Home »  Magazine »  Arts & Entertainment »  Shamitabh


More silly and stupid than profound and philosophical.


Starring: Starring: Amitabh Bachchan, Dhanush, Akshara Haasan
Directed by R. Balki
Rating: **

At the very outset, there are two things that irritate you a lot about Shamitabh. One is the in-your-face, blatant and unashamed in-film brand promotion. It’s tacky, and not even an attempt is made to integrate the products into the storyline of the film. So much so that they could as well have called this film ‘Lifeorr’ or ‘Knobuoy’ (portmanteaus of Lifebuoy and Knorr, the two major presences).

The other is to do with Amitabh Bachchan’s baritone. “Ye awaaz ek kutte ke moonh se bhi achchi lagegi,” his character says in the film. Well, not quite. A voice that has an identity and mythology of its own is difficult to accept on anyone other than the one who it truly belongs to. Especially for someone like me, who has grown up on a healthy diet of the  superstar’s ‘Angry Young Man’ movies. And Shamitabh is all about smothering this larger-than-life voice, cruelly rendering it disembodied. Which is not to diss the great, big idea of the film itself: about how stardom is a chimeric creation, cobbled together by borrowing elements from here, there and everywhere. In this case, it’s the voice of one and the face of another. It’s about how individual egos can spell doom for fame and glory and destroy the jury-rigged construct that stardom is. All fine on paper, but Balki executes it in a manner which is more silly and stupid than profound and philosophical.

A mute Dhanush wants to be a superstar. With the help of a philanthro­pic assistant director and writer Akshara Haasan, he is flown abroad for an experiment in “laryngology”, thanks to which he can talk in the voice of the alcoholic keeper of a burial ground, that is, the deep-toned Bachchan. This entire “live voice transfer technology”, which is accomplished by implanting a chip in Dhanush’s throat, feels utterly daft and dim-witted. It’s hard to take it with any amount of seriousness. Moreover, the voice-face disjunct, given the grandeur and iconicity of Big B’s voice, proves too hard to bridge.

For a film that has a mute character at the centre, Shamitabh is excessively loud. Be it the acting or the emotions, everything is pitched high—as a result of which even silences become deafening. Both Dhanush and Bachchan are forced to overact. What works are the spontaneous moments of humour. Like when Amitabh asks Dhanush his weight and then tells him that his voice is weightier. Or when Rekha (playing herself) gives Dhanush a quizzical look on hearing the voice. Has she heard it on someone else before? It’s in the wry, self-mocking humour that Amitabh comes alive. One wishes there were more of them than those drunken soliloquies. One wishes the same light touch for Dhanush as well.

It all ends at the hospital, as most of Balki’s films do. Coming out of the theatre, I couldn’t help but think of his morbid fascination with sickness, disabilities and abnormalities. Sadly, the film feels more manipulative than sensitive. And also extremely boring.

Post a Comment

You are not logged in, To comment please / Register
or use
Next Story : VII Things We Learnt Last Week
Download the Outlook ​Magazines App. Six magazines, wherever you go! Play Store and App Store
Here in Mumbai, when Faezeh Jalali presents Shikhandi: The story of In-Betweens, the story becomes a brisk, pinching satire about punishing times, then and now.
MAGAZINE April 19, 2018
Movie Review
This biopic of V.P. Sathyan, Kerala’s and India’s football team captain in the ’90s, injects a dose of adrenaline into the veins of a resurgent Kerala
MAGAZINE February 22, 2018
The musical moves from one milestone to the other interspersed with songs and commentary by Boman Irani as the voice of the British Raj.
MAGAZINE April 07, 2017
The story touches upon glamour and the cost it extracts. It's about crime, the afterlife and love...
MAGAZINE March 02, 2017
Watching it as just a movie divorced from the reality around us, Raees offers as many moments of entertainment as tedium in the second half...
MAGAZINE January 25, 2017


A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9

or just type initial letters