The Hindu: Very Divided Family
For those who came in late:
It started with this newsreport in the Indian Express (also reproduced in the group's Financial Express) about the goings-on at one of the country’s oldest and most respected media companies, Kasturi & Sons Ltd, the publisher of the 132-year-old English newspaper The Hindu and business daily The Hindu Business Line:
The report went on to allege:
“While the retirement age for all employees at Kasturi is 60 years, there was no such stipulation for board members. It was proposed by Murali that 65 years be set as the retirement age for board members,” said the sources.
The Kasturi board of directors has 12 members, descending from four cousins — G Narasimhan (father of N Ram, N Ravi, N Murali); S Parthasarathy (father of Malini Parthasarathy, Nirmala Lakshman and Nalini Krishnan); S Rangarajan (father of Ramesh Rangarajan, Vijaya Arun and Akila Iyengar) and G Kasturi (father of K Balaji, K Venugopal and Lakshmi Srinath).
According to the faction opposed to Ram, all members at the meeting agreed to the proposal and Ram, who turns 65 this May, was identified as the first member to step down from the board followed by Murali and N Ravi, who will turn 65 in August 2011 and 2013 respectively.
It was also decided, these sources said, that after Ram’s retirement, Ravi would take over as Editor-in-Chief of the group while Malini Parthasarathy would be appointed the editor of The Hindu and Venugopal the editor of The Hindu Business Line.
Read more at the Express
The Hindu used to be edited by G. Kasturi from 1965 to 1991. The power-struggle in the extended family is said to go back to this period. On his retirement, Deputy Editor N. Ravi, N. Ram's younger brother, replaced G. Kasturi as Editor. N. Ram was given independent charge of Sportstar and Frontline. Nirmala Lakshman, Kasturi Srinivasan's granddaughter, became Joint Editor of The Hindu and her sister, Malini Parthasarathy, Executive Editor. There was a change at the helm once again in 2003 when N. Ram took over the editorship of The Hindu on June 27, 2003.
The Express report also mentions that Murali, Ravi and Malini Parthasarthy questioned the appointment of two family members in the company by N. Ram " without the board’s consent and proper governance norms"-- Narayan Lakshman, son of Nirmala Lakshman; and Vidya Ram, N.Ram's daughter. It also goes on to allege that the trio "also pointed out several alleged financial irregularities in the way in which Kasturi’s resources, financial as well as editorial, were used to further the interests of some board members".
The paper did, however, also give Mr N. Ram's version of the events. N. Ram hit back soon thereafter, as the Hindu website announced:
“These reports are riddled with demonstrable falsehoods and defamatory assertions, some of them attributed to unnamed sources, made with reckless and malicious disregard for the facts and the truth,” Mr. Ram said in a statement issued in Chennai today. “And this despite the professional courtesy I extended to the journalist and the newspapers by responding precisely and factually to five specific questions emailed to me on March 24 by Ms Shukla.”
Following are some of the interesting tweets that soon ensued from some of the dramatis personae:
Mr Ram's youngest brother whose twitter account had been dormant since November 3, decided to break his silence with this tweet:
Malini Parthasarthy retweeted the above and also chipped in:
Incidentally, Malini Parthasarthy not only retweeted N. Ravi’s tweet above but also another one: "Word is that NRam wants Venugopal as editorinchief & Nirmala as editor instead of Ravi & Malini." The latter being from none other than Aditya Sinha, the Editor-in-Chief of The New Indian Express (Ironically, a result of another family split, following the death of Ramnath Goenka), the Hindu's rival paper in Chennai, who seemed to be having a bit of fun and feeding grist to the rumour mills:
The Deccan Chronicle is a Hyderabad paper with a Chennai edition. And one should not miss the reference to China. An SMS, doing the rounds through the day was the old joke when Mr Ram took over the Hindu: "Rumour has it that it has been unofficially renamed as the People's Daily of Chennai." It was countered by another one that just said: "The American Express?"
Watch this space.
