56. In the totality of circumstances adduced frommaterial on record, the judgment under challenge appears to us to be an immatureassessment of material on record which is self-contradictory, based onmisreading of material and unsustainable. We find that Beena Ramani hasidentified Sidhartha Vashisht @ Manu Sharma, Amardeep Singh Gil, Alok Khanna andVikas Yadav to be the persons present at the Tamarind Cafe at the time of theincidence. She also saw Manu Sharma firing the fatal shot which hit Jessica Lal.Her testimony finds corroboration from the testimony of Malini Ramani and GeorgeMailhot.