The Supreme Court has contended the Delhi High Court judgement holding the Chief Justice of India accountable under the RTI Act would seriously impair the independence of the judiciary.
In an appeal filed before itself today, the Supreme Court registry said the judgement needs to be quashed as the judiciary not only as institution but even individual judges should be "insulated from pressures and prejudices."
"Judges under our Constitutional scheme occupy a unique position and discharge unique functions in the constitutional scheme of things. It is necessary and imperative that the conduct of the judges is not subject to ‘litigative public debate‘.
"It is respectfully submitted that the effect of the judgement of the Hon'ble High Court will seriously impair the position of the judges and the doctrine of independence of judiciary," the special leave petition filed behalf of the Supreme Court by counsel Devdatt Kamat stated.
In a path-breaking verdict, the Delhi High Court had on January 12 held that the office of the Chief Justice of India comes under the purview of the RTI Act and rejected a Supreme Court appeal, saying judicial independence is not a judge's personal privilege but a responsibility cast upon him.
In its appeal, the apex court submitted the principle of ‘Independence of the Judiciary’ entails that the judiciary is insulated from pressures and prejudices at all levels: institutionally and at individual level.
The apex court's appeal said it totally disagreed with the high court's view that the 1997 resolution of judges to declare their assets voluntarily had a legal sanctitiy.
"The concept of independence of judiciary is not only applicable vis-a-vis the judiciary at the institutional level and other branches of government but it also applies at the individual level. The result of giving legal sanctity to such resolutions would result in impeding the independence of the individual judges," the SLP said.
The observations of the High Court that the resolutions have a binding effect and have legal sanctity strikes at the root of independence of the higher judiciary at the individualistic level, the apex court argued.
It maintained disclosure of such confidential matters would go against the basic structure concept of the Constitution.
"A statute has to be read and interpreted in a manner so as to uphold the basic structure of the constitution.
In the present case, the High Court while interpreting the Right to Information under the Act with reference to the judiciary ought to have appreciated and interpreted the right under Section 2(j) in a manner which is in furtherance of the basic structure of the Constitution namely "Independence of the Judiciary," the appeal said.
"The impugned order seeks to give extra constitutional legal sanctity to Resolutions which is impermissible under the Constitutional framework. It is submitted that the same cannot be said to have a legal sanction. The sanction is moral only," the Supreme Court said.
SC Challenges HC Verdict Bringing CJI Office Under RTI
THE LATEST ISSUE
- As Assam CM, Himanta Biswa Sarma Finally Lives His Dream
- GST Exemption On Vaccine, Covid Drugs Will Make Them Costlier: FM Nirmala Sitharaman
- ‘I Would Like To Play Women Who Are Irresponsible': Konkona Sen
- Lockdown In Delhi Extended Till May 17: Arvind Kejriwal
- Tamil Nadu's New Health Minister MA Subramanian Is Also A Marathon Runner
- India In England: Prithvi Shaw Unlucky, Hardik Pandya Needs To Prove All-rounder Credentials
- Online Real Money Gaming: Why Present Is Imperfect And Future Is Tense
- For IPL Organisers, Loss Of Revenue Seems More Important Than Loss Of Lives Due To COVID
- Why Should Boys Have All The Fun? Sports For One And All!
- Why Virat Kohli Is Right And ICC Wrong: A Philosopher Looks At DRS
- Led By Debutants Why Indian Cricket Is On Top Of The World
- Cong Leader Mallikarjun Kharge Urges PM Modi To Hold All-Party Meeting
- Talks For National Alliance Of Opposition Parties To Start Soon: Raut
- YouTuber Rahul Vohra Dies Hours After Predicting His Death On Facebook
- Sikh Body Provides Oxygen Concentrators To Covid Patients
- Youth Congress President Steps Into Sonu Sood’s Shoes
- How India’s Top Sports Institution Let Covid Breach Elite Training Camps
- Lewis Hamilton Wins Record-equalling Sixth Spanish Grand Prix
- Remainder Of IPL 2021 Can't Happen In India, Says Sourav Ganguly