The issue in question: amendments to the Prevention of Disqualification Act, 1959, which incorporated 56 posts to be exempted from the list of offices of profit. Kalam, after "wide-ranging judicial and legal consultations", had asked the government whether the bill had a "comprehensive criteria for the just, fair and reasonable application (of the law) across the states and Union territories in a clear and transparent manner"; and questioned the "soundness and propriety" of making it applicable with retrospective effect.