May 29, 2020
Home  »  Magazine  »  National  »  »  Letter And Holy Spirit

Letter And Holy Spirit

The Kanchi Shankaracharya's formula on Ayodhya is a repetition of his old theme

Letter And Holy Spirit
Letter And Holy Spirit
The Kanchi Shankaracharya's final "solution" is not half as original as some would have us believe.

The hyped formula, which has dominated the news, was dashed off to the All India Muslim Personal Law Board (AIMPLB) on June 20. It doesn't contain anything that the Shankaracharya hasn't said before. Addressed to Board president Maulana Mohammed Rabbey Hasani Nadwi, the two-page letter written in English on behalf of the Jagadguru Sri Shankaracharya Swamigal has a five-point plan to resolve the dispute:

  • Both Hindus and Muslims will wait for the court's verdict on the disputed plot (No 583).

  • A wall will be constructed around plot number 583 to protect it.

  • The AIMPLB will issue a no-objection certificate for the construction of a Ram temple at the acquired land.

  • After the AIMPLB issues the no-objection certificate, the Shankaracharya will approach the Centre to implement the agreement between the two parties.

  • The Board as well as the Shankaracharya will involve the respective communities and the various parties involved to settle the dispute.

The Shankaracharya himself hasn't signed the letter. On his behalf, the letter has been signed by a secretary in the seer's office. The signatory is named "Srikaryam and Agent". If one forgets a few added finishing touches, the letter is almost a replica of the formula sent by the Shankaracharya to the Board on March 8, 2002, that had also suggested a legal solution to the disputed site and the building of a separation wall between the disputed site and acquired land.

Contrary to the media hype about the Shankaracharya having envisaged a mosque within 8-10 km radius of the disputed site, the subject of the mosque has not been discussed in the letter at all. The Shankaracharya's private deliberations with some Ayodhya residents indicate he is in favour of allotting land for the mosque at a nearby place.

The seer's letter also doesn't say anything about withdrawing Hindu claims on Kashi and Mathura. Neither has any promise been made to throw open 1,000 mosques under the asi. "All this is part of media speculation about the contents of the letter," says Maulana Sajjad Nomani, spokesperson for the Board in Lucknow.

In its initial response the Board has reportedly sought clarification from the seer on the construction plan for the temple. The temple plan, till now, includes the disputed site that according to the VHP houses the sanctum sanctorum.
Next Story >>
Google + Linkedin Whatsapp

Read More in:

The Latest Issue

Outlook Videos