The Case Against Modi Is Not Weakened By 1984
The question, ‘What about 1984?’, is a trap. The case against Modi is not weakened by this counter, but the attempt to engage with it does highlight a secular failure on 1984 that persists. If you consider the difference between the pursuit of justice post-2002 and post-1984, [Mukul] Kesavan’s explicit claim [in the Telegraph—"the reason the dynastic Congress isn’t as dangerous as Modi’s BJP is dispiriting but straightforward: while the Congress is capable of communalism, it isn’t constituted by bigotry."] that is what accounts for the active involvement of civil rights activists in Gujarat and their apathy in practice over the 1984 killings. Many of the activists who have done outstanding work in Gujarat, such as Teesta Setalvad, see no problem in maintaining close links with the Congress. They see the BJP and Modi as ever present dangers that need to be combated, but they treat 1984 as an aberration that lies in the past.
...Madhu Kishwar, always a maverick, is treated these days with well-deserved disdain by secularists for her recent claims that Modi acted promptly and effectively to quell the 2002 violence in Gujarat. Yet, the same people see no problem in claiming Mani Shankar Aiyar, another maverick, as their own even though he has spent close to three decades making similar claims about Rajiv Gandhi’s response to the 1984 violence in Delhi.
Read the full piece at Open: Secular Nonsense
Also See older pieces referenced here:
- Disappointed By India's Negative, Arrogant Response: Pak PM Imran Khan After Talks Called Off
- Photo Essay | Deserted Kashmiri Pandit Homes Caught In Haunting Time Capsule
- Obsessed With Selfies And Afraid Of Body-Shaming, Teenagers Are Turning To Cosmetic Surgery
- 'Surgical Strike' On Defence Forces, Says Rahul Gandhi Over Rafale Deal
- What? Where? Why? A Guide To Universities And Business Schools Abroad
- Why Railways' Largest Recruitment Drive May Fail To Address Passenger Safety Concerns
- Article 35A: An Unprecedented Situation In Kashmir
- Four Months Of Kumaraswami Govt: Karnataka Power Games Carry On
- Prashant Kishor No Exception, Nitish Has Always Relied On 'Apolitical' Advisors
- With A Formidable BJP, Is Mamata Worried About Hindu Votes?
- The VVIP Culture In Indian Railways
- Trump Administration Says Will Revoke Work Permits To H4 Visa Holders Within 3 Months
- Not Involved In Choice Of Indian Partners For Rafale Deal, Says French Govt
- Militants Adopted Similar Strategy To Abduct, Kill Three Policemen In Kashmir
- Resumption Of India-Pak Dialogue Can Be Ruled Out Till 2019 Elections
- Rima Das' 'Village Rockstars' Makes Official Entry To Oscars 2019
- 'Kashmir Situation Scary, Ground Rules Will Have To Be Redrawn'
- ‘Be Careful, Will Cut Your Tongues’, Andhra Police Inspector Threatens Abusive MPs, MLAs
- Asia Cup 2018: India-Pakistan Rematch In Super Four Serves As Precursor To Final