Advertisement
Wednesday, Oct 27, 2021
Outlook.com

A Broken Rule

Courts are routinely flouting basic judicial norms on bail

A Broken Rule
A Broken Rule
outlookindia.com
2021-02-10T17:25:19+05:30

“No free man shall be seized or imprisoned or stripped of his rights or possessions, or outlawed or exiled, or deprived of his standing in any other way, nor will we proceed with force against him, or send others to do so, except by the lawful judgement of his equals or by the law of the land.”

—Magna Carta

These lines from Clause 39 of the Magna Carta form the bedrock of personal liberty and due process. In India, right to life and personal liberty is the most sacrosanct fundamental right. A person can be deprived of his ­liberty only “according to the procedure established by law”. There is a struggle between the procedure established by law and the due process of law as ­req­uired by the Eighth Amendment to the American Constitution—the two poles of bail jurisprudence not just in India, but around the world. Even though the ­makers of India’s Constitution chose to adopt “procedure established by the law”, the Supreme Court in Sunil Batra as well as in Maneka Gandhi interpreted it as “due process of law”.

The discussion on due process of law and procedure established by law in the context of personal liberty has assumed relevance as a result of inconsistency in granting bail to activists, journalists and comedians. Many on social media and television have made insinuations that the courts, especially the Supreme Court, have shown a bias in favour of granting liberty to people known to be pro-­government, while those who have been critical of the government are treated differently. The right to personal liberty seems to be contingent upon not the ­procedure established by law, but the identity and ideology of the person in conflict with the law. Courts continue to regard bail as a...

Advertisement

Outlook Newsletters

Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement

Read More from Outlook

Bombay High Court Adjourns Aryan Khan's Bail Application Till Tomorrow

Bombay High Court Adjourns Aryan Khan's Bail Application Till Tomorrow

Former Attorney General of India (AGI) Mukul Rohatgi appeared for Shah Rukh Khan’s son Aryan Khan, along with his existing legal counsel comprising Satish Manishinde and Amit Desai.

Explainer | Why A Lawyer Is Seeking FIR Against NCB's Wankhede For 'Extortion' In Aryan Khan Drugs Case

Explainer | Why A Lawyer Is Seeking FIR Against NCB's Wankhede For 'Extortion' In Aryan Khan Drugs Case

On Monday, a lawyer approached the Mumbai police with a complaint seeking registration of an FIR against Sameer Wankhede and five others for extortion in the drugs-on-cruise case.

IPL Controversy: CVC Capital Under BCCI Scanner

IPL Controversy: CVC Capital Under BCCI Scanner

The BCCI on Monday named RPSG Ventures Limited and Irelia Company Pte Ltd. (CVC Capital Partners) as owners of the new IPL teams from 2022.

'TMC & AAP On A Mission To Split Congress Votes And Help BJP In Goa': State Congress Chief

'TMC & AAP On A Mission To Split Congress Votes And Help BJP In Goa': State Congress Chief

Goa Congress president Girish Chodankar strongly asserted that the voters cannot be wooed with false promises and money as people are deeply rooted in the Congress.

Advertisement