Advertisement
Thursday, Oct 28, 2021
Outlook.com

Judge Not Too Harshly

We must trust courts to usher in transparency. Pursuing transparency without that will expose judicial freedom to risk from State and market.

Judge Not Too Harshly
Illustration by Saahil
Judge Not Too Harshly
outlookindia.com
2016-09-12T15:53:00+05:30

What judges at work say and do matters for the nation. They wield enormous powers over citizens and the state. Their judicial interpretation determines the contours of our freedom and the future of human rights as well as powers and structures of governance. They increasingly co-govern the ­nation, alongside Parliament and the executive. Their interpretation of the Constitution (jurisprudence) and powers of innovation to serve the people of India (demosprudence) have showcased for the world the wonder of constitutional democracy at work in India that is Bharat.

In this context, Justice J. Chelameswar’s recent public outpourings concerning the workings of the Supreme Court’s judicial collegium are noteworthy. His lordship is reported widely as expressing shock at how there is no room allowed for democratic consultation among the five justices who constitute the collegium; it seems only the Chief Justice of India (CJI) and the next seniormost justice confer, while the other collegium members are only asked to ­say yes or no to the proposed names.

Advertisement

Outlook Newsletters

Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement

Read More from Outlook

Aryan Khan Drugs Case: Who Is KP Gosavi? NCB's Absconding 'Witness' Detained In Pune

Aryan Khan Drugs Case: Who Is KP Gosavi? NCB's Absconding 'Witness' Detained In Pune

Gosavi, said to be a 'private investigator' whose selfies with actor Shah Rukh Khan's son Aryan Khan went viral after the NCB arrested him on October 2, had been on the run.

Haryana: 3 Women Farmers Returning From Protest Killed After Truck Hits Them At Tikri

Haryana: 3 Women Farmers Returning From Protest Killed After Truck Hits Them At Tikri

The accident, which also left two women injured, took place when the women were waiting for an autorickshaw to go to Bahadurgarh railway station after attending the farmers' protest.

'I Am Not A Racist': De Kock Apologises, Will Take The Knee

'I Am Not A Racist': De Kock Apologises, Will Take The Knee

Quinton de Kock has apologised for not taking the knee with his other South African teammates during the T20 World Cup match against the West Indies. The South African wicket-keeper batsmen said it was a "misunderstanding."

Explainer | Why India Celebrates Vigilance Awareness Week Every Year

Explainer | Why India Celebrates Vigilance Awareness Week Every Year

This year, the theme of the Vigilance Week celebrations is 'Independent India @ 75: Self Reliance with Integrity'.

Advertisement