Advertisement
Wednesday, Dec 08, 2021
Outlook.com
Opinion

Opinion | Culture Of Intolerance Is Hurting India's Tradition Of Debate And Discussion

In democratic India, suppression and erasure of dissent has become the norm of the day and it's across political parties.

Opinion | Culture Of Intolerance Is Hurting India's Tradition Of Debate And Discussion
Illustrations by Saahil
Opinion | Culture Of Intolerance Is Hurting India's Tradition Of Debate And Discussion
outlookindia.com
2021-10-04T14:30:50+05:30

Voltaire defined tolerance as “the consequence of humanity” and described the ind­ividual who persecu­ted another person because of differing opinion as a “monster”. If we look around, we would find that India in the third decade of the 21st century looks woefully short on hum­anity. Although it is doubtful if Voltaire ever used these exact words— “I disapprove of what you say, but will defend to death your right to say it”—it is beyond doubt they faithfully express what he stood for, and tru­thfully enc­­­apsulates the spirit of liberty so essential to democracy. These words also res­o­­­n­a­te with Kant’s famous argument that Enlightenment stems from free and public use of critical reason, and from the liberty that allows such critical deb­ate to take place without any restrictions. Accor­ding to Kant, “Have courage to use your own reason” is the motto of the Enlightenment.

It’s a matter of concern that India, with its glorious tradition of rational thinking and reason-­based public debates, finds its­elf in a situation where prejudice prevails and coercion is used to stifle dissent. Ideas are not countered by alternative and better ideas, but forcibly suppressed by coercive State apparatus or raw vigilante muscle power. Ideological hegemony is freely utilised to promote certain ideas and to suppress others. Free, fair and public deba­tes and discussions of contentious iss­ues have become almost impossible, naturally impinging on literary and art­istic creativity. The recent incidents at Kan­nur Univ­ersity in Kerala are a case in point. They also bri­ng to fore another imp­or­tant issue—autonomy of insti­tutions of higher learning and research.

Advertisement

Outlook Newsletters

Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement

Read More from Outlook

Aung San Suu Kyi Verdict 'Disturbing' But Will It Change India's Equation With Myanmar?

Aung San Suu Kyi Verdict 'Disturbing' But Will It Change India's Equation With Myanmar?

While India has time and again appealed for rapprochement between the democratic forces and the military, it has continued to engage with the junta in Myanmar.

Church In India Cosying Up To BJP To Protect Its Interests

Church In India Cosying Up To BJP To Protect Its Interests

What has led to this change of heart over the past few years for the Church, long seen to be anathemic to the Sangh Parivar?

Ashes, 1st Test, Day 1 LIVE: ENG 147 All Out; Rain Delays Start Of AUS Innings

Ashes, 1st Test, Day 1 LIVE: ENG 147 All Out; Rain Delays Start Of AUS Innings

England have not won a Test match in Brisbane since 1986-87. Can Australia protect that record this time in the Ashes? Follow live.

Why AFSPA In Jammu And Kashmir Is Not Just A Defence Act

Why AFSPA In Jammu And Kashmir Is Not Just A Defence Act

Has the AFSPA become an ideological Act, a tool to revise Kashmir history? Many analysts believe so.

Advertisement