Advertisement
Wednesday, Dec 01, 2021
Outlook.com
Outlook.com
The Freedom Series I Siddiq Wahid

Revolutions Can Be So Very Bloody

The last two years of BJP-led governance in India has the feel of that “revolution” being at hand.

Revolutions Can Be So Very Bloody
Revolutions Can Be So Very Bloody
outlookindia.com
2016-02-20T14:43:18+05:30

There is a telling passage in Gary Bass’s book, The Blood Telegram. In as early as 1969, frustrated by the interlocutory spirit and cumbersome rules of democracy, Indira Gandhi mused that “Sometimes I wish …we had a real revolution–like France or Russia–at the time of independence.”  Her meaning is clear -- India’s governance paradigm needed to shift and settle, once and for all, the ambiguities of democratic rule. Six years later she declared Emergency rule.

The last two years of BJP-led governance in India has the feel of that “revolution” being at hand. What is at stake is India’s identity from being an avowed liberal-secular polity to an unapologetically religious-nationalist one. In that context, 2014 was not so much a “Modi wave” as it was a popular tide reflecting the frustrations of India’s 1950s generation who were at a loss to explain her lack of salience in world affairs, insulting for the world’s second most populous, at 1.2 billion, state.

The multiple legacies of this country’s ancient philosophies, arts and sciences (the plurals are important) seem to have failed the fledgling nation-state: fifty per cent of the population is bereft of toilets; large sections of its minorities are under attack for their beliefs and life-ways; its foreign relations with the neighborhood are ambiguous, troubled; and its truly poor are without relief.

The overt march towards the goal of a Hindu nationalist country began with the 1992 demolition of Babri Masjid. It was under a Congress government. It was confirmed in 2014. In the event, the BJP regime’s strategy has been to glorify India’s majority religion, transform that advantage into a case for majoritarian rule and brand as anti-national everyone who resists it.

But the BJP may find that the JNU debacle, all the more audacious for having begun over Kashmir, is the tip of the iceberg of the resistance to its intent. It recalls the student revolution of the 1960s in Europe and America which arguably changed the course of their histories. Indeed, the BJP may have brought India to its French-and-Russian-moment, its “real revolution” in Indira Gandhi’s words.

It is both exhilarating and scary to contemplate. The first invigorates because those revolutions spelt real change; the second has menacing overtones because revolutions can be so very bloody.


(Siddiq Wahid is the former vice-chancellor, Islamic University of Science and Technology, Kashmir)

(The views expressed in the Freedom Series are personal and do not necessarily reflect the views of 'Outlook' magazine or its journalists.)

Advertisement

Outlook Newsletters

Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement

Read More from Outlook

Five Powerful Indian-Americans Rocking Silicon Valley, Parag Agrawal Latest Addition

Five Powerful Indian-Americans Rocking Silicon Valley, Parag Agrawal Latest Addition

As Parag Agrawal becomes the CEO of Twitter, the Indian diaspora's representation in the tech giants of America, especially the companies in Silicon Valley gets a new badge.

Omicron Scare: All You Need To Know About India's New Travel Rules Effective From Today

Omicron Scare: All You Need To Know About India's New Travel Rules Effective From Today

Health Ministry has separated travellers coming from Omicron Variant 'Countries at-risk' from other international travelers. Check the list here, along with other guidelines.

Man United, IPL Big Boys, Sydney Sixers Enter UAE T20 League

Man United, IPL Big Boys, Sydney Sixers Enter UAE T20 League

Lancer Capital has made its first-ever historic foray into cricket by acquiring a franchise in the UAE T20 league. The ECB has already roped in IPL teams like MI, DC and KRR.

Omicron: Should Pregnant Women Be Worried About New Covid-19 Mutations?

Omicron: Should Pregnant Women Be Worried About New Covid-19 Mutations?

Amid the emergence of the Omicron variant, researchers in France say vaccination may be useful to protect women and their babies against Covid-19.

Advertisement