamshedpur, in collaboration with the MSR India Chapter and the Academy of Management Community Accelerator Program, the International Conference on Spiritual Intelligence in Leadership will convene scholars, business leaders, practitioners, and students around one unifying theme: cultivating inner wisdom for compassionate and effective decision-making.
The invitation goes well beyond theoretical debate. Participants are called to share research, case studies, and lived organisational practices proving that economic vitality and human flourishing are not mutually exclusive.
The Problem on the Table: A Race With No Finish Line
When the finish line is always another zero on a pay slip, the race never ends. The cost falls quietly on students themselves—in heightened anxiety, eroded well-being, and a thinning sense of purpose. Future leaders are burning out before they even step into the corporate arena.
Economics textbooks introduce a familiar character: homo economicus, the rational maximiser. His business-school cousin might be called homo materialis—the student for whom package, rank, and title stop being tools and quietly harden into identity. He is not greedy by nature; he has simply been trained, semester after semester, to read every choice through a single lens: What will this add to my number?
Max Weber saw this trap over a century ago. In The Protestant Ethic and the Spirit of Capitalism (1905), he described the "iron cage"—systems of efficiency and calculation that begin as means to a good life, then solidify into a structure that holds people captive. His darkest fear was a world of "specialists without spirit". Today’s placement season is a modern iron cage. Those who chase the package are not villains; they are simply acting rationally inside the architecture built for them.
That cage is sustained by a tight market loop. Students and families invest heavily in a management degree and seek a visible return, with the salary package serving as the easiest figure to count. Recruiters supply offers; schools, judged by rankings on placement outcomes, supply whatever lifts those numbers. Competition tightens the loop further. Economists call rank and relative pay positional goods—valued largely by comparison. If a classmate’s offer rises, mine feels smaller, even when nothing in my own life has changed. In a hyper-competitive ecosystem, nobody can step off the treadmill alone without feeling left behind.
That is precisely why seating academia and industry together in Jamshedpur matters. When both ends of the market share one room, each can begin sending a different signal:
A market supplies what it is asked for. Change the question being asked, and the supply inevitably follows.
From Maximisation to Sufficiency
The educational paradigm at the heart of the conference moves from endless economic maximisation to humanistic sufficiency and spiritual intelligence (SQ). Crucially, this is not about bringing religious dogma into the lecture hall. Spiritual values are approached as secular foundations for ethical leadership, creativity, and holistic health. If IQ gets a manager hired and EQ helps them lead a team, SQ answers a far more urgent question: What is the work actually for?
Forward-looking institutions are already weaving philosophical inquiry and inner development into their curricula around four transformative pillars:
From Ṛtam to Radical Responsibility: Instead of framing the market as a zero-sum battlefield, students encounter ṛtam—the Indian concept of cosmic order and ecological interconnectedness. Karma is stripped of fatalism and recast as radical responsibility: lucidity in action paired with emotional maturity in accepting outcomes beyond one’s control.
Gross Domestic Happiness Over Salary Maximisation: Human values operate like a seesaw. Press down on intrinsic, self-transcendent goals such as community contribution and personal growth, and materialistic impulses naturally rise less—fostering organisational citizenship driven by inner satisfaction rather than external applause.
Beyond the Spreadsheet: Analytical rigour alone cannot forge moral courage. Practices like meditation, dialogue circles, and voice and drama therapy help students connect with their authentic selves, sharpening intuitive thinking and ethical judgment.
Detoxifying the Learning Ecosystem: True change is structural—shielding campuses from aggressive consumerist messaging, replacing purely financial yardsticks like GDP with holistic well-being indices, and designing fieldwork that confronts ambiguity and social inequality firsthand.
From Catharsis to Transformation: Learning by Living It
Experiential learning passes through the whole person: do something real, feel it, reflect on it, and let it reshape how you act. While the traditional case method often leaves the student a detached spectator, fieldwork, live projects, and dialogue circles place them squarely inside human reality. Four distinct stages mark how such experiences take root:
Catharsis: Borrowed from Greek drama, this is an emotional release—a clearing out. A student who finally voices the fear of falling behind or the quiet envy of a peer’s offer feels lighter. Yet relief alone is a passing moment, not lasting change.
Disorienting Dilemma: As transformative learning theorist Jack Mezirow observed, deep change begins when lived experience refuses to fit our existing assumptions—such as a week of immersive fieldwork that redefines what "success" looks like.
Paradigm Shift: Here, the frame itself transforms, much as philosopher Thomas Kuhn described in science. The guiding question shifts from "How do I win?" to "What is enough, and for whom?"
Transcendence: The boundaries of the self widen to embrace something larger—a community, an ecology, the interconnected order that ṛtam names.
Without reflection, catharsis fades. Without lived experience, a paradigm shift remains a slogan.
Finding the Balance Point
A materialistic environment overpowers because it is ambient—woven into placements, rankings, peer chatter, and social feeds. Individual willpower rarely outlasts an ecosystem, which is why balance must be designed into both the programme and a student's daily habits.
This does not mean abandoning ambition. It means the salary scale stops being the only scale: the package becomes one measure beside learning, health, relationships, and contribution, and a personally defined "enough" replaces endless "more". Three simple practices help anchor this shift: asking "Enough for what?" before every major career choice; keeping a second ledger of what a role gives and takes beyond money; and maintaining one recurring reflective practice—a dialogue circle or a journal—long enough for the new frame to hold.
What the Room Can Carry Out
As the corporate world navigates climate disruption, technological upheaval, and deep social polarisation, clever financial engineering will no longer suffice. By uniting classrooms and boardrooms around spiritual intelligence and humanistic sufficiency, the XLRI Jamshedpur conference seeks to nurture the inner core that is the true source of creativity, health, and happiness.
The alternative on offer is a different measure of leadership altogether: not how much a person accumulates, but how much stability and well-being they sustain for the world around them. In a placement season obsessed with the package, that may be the most radical line item of all.
About the Author: Fr. Dr. Joseph Mathew, S.J., is an Assistant Professor at XLRI – Xavier School of Management, Jamshedpur, holding a DPsych in Counselling Psychology from Glasgow Caledonian University (GCU), UK, an MSc in Clinical Psychology from Bangor University, UK, and an MSc in Child and Adolescent Mental Health from King’s College London, UK. An academic and practitioner, his work focuses on organizational behavior, business ethics, workplace spirituality, and mental health.
Disclaimer: The views and opinions expressed in this article are those of the author(s) and do not necessarily reflect the official policy or position of the publisher. While every effort has been made to ensure the accuracy of the information, the publisher is not responsible for any errors or omissions, or for the results obtained from the use of this information.



