July 08, 2020
Home  »  Magazine  »  National  » Cover Stories  » Cover Story »  Don’t Fix What Isn’t Broken

Don’t Fix What Isn’t Broken

Why doctors think it is a bad idea to target the MCI now

Google + Linkedin Whatsapp
Follow Outlook India On News
Don’t Fix What Isn’t Broken

The government’s move to introduce the National Medical Commission Bill, 2016, in the next Parliament session, has triggered a raging debate in the medical fraternity. A paper on the bill drafted by a committee formed by the NITI Aayog has added fuel to fire with irate doctors asking how its three members—P.K. Mishra, additional private secretary to the PM, NITI Aayog CEO Amitabh Kant and health secretary B.P. Sharma—could be better suited for the job than medical professionals.

In a scathing communication to the gov­e­rn­ment, Chandigarh-based Medicos Legal Act­­­ion Group (MLAG) has alleged that MPs directly and indirectly associated with private medical col­­l­­eges­ were upset when the MCI began INS­isting on minimum standards, and hence the att­empt to replace the MCI with a commission that will have members nominated by the Centre and the states. According to MLAG, there are at least 80 such MPs.

“The very forces that misused and armtwisted the MCI to serve their interests are now seeking to get total control through the bill,” MLAG claims in the letter. “Medical education has been recognised as a cash cow with seats being sold for crores…. Since MCI does not toe their line, it is now being attempted to bring the entire process under government control where political power, not standards, will determine whether a college will be given recognition or not.”

Others fear that the bill appears to be subverting the self-regulatory status of the profession, turning the regulator into a dep­artment under the health ministry. If NITI Aayog’s prescription is to be accep­ted, they point out, all other self-regulating bodies like the Bar Council of India and the Institute of Chartered Accountants of India would also have to be scrapped.

Many doctors believe the large number of Indian doctors working abroad is testimony that there is nothing inherently wrong with the MCI. “This is borne out by the growing number of foreigners choosing Indian hospitals for treatment,” says one. It is the government, the doctors argue, that has interfered with medical education over the years. Pointing out how ordinances were issued to ensure registration of AYUSH graduates as medical practitioners by the, they argue it makes a certain degree of dilution inevitable.

A senior doctor in Bangalore believes the perception of the MCI as a venal body dates back to pre-2013 days and, since then, it has put its act together. “In Karnataka, the MCI slashed many seats even in government colleges, causing an uproar,” he says. “The state had to pledge Rs 32 crore to ensure that the lacunae in infrastructure were taken care of. Private colleges are very afraid now. Everything is by the book. We are allowing ourselves to walk into a trap. Dissolving the MCI is a very dangerous path we are treading. The known devil is better than an unknown angel.” In fact, it is the NITI Aayog paper that suggests an end to fee ceilings and legitimi­ses profiteering in medical education.

Next Story >>
Google + Linkedin Whatsapp

The Latest Issue

Outlook Videos