Going the extra mile
But at the Madras High Court, initial indulgence by judges to advocates demanding that proceedings be in Tamil, turned into impatience on the day the conference was inaugurated by the President in Coimbatore. The court lambasted the attempt by advocates, 20 of whom were arrested for going on a fast demanding that Tamil be declared as the official language of the court, for trying to turn the legal institution into a “political platform”. There was a partial boycott in Madurai unlike in Chennai.
In fact when Karunanidhi’s son and union minister, M K Azhagiri, met six advocates on hunger strike so that they would call it off and not ruin his father’s moment, the lawyers embarrassed him by pointing out his inability to speak in Tamil in the parliament. Azhagiri withdrew hastily, but the advocates continued agitating till the judges said enough was enough. “They (the advocates) should not indulge in hunger strikes, shouting of slogans, hold processions, display banners, distribute pamphlets or hold any other kind of demonstration or bring in persons with political affiliations to address meetings or hold any other activities except the discharge of their duties as lawyers,” said the judges granting bail to the advocates.
The irony, however, was that a day after the Madras High Court said that there was nothing to stop advocates from arguing in Tamil, only one advocate made bold to speak the language which is being celebrated at the Coimbatore conference. In fact, newly appointed Chief Justice M Yousuf Eqbal who is Bihar-born, was accommodating enough to hear brother judge D Murugesan's translation of advocate Ramesh’s argument. This is what is called going the extra mile for Tamil. But with such a huge backlog of cases for the courts to deal with, should the court’s time be utilized for non-Tamil speaking judges to be forced to rely on translations of arguments in Tamil? Besides, isn’t there a danger of something getting lost in translation?