Australia’s final 11 for the big matches in the World Cup is far from clear. The injury to Shane Warne and the selector’s decision to forget the Waugh twins has left them in a dilemma. To solve the problem, they’ve decided to go the all-rounder route and selected Andrew Symonds, Brad Hogg and Shane Watson. All are useful enthusiastic cricketers, but none of them pass my all-rounders test and that is, they must be good enough to hold down a spot on one skill alone. Too often all-rounders are chosen because they can bat and bowl a little, and it’s hoped this will be enough to warrant selection. Unfortunately, it very rarely is and when the crunch comes these "all-rounders" are found wanting.