Home »  Magazine »  National »  How Many Seas...

How Many Seas...

A good man goes, head held high. Ethical cleansing in reverse?

How Many Seas...
Nilotpal Baruah
How Many Seas...

The many people telephoning or trooping in to meet Justice Nitte Santosh Hegde after he put in his papers as Karnataka’s Lokayukta, on June 23, are either trying to persuade him to stay back and fight the system or are congratulating him for effortlessly giving up the much-coveted chair, which affords him moral authority even over a chief minister. Among those who have urged him to continue are Union home minister P. Chidambaram and Opposition leaders in the state. Among those who have congratulated him are two former chief justices of India and an octogenarian Gandhian. Justice Hegde appears more inclined to accept the congratulations than to heed advice on reversing his decision. He does not sound stubborn, but understands the importance of stepping down. And to anxious questions about who might replace him, he has a ready line from history: “People asked, ‘After Nehru, who?’ But we got a very competent man after him.”

Justice Hegde chuckles when it is suggested that he is perhaps now the most famous Bunt (a prosperous land-owning community of  coastal Karnataka) after Aishwarya Rai and Shilpa Shetty. “Why after them?” he retorts playfully. He is aware, of course, of the hype surrounding him; also his phenomenal success and now the aura of a martyr that has brought him stardom.

But people who want Hegde to stay on—essentially because he is competent and his personal integrity is beyond doubt—find it difficult to understand his paradoxical stance against politics. “How do we save democracy if we fuel such an anti-politics imagination?” asks one of his senior colleagues. “What is the alternative ideal we should chase? Why is he creating a cynical, non-participatory ethos among the people? Why is he fuelling public euphoria with a new upgrade to his martyrdom?” They are surprised, and say he is erring in putting his private convictions over public exigencies. But this is what Justice Hegde says: “I have seen politics from close quarters. I have no faith in it. It is a dirty game. I have no hesitation in saying that. I don’t think anybody can be useful there by being honest.”

Well-connected Sushma Swaraj with the Reddy brothers

Hegde’s predecessor, Justice Venkatachala, joined the BJP after he demitted office, but Justice Hegde is clear that isn’t the route he will take. “My no to politics is firm. This is not something I’m telling you today. I said this even when a former chief minister, whom I indicted in my mining report, alleged that I had an understanding with Yediyurappa. I had said then that if I contest an election, don’t give me a vote, give me a slap. I stand by it.” This prompts another colleague of his to say that he is occupying a “nebulous middle” after segregating the public and the state.

The web through which politics and business interests feed each other is something Justice Hegde is wary of.

Justice Hegde is certainly not naive. He does understand that these two categories are not water-tight, but he goes to the other extreme. Perhaps his position at present stems from a deep personal hurt. In fact, he indicts the entire public. He believes that the higher strata of society want corruption to exist because they are the ones who benefit from it. “They invest their money power in politicians and bureaucrats and in return get huge dividends.”  The middle class, he argues, suffers all of this, complains about it but does not want to do anything. “They don’t want to be dragged to the courts.” And the poor are submissive to corruption. “They have to pay even for their basic necessities. I read somewhere that in Karnataka every third person with a BPL card has to pay a bribe for drinking water. Can there be anything worse than this?” he asks.

People who have known Hegde’s father—Justice Kawadoor Sadananda Hegde—are surprised by his revulsion for politics. After quitting the Supreme Court in 1973 to protest the supersession by a junior judge (Justice A.N. Ray) for the post of chief justice, the senior Hegde had joined the Jayaprakash Narayan movement during the Emergency. Later, he contested on a Janata Party ticket from the Bangalore South constituency against Congressman and former chief minister Kengal Hanumanthaiah and was elected to the sixth Lok Sabha, in which he also held the Speaker’s post. After stepping down, he even became the national vice-president of the BJP. Prior to this, he was a member of the upper house of Parliament in the ’50s. “My father was a Congressman until certain developments happened in that party. He always wore khadi and he was opposed to the communal politics of the Jan Sangh,” insists Justice Hegde.

Earlier, Justice Hegde himself has been close to non-Congress governments in the state and Centre. When Ramakrishna Hegde (not related) was chief minister, he was an advocate-general, a post he quit when Hegde resigned and S.R. Bommai took over. He was additional solicitor-general of India between 1989 and 1990, when V.P. Singh was prime minister, and then became solicitor-general between 1998 and 1999, when Vajpayee was prime minister, before being appointed to the Supreme Court. In 2006, the H.D. Kumaraswamy-led coalition government made him Lokayukta. “After my father quit the SC, he could not work in any court, but he advised me to file applications for the detenus held in the Bangalore Central Jail during the Emergency. Through me, he came in contact with L.K. Advani, Vajpayee, S.N. Misra and other leaders,” he says.

For those floating a conspiracy theory about Justice Hegde timing his resignation to embarrass the Yediyurappa government, these facts may come as a surprise. People who have known Justice Hegde for a long time confirm that he is not given to strategy. “His core is sentimental. There is a childlike innocence in him,” they say. Justice Hegde somewhat adds to this perception when he says: “I have asked for my resignation to take effect two months later only to prevent a statutory deadlock; there is no other hidden motive.”

Justice Hegde has led a good life. “My wife and I have no children, but we have a close-knit family and a small circle of friends. We have travelled three-fourths of the globe together. When my practice was good, I used to travel first class. I have travelled on the Concorde some three or four times. I have stayed in the best of hotels. Between 1977 and 2006, until I became Lokayukta, I went to the US once a year. I went so frequently because I have a paraplegic brother-in-law there who lost the power of his limbs in an operation. I had promised my sister I will visit them every year. As soon as I retire, I owe her a visit.” And, of course, he promises to remain a “freelance speaker” against corruption.

Post a Comment

You are not logged in, To comment please / Register
or use
Next Story : May The Game Prevail Over Parallax Errors
Download the Outlook ​Magazines App. Six magazines, wherever you go! Play Store and App Store



A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9

or just type initial letters