Advertisement
X

In Combat Mode

Vajpayee targets the Sangh, but is he tempting fate?

The targets had never been clearer; the shower of arrows seldom so thick or so accurate. The venue: the prime minister's house in Delhi, and Vajpayee was cracking the whip.

As the coordination committee meeting of the coalition partners in Delhi played out on February 2, bjp president Kushabhau Thakre's countenance, said a participant, mirrored his party's predicament. Speaker after speaker castigated the attempts of Sangh affiliates to ruin the prospects and image of the government led by 'their man' Atal Behari Vajpayee.

But unlike Thakre, Vajpayee didn't appear to have misgivings. It was an aggressive prime minister, aided by his coalition managers, who seized the momentótaking on the rss and rapping the allies sharply on the knuckles in one swoop.

The joint statement signed by the bjp and its allies made it clear that the Sangh parivar was in the line of fire. 'Negative utterances and positions by certain elements perceived to be close to the nucleus of our coalition, bjp, have undermined the prestige of the government. This creates confusion and dismay among the people...more than anything else it is these that have adversely affected the image of our government.' There was no room for doubt: 'The bjp, the core of our alliance, shall make every effort to ensure that the prestige and cohesiveness of the coalition are not diluted by organisations belonging to its ideological fraternity.'

Earlier at the meet, others had pointed out that certain allies were not helping matters by going public with complaints. The statement duly snubbed troublesome allies: 'No constituent of the ruling alliance shall publicly voice their differences/opposition to any policy or action of the government.'

That pill was sweetened by placebos intended to 'calm' allies like the Trinamul Congress and the tdp. On February 4, the Cabinet cleared some of the railway projects Mamata Banerjee had demanded as part of the 'Bengal package'. And it requisitioned a National Development Council meeting on February 19 where chief ministers can discuss the price hike. An earlier move by the Centre that opposed the Tamil Nadu government's setting up of special courts to try corruption cases against J. Jayalalitha is also part of the policy a party spokesman dubbed 'coalition dharma in action'.

But the real problem is, according to a bjp leader, the 'overbearing attitude of the Sangh'. Vajpayee fired another salvo in Lucknow last week, declaring that he did not agree with the contention that conversions were taking place through forcible means. He went even further: 'I did not call for a debate on conversions; only a dialogue.' He reiterated that there was no move to tamper with the Constitution.

Advertisement

Vajpayee has evidently realised that the more probable flashpoint lies with the Sangh and its supporters in the bjp. That he has waited for nearly a year before this showdown, say his supporters, has helped: 'It has exposed the agenda of the hardliners and made clear that it is they who seem interested in letting the Congress in.'

The reaction from the Sangh was swift. And uncompromising as it goes head to head with Vajpayee, despite the attempts of L.K. Advani to mediate. Just a day after the February 2 meet, bjp general secretary K.N. Govindacharya insisted that the Sangh's actions have not hurt the government and that the joint statement can't be read as a general condemnation of the agenda of the rss and its affiliates. He went on to articulate the rss/vhp stand on conversions, even arguing in favour of disallowing them if they 'threatened social cohesion'.

Advertisement

And in a rare public response to a newspaper article, rss general secretary H.V. Seshadri, wrote a letter to The Hindu (published on February 5): 'Conversion to Christianity ends up in their (the converts) snapping and even destroying their ancient traditional, social and cultural fabric of life and getting sucked into Western modes of life'.

bjp spokesmen J.P. Mathur and K.L. Sharma were caught in the crossfire. Said Mathur: 'We can only ask them (Sangh parivar) to listen to us but they are distinct organisations. Our only connection is a common commitment to nationalism...of course I am proud to be an rss swayamsevak.'

The tie is obviously symbiotic, as Vajpayee himself seemed to concede in the aftermath of the 'dual membership' crisis during the Janata regime in the late 1970s. Socialist leader Madhu Limaye had pointed out that the Bharatiya Jana Sangh was part of the Janata Party but its members retained allegiance to the rss. Vajpayee was under immense pressure to make a 'clean break' with the Sangh and ensure the future of non-Congress centrist politics in India. He didn't. The Indian Express reported that he said: 'The issue is resolved; there is no crisis... we are members of the rss as a social, cultural organisation.'

Advertisement

Some years later, he made an almost genteel attempt at distancing the bjp from the Sangh and its singular worldview by articulating a set of ideas, termed 'Gandhian socialism' by the media. Post-1984, however, this attempt was ruthlessly jettisoned in favour of the Hindutva/cultural nationalism thesis propounded by Advani. Vajpayee lumped it. His response to the comment that he was the 'right man in the wrong party': 'Jaye to jaye kahan?' The implication was clearódespite his disagreement with aspects of the bjp's agenda, not to mention the Sangh, his political-ideological loyalty was to them.

This, then, is the man who in the past week has upped the ante in an unprecedented fashion. But this is hardly surprising, given the situation. The vhp leadership has passed from a Dr Karan Singh to an Ashok Singhal as the organisation metamorphosed into Hindutva's sword-arm; the rss mantle rests upon Rajju Bhaiyya, Seshadri and K.S. Sudershan who have jettisoned any pretence that old gurus like Deoras and Golwalkar may have maintained of granting functional autonomy to its 'political wing'.

Advertisement

But Vajpayee knows that his place in history will be judged by the government he leads. This call to arms is the endgame rather than the start of hostilities. Even though the less charitable feel that Vajpayee is doing in the wake of the Staines murder what he should have done after December 6, 1992.

Published At:
US