The Delhi High Court today declined to stay the city government's notification imposing a blanket ban on manufacture, sale, storage and display of all gutka products under the Food Safety and Standards (FSS) Act.
The court, however, issued notice to the Delhi government, the Centre through the Ministry of Health and Family Welfare and also Food Safety and Standards Authority of India
(FSSAI) and sought their response by December 11 on the plea of a city-based gutka manufacturer challenging the September 11 notification.
"Except issuing notices, we are not inclined to pass any order as the notification (of September 11) was issued (by Delhi government) on the basis of the Centre's regulations, which is not under challenge," the bench of Chief Justice D Murugesan and Justice Rajiv Sahai Endlaw said while dismissing the stay application filed by Trimuti Fragrances Private Ltd.
In its plea, the gutka manufacturer had said that the city government had issued the notification in terms of Centre's August 2011 Regulations under the Food Safety and Standards Act.
As per the 2.3.4 of the Regulations, "products (should) not to contain any substance which may be injurious to health; Tobacco and nicotine shall not be used as ingredients in any food product."
Terming the city government's notification as arbitrary, the petition had said, "The notification is arbitrary and bad in law in as much the same is ultra vires the FSS Act itself which does not confer any power to impose permanent prohibition on any food product."
Appearing for the petitioner, senior advocate A M Singhvi submitted that a central law--Cigarettes and Other tobacco Products Act 2003
(COTPA)--is already there to control tobacco products and any general regulations under the FSS Act could not supersede the special Act.
He also submitted that the food safety law did not empower the city government to issue any such regulation imposing blanket ban on gutka products.
As per the petition, "Parliament by enacting COTPA has already evinced its intent to occupy the whole field with regard to prohibition of advertisement and regulation of trade and commerce, production, supply and distribution of tobacco products.
"The notification is nothing but a colourable exercise of power in as much the government of Delhi has erroneously proceeded to prohibit a defined tobacco product under the regulation framed by SFFAI governing food products," the petition said.
The Delhi government had issued the notification banning gutka products after number of states including
Maharashtra, Rajasthan, Kerala, Punjab, Madhya Pradesh, Gujarat and Bihar announced ban on gutka products.
HC Declines to Stay Delhi Govt Notification on Gutka Ban
READ MORE IN:
THE LATEST ISSUE
- As Kashmir Reels Under Indefinite Curfew, Article 370 Scrapped, J&K Bifurcated
- Explained: What Is Article 370?
- Article 370 Increased Corruption, Gave Rise To Terrorism In J&K: Amit Shah In Rajya Sabha
- Pak PM Imran Khan Terms Abrogation Of Article 370 'Illegal And Violation Of UN Resolutions'
- 'Bold', 'Historic' and 'Monumental': BJP Leaders Hail Govt's Move on Article 370
- The Little Sleep I Get Is Filled With Nightmares About Home: Kashmiri Living In Delhi On J&K
- UAPA A Tool Of Repression, The Amendment Just Makes It Worse
- 'Kashmir Is Tense. Let's Have Tea. This Could Be The Last Time We Are Together'
- Govinda Does Not Deserve The Lampoon Over Avatar Claims
- For All Practical Purposes, BJD Is Now A Part Of NDA
- After India's Chandrayaan-2, Time To See What Other Countries Are Planning On Space Front
- New J&K Union Territory To Have Lt Gov, 7 More Assembly Seats After Delimitation
- Article 370 Scrapped: Ram Madhav Tweets Old Photo Of PM Modi, Says 'Promise Fulfilled'
- Dale Steyn, South Africa Pacer, Retires From Test Cricket
- India Briefs Foreign Envoys On Decision To Scrap Article 370, Bifurcate J&K
- Ashes: Joy Of Six For Lyon As Australia Crush England To Seize Initiative
- J&K's Head Chopped Off; Identity Lost: Congress Leader Ghulam Nabi Azad On Revoking Article 370
- SC Directs Unnao Rape Survivor To Be Airlifted To Delhi For Treatment At AIIMS
- Article 370 Scrapped: Jammu Celebrates, Calls It A 'Historic Day'