Thursday, Dec 09, 2021
Outlook.com
christianity

Old Narrative, New Fears

An old narrative seems to be gaining currency.

Old Narrative, New Fears
Tribhuvan Tiwari
Old Narrative, New Fears
outlookindia.com
-0001-11-30T00:00:00+05:53

The underlying thread of the ongoing debate on Christians and conversions (and this is what is making the Christians more upset and fearful than the reports about attacks on them) is the insinuation that people of faiths other than those of Indian-origin are somehow less Indian. And this, despite the fact they are as much daughters and sons of this soil as anyone else and their own or their ancestors’ decision in bygone centuries to choose a path of their liking doesn’t change this one iota. The idea of stigmatising people who changed their faith has a long history, going back to Veer Savarkar—and later M.S. Golwalkar—who argued early in the last century that those who consider any land outside India as ‘sacred’ are not full-fledged Indians. This definition was probably a device specifically created to keep out Muslims and Christians, but it posed and continues to pose serious conceptual and logical problems, quite apart from the fact that it was gratuitous on the part of Savarkar/Golwalkar to define what people of other faiths considered sacred or not sacred.

For example, are the 350 million Buddhists around the world who may consider places in India sacred, and sometimes come on pilgrimages here, lesser citizens of their own countries? Are the 1.9 per cent Hindus in the UK, the 2 per cent Hindus in Canada and the 0.5 per cent Hindus in the US lesser citizens of those countries because they may look up to India not only as their ‘sacred’ land, but also their ‘mother’ land? Should Myanmar look at its Hindus, or China look at its Buddhists as less than full citizens? Should the US curtail the freedoms of its Hindu citizens to propagate their religion and culture, build temples, bring priests and new-age gurus from the motherland, or get new adherents? No reasonable person can say yes to any of these questions and that is because the very idea cuts at the roots of modern notions of state, citizenship and democracy.

Outlook Newsletters

Read More from Outlook

AFSPA: When SC Probe Panel Found Six Encounters In Manipur To Be Fake

AFSPA: When SC Probe Panel Found Six Encounters In Manipur To Be Fake

AFSPA is in force in Nagaland, Assam and parts of Manipur and Arunachal Pradesh in the northeast. A similar law exists in Jammu and Kashmir.

CDS General Bipin Rawat: A Saga Of Valour And Excellence

CDS General Bipin Rawat: A Saga Of Valour And Excellence

General Bipin Laxman Singh Rawat held the status of a four star general of the Indian Army. He took over as the 27th Chief of Army Staff (COAS) on December 17, 2016.

Ashes, 1st Test, Day 2 LIVE: Warner Approaches Century

Ashes, 1st Test, Day 2 LIVE: Warner Approaches Century

Get here live cricket scores of day 2 of the first Ashes Test in Brisbane. Pat Cummins has given Australia a head start with a five-wicket haul on Day 1.

Women In Hip-Hop: Emerging Female Rappers Who’re Bringing In A Freshness To The Genre

Women In Hip-Hop: Emerging Female Rappers Who’re Bringing In A Freshness To The Genre

While the hip hop culture in India is growing for quite a while, not many female rappers had been there for a long time. Here are a few female rappers who’ve started making a lot of impact in the recent past.