The Case Against Modi Is Not Weakened By 1984
The question, ‘What about 1984?’, is a trap. The case against Modi is not weakened by this counter, but the attempt to engage with it does highlight a secular failure on 1984 that persists. If you consider the difference between the pursuit of justice post-2002 and post-1984, [Mukul] Kesavan’s explicit claim [in the Telegraph—"the reason the dynastic Congress isn’t as dangerous as Modi’s BJP is dispiriting but straightforward: while the Congress is capable of communalism, it isn’t constituted by bigotry."] that is what accounts for the active involvement of civil rights activists in Gujarat and their apathy in practice over the 1984 killings. Many of the activists who have done outstanding work in Gujarat, such as Teesta Setalvad, see no problem in maintaining close links with the Congress. They see the BJP and Modi as ever present dangers that need to be combated, but they treat 1984 as an aberration that lies in the past.
...Madhu Kishwar, always a maverick, is treated these days with well-deserved disdain by secularists for her recent claims that Modi acted promptly and effectively to quell the 2002 violence in Gujarat. Yet, the same people see no problem in claiming Mani Shankar Aiyar, another maverick, as their own even though he has spent close to three decades making similar claims about Rajiv Gandhi’s response to the 1984 violence in Delhi.
Read the full piece at Open: Secular Nonsense
Also See older pieces referenced here:
- OPINION | Mahua's First LS Speech Is Commendable, But It's Time She Looks At What TMC Does In Bengal
- Live, IND vs WI: Virat Kohli Hits Fourth Consecutive Fifty But India Wobble
- PM Modi, Abe Discuss Global Economy, Disaster Management At G20 Summit
- Bombay High Court Upholds Maratha Quota, But Says Percentage Should Be Reduced
- Fastest To 20000 International Runs! Virat Kohli Breaks Another Sachin Tendulkar Record
- Trump's America Is Once Again Locking Horns With Iran. What Should India Do?
- Do Driving And Education Have A Connection?
- Ola, Ole! How's The Patient Doing?
- Salman Khan’s Fears Misplaced, No Reviewer Can Make Or Mar A Film Destined For Greatness
- With No Malls, No App-Based Economy, Kashmir Stuck At Where It Was 2 Decades Ago
- India, Pakistan And The Cost Of A Cup Of Tea In Kashmir
- Nirmala Sitharaman Meets Manmohan Singh Ahead Of Her First Budget
- My Private Member Bill Exposed BJP's 'Double Standards' On Sabarimala: NK Premachandran
- On Kumaraswamy Losing Cool, BJP's Prahlad Joshi Says Karnataka CM Has 'Lost His Mental Balance'
- Why India Is Not A Favourite Tourist Destination For Affluent Chinese
- 'We Can Change The World': DiCaprio Draws Attention To Chennai Water Crisis
- In UP's Unnao Jail, Inmates Seen Flashing Pistol, Govt Says It's Made Of 'Clay'
- 'Is She Serious,' Says Congress On Mamata Banerjee's Call To Defeat BJP Together
- J&K: Eleven Students, Including 9 Girls, Killed After Minibus Falls In Gorge In Shopian District