It was the perfect example of a defensive team selection. Instead, India should have bitten the bullet and brought Gandhi back into the side. Opening the batting in a Test match is a specialist role. An opener must weather the new ball, see off the opposing sides fastest bowlers and set the platform for batsmen further down the order while occupying the crease for as long as possible. Had Gandhi and Laxman opened the batting together in Sydney, the Test could conceivably have been saved, perhaps even won. But the policy of caution failed on three counts. First, Prasad fell hopelessly short of the role of an opener, dismissed for 5 in the first innings and 3 in the second. Second, Kanitkar, brought in to strengthen the fragile batting, did nothing of the sort. He scored 10 in the first innings and 8 in the second. Third, and most importantly, the Test match was lost as well, when a draw or a win would have given India some measure of self-belief.