Advertisement
Saturday, Dec 04, 2021
Outlook.com
Outlook.com

''Where is China-India standoff in Ladakh leading to?''

''Where is China-India standoff in Ladakh leading to?''
outlookindia.com
1970-01-01T05:30:00+0530
''Where is China-India standoff in Ladakh leading to?''

The reported disengagement of troops and partial pull back at multiple points was a good news on Tuesday, indicating a de-escalatory trend in standoff, amidst rhetoric and escalation dynamics. It shows some usefulness of Confidence Building Measures (CBM) and established ''Maintenance of Peace and Tranquillity Agreement, 1993. It also exhibited important role of military diplomacy in resolving border issues having military implications. It is however not the end of standoff, as further talks between the two armies are to be held this week commencing from Wednesday in Hot Spring area, for easing out the situation at multiple locations including Galwan area and Pangong Tso.

Why do Standoff Happen?

China does not recognise the border agreement between British India and Tibet of 1914. In absence of any border treaty between PRC and India post-independence, both countries have own perception of Line of Actual Control (LAC) and in certain areas these perception overlap. Both sides patrol areas up to own perception of LAC; hence in overlapping areas, it is termed as transgression by opposite side. In most transgressions troops patrol and go back to their bases. In case the troops do not go back and make arrangements to stay in particular areas claiming to be their own, it leads to standoff, as the opposing side is also under compulsion to do the same, which is the case in Pongong Tso and most of the earlier standoffs along LAC. In case of Galwan valley, it''s a case of relatively fresh claims, leading to similar action by Indian troops leading to face-off.

Why a standoff happened in Ladakh?

China has developed its infrastructure up to LAC much earlier, but it wants to deny the same to India, which is only trying to catch up, to protect its sovereign territory. The trigger for this face-off in Ladakh was China''s opposition to Indian road building activity in the Finger area around the Pangong Tso Lake, the road connecting the Darbuk-Shayok-Daulat Beg Oldie in Galwan Valley. China feels that this infrastructure development will make their strategic roads and positions vulnerable and put them at disadvantage. After a few scuffles at few points along LAC earlier in May, which were cases of response to transgressions, China transgressed at multiple points with large number of troops, pitched tents and made some bunkers. Indian troops have also positioned themselves in large numbers which led to a standoffs at multiple places in Galwan Area and at Finger 4 in Pangong Tso area. This was followed by some military build-up by both side, as both sides got ready for longer standoff. Indian Army continued with infrastructure development in its own territory, during faceoff and local level talks, to support important posts like DBO and Hot spring.

What are the Complications and likely Solution?

Resolving border problem is a complicated matter because in absence of a Border Treaty or Agreement, both countries read history as it suits them. Over decades, and 22 rounds of talks, the positions have hardened, with national sentiments attached with it. The demarcation of LAC is doable, but Chinese continue to drag their feet in doing so, as they fear that it will become de facto border, forcing them to forego their claims made in 1960, including Tawang. India will not like to lose claim over Aksai Chin. Certainly this is not the first or last transgression and standoff, which will continue to happen, unless the LAC is demarcated. In long term, therefore, it will get resolved only when the political cost of not resolving it, will become higher than the cost of resolving it.

In the short term, I am sure China and India do not want a war; hence will like to resolve it by talks. The problem with standoffs is that a graceful disengagement becomes difficult, as no side wants to blink first. This incidence has shown the utility of Military Diplomacy'' in such sensitive problems. They have resolved some problems and are progressing to resolve the rest in next few meetings. India seems to be firm on ground so far, ready to protect its territory despite rhetoric, Chinese coercion and information warfare. We might need more confidence building mechanisms to avoid fist fights, as the current mechanisms have avoided bullets, but not manhandling of each other. This also has to be a subject of future talks.

(The writer is Major General S.B. Asthana,SM,VSM (Veteran). The views expressed are personal views of the author, who also retains the copyright. He can be reached at Facebook and LinkedIn, as Shashi Asthana, @asthana_shashi on twitter, on personnel sitehttps://asthanawrites.org/ email shashiasthana29@gmail.com; LinkedIn www.linkedin.com/in/shashi-asthana-4b3801a6; Youtube link

https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCl50YRTBrOCVIxDtHfhvQDQ?view_as=subscriber)

--IANS

asthana/in


Disclaimer :- This story has not been edited by Outlook staff and is auto-generated from news agency feeds. Source: IANS

More from Website

Ajaz Patel (10/119) Enters History Books Alongside Jim Laker, Anil Kumble In IND Vs NZ Test

Ajaz Patel (10/119) Enters History Books Alongside Jim Laker, Anil Kumble In IND Vs NZ Test

Ajaz Patel became only the third bowler to take all the 10 wickets in an international Test match. Jim Laker (10/53) achieved the feat against Australia while Anil Kumble's (10/76) milestone came against Pakistan.

BTS' Kim Seok-jin: I Want To Make My Mother Proud

BTS' Kim Seok-jin: I Want To Make My Mother Proud

Kim Seok– jin once broke down on stage as he recalled how his mother would never 'brag' about him. “When I was younger, my mother used to just listen to her friends bragging about their sons," said the artist.

Sigh Of Relief For Odisha, Andhra As Cyclone ‘Jawad’ Likely To Weaken: IMD

Sigh Of Relief For Odisha, Andhra As Cyclone ‘Jawad’ Likely To Weaken: IMD

According to India Meteorological Department (IMD), the cyclone is likely to lose it's strength and continue to move north-northeastwards along the Odisha coast before entering West Bengal.

More from Outlook Magazine

Diary | I Want To Fly: The Unrealised Dreams Of An Ex-Banker And Mother

Diary | I Want To Fly: The Unrealised Dreams Of An Ex-Banker And Mother

Kaveri Mishra, an ex-banker and a mother, turned into a full-time home-maker four years back. What holds her back every time she wants to return to her career?

India Needs Kabir Today More Than Any Other Time

India Needs Kabir Today More Than Any Other Time

The Mahindra Kabira Festival at Guleria Ghat in Varanasi was a gentle reminder of the Sufi saint’s centrality to India’s syncretism

Death Of Three Dalit Girls And A Story Of Pain And Humiliation

Death Of Three Dalit Girls And A Story Of Pain And Humiliation

Family from UP village forced to run around to complete post-death official paperwork and even last rites.

Advertisement

Outlook Newsletters

Advertisement
Advertisement