Advertisement
Wednesday, Dec 08, 2021
Outlook.com
opinion

Let The Numbers Speak

A caste-inclusive census can clear cobwebs, tackle malcontents

Let The Numbers Speak
Illustration by Sorit
Let The Numbers Speak
outlookindia.com
-0001-11-30T00:00:00+05:53

We do not yet know what upheavals will be caused by the old, not to say divisive, bogie of caste about to be let loose in the 2011 census. In all likelihood, it will engulf in its raging torrents the existing protagonists of the OBC brand of politics. While they have egged on the government to revive caste-based census after 80 years, the Laloos, Mulayams and Sharad Yadavs seem to have been unable to gauge its adverse effect on their own political interests. Commentators are sceptical of caste being included in the census, fearing a deluge of caste claims and counter-claims that independent India has striven to avoid, since such conflicts are deemed detrimental to our constitutional goal of a casteless society.

But since we have already walked down the road of caste-based reservation and have of late been grappling with the issue of a ‘creamy layer’ hogging the benefits over a few generations, enumerating caste in this census might provide an opportunity to understand this contentious layer with a degree of precision. The creamy layer apart, there are also faultlines between groups that benefit from reservation. An example of this is the bitter, aggressive resentment that Gujjars in Rajasthan feel against the Meenas, who have reaped benefits through their ST status. During the previous BJP regime in Rajasthan, that resentment had erupted in an agitation for ST status. The Meenas had traditionally the same standing in society as the OBC Gujjars, who found their benefits eroded when the more dominant Jats were granted OBC status in Rajasthan. The Meenas, naturally, oppose the Gujjars’ demand for ST status. In a parallel case, Muslim Gujjars in Jammu & Kashmir, who have ST status, oppose the demand of  the Paharis of the Jammu region for the same status. They think the Paharis will eat into their share of preferment.

Advertisement

Outlook Newsletters

Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement

Read More from Outlook

Aung San Suu Kyi Verdict 'Disturbing' But Will It Change India's Equation With Myanmar?

Aung San Suu Kyi Verdict 'Disturbing' But Will It Change India's Equation With Myanmar?

While India has time and again appealed for rapprochement between the democratic forces and the military, it has continued to engage with the junta in Myanmar.

Church In India Cosying Up To BJP To Protect Its Interests

Church In India Cosying Up To BJP To Protect Its Interests

What has led to this change of heart over the past few years for the Church, long seen to be anathemic to the Sangh Parivar?

Ashes, 1st Test: Cummins Steals The Show On Rain-affected Day 1

Ashes, 1st Test: Cummins Steals The Show On Rain-affected Day 1

Pat Cummins made his captaincy bow in style with a fifer at The Gabba, helping Australia dismiss England for 147. Then rain arrived.

Why AFSPA In Jammu And Kashmir Is Not Just A Defence Act

Why AFSPA In Jammu And Kashmir Is Not Just A Defence Act

Has the AFSPA become an ideological Act, a tool to revise Kashmir history? Many analysts believe so.

Advertisement