Advertisement
Sunday, Oct 17, 2021
Outlook.com

Ayodhya Verdict: How Different Is The Supreme Court Decision From Allahabad High Court Judgement Of 2010?

On November 9, the Supreme Court delivered a 1,045-page judgment on the title suit of the land where the Babri Masjid once stood. Outlook spoke to legal luminaries to seek their views on the Ayodhya verdict.

Ayodhya Verdict: How Different Is The Supreme Court Decision From Allahabad High Court Judgement Of 2010?
Ayodhya Verdict: How Different Is The Supreme Court Decision From Allahabad High Court Judgement Of 2010?
outlookindia.com
2019-11-15T15:49:38+05:30

What are the key legal takeaways from the 1,045-page judgment delivered by the Supreme Court on November 9? And can the ­verdict on the title suit to the land where the Babri mosque once sto  od be challenged? Outlook asks former additional solicitor ­general and ­Supreme Court lawyer Sidharth Luthra, NALSAR University of Law vice chancellor Faizan Mustafa, Supreme Court lawyer Vikas Singh and advocate Eijaz Maqbool, who represented a Muslim litigant in this case.

1. How different is the Supreme  Court verdict in spirit from the ­Allahabad High Court judgment of 2010, which was criticised for its attempt at conciliation?

Faizan Mustafa: The Allahabad High Court judgment was wrong on the law as it was not a partition suit and relief ­cannot be given to a party whose suit is barred by limitation. But the judgment was good as it tried to preserve our composite ­culture at the disputed site. The...

Advertisement

Outlook Newsletters

Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement

Read More from Outlook

Two Vendors From UP, Bihar Shot Dead By Militants In J&K

Two Vendors From UP, Bihar Shot Dead By Militants In J&K

Police claim 13 terrorists have been killed in Jammu and Kashmir in nine encounters over the last nine days.

In Ongoing Poonch Encounter, Bodies Of Two Missing Soldiers Recovered, Toll Rises To Nine

In Ongoing Poonch Encounter, Bodies Of Two Missing Soldiers Recovered, Toll Rises To Nine

According to the Army, the bodies of a jawan and the JCO were recovered during the search operation on October 16.

SAFF 2021: Chhetri Equals Messi Feat As India Thrash Nepal To Win 8th Title

SAFF 2021: Chhetri Equals Messi Feat As India Thrash Nepal To Win 8th Title

India crushed Nepal 3-0 to win their 8th SAFF title, thanks to goals from Sunil Chhetri, Suresh Wangjam and Sahal Abdul Samad.

Kerala: Six Dead, 12 Missing As Heavy Rains Cause Flash Floods And Landslides

Kerala: Six Dead, 12 Missing As Heavy Rains Cause Flash Floods And Landslides

Several people have been injured and displaced. Dams in many districts are nearing full capacity. Small towns and villages in the hilly areas are totally cut off.

Advertisement