N. Ram says There can be no defence, in law or intelligent discourse, for these demonstrable falsehoods that defame recklessly http://bit.ly/d5ZZRH | 2:17 AM Mar 26th and adds:
The Indian Express responded to Mr Ram's threat to sue, which it carried equally prominently on its front page:
“The report, ‘Battle for control breaks out in The Hindu very divided family’, (The Indian Express, The Financial Express, March 25, 2010) is based on information received from multiple and high-level credible sources.
“All facts were verified and cross-checked to the highest standards of accuracy and fairness that The Express Group holds itself to. We believe our report was neither malicious nor defamatory.
“We have great regard for The Hindu as an institution and for its Editor-in-Chief N Ram as a journalist and editor for their commitment to principled journalism.
“We stand by our report and the reporter.”
And went on to add more details: The Hindu war in the open: Ram strips Murali of powers, he says won’t quit
Stripped of his powers by publisher and group Editor-in-Chief N Ram, Managing Director and his brother N Murali has hit back saying that he will not quit. And that he would try to “make Ram see reason and retire as Editor-in-Chief as committed by him in September 2009 and ensure a smooth transition.”
Ram, incidentally, has denied that he made such a commitment.
“Some members of the Board of Directors have been trying to systematically undermine and erode my authority and responsibilities and rights and obligations,” Murali wrote in an email to “colleagues” in the company today. “I will not allow that to happen.”
That was not all. The Express story went on to quote a purported letter to the Kasturi board-members from Murali’s children Kanta and Krishna and Ravi’s daughter Aparna protesting the appointment of Narayan Lakshman and Vidya Ram in senior editorial positions in the US and Europe:
“It is essential that the Board considers issues of corporate governance and the appointment of family members seriously. To point out the obvious, the business cannot accommodate every member of the family, particularly when there are no institutional mechanisms in place to prevent the receipt of unjustifiably large entitlements over a long period of time. Each of us, whether in the previous, current or next generation, has received and continues to receive tremendous benefits from Kasturi and Sons, which far outweigh those received by non-family employees. It is high time that we recognize that our privileges are derived primarily from the contributions and loyalty of over 3500 non-family employees. Each one of us has, in some way or the other, abused their loyalty, trust and contribution.
“The inequitable and arbitrary system that currently exists is not only unfair to non-family employees but to shareholders as a class as well. If there is ever any intention of instituting sound and modern corporate governance practices and discontinuing the feudal system that exists, then issues such as the ones we have raised need to be addressed squarely, honestly and without fear or favour.” Read the full Indian Express report:
This should of course be read in light of the Express reporter Archna Shukla’s emailed question to N. Ram in which she asked:
I am told that Mr Murali was opposed to the induction of the children of some of the family members hired at very high salaries and that led to unpleasantness among members and finally, his ouster. Is this correct?
And Mr Ram replied:
Totally wrong, as the written record will show. Any appointment of a relative of a Director that needed approval by both the Board of Directors and Shareholders before going to the central government was approved unanimously, without a murmur of dissent by any Director or Shareholder.
Every one of the 12 Directors of the Company approved every such appointment. To describe the relevant salaries as “very high” would be laughable; in fact, if the precise numbers were revealed, the salaries or remuneration would be characterised as “rather low.” They are similar to what other foreign correspondents of our newspaper Group get. More here
Later, on Twitter, in response to a question: @malinip also, the issues on which the fight is happening, are they ideological or mostly administrative like IE suggested?, Malini Parhasarthy replied:
@ssudhirkumar I think many latent issues relating to management of newspaper have come to the surface, including editorial direction
Day III, March 27
Cryptic. Surely she does not mean the supporters of the Deputy Chief Minister of Tamil Nadu?
Talking of which, in other news, the Editor-in-Chief of The New Indian Express, Aditya Sinha, reported again via Twitter:
- Well, N Ram is hosting lunch for Chennai editors & deputy CM Stalin for the June World Classical Tamil Conference. It ought to be exciting!
- Ram is very gracious. Venugopal is the one tearing into me for my tweets!
- Hosted and chief guested by 2 men whose brothers are rebelling: N Ram and MK Stalin. http://myloc.me/5i9Ar
- Venugopal says my tweets are being used! This is NOT journalism! [He perhaps means in blogs such as this one]
- Ram introducing me to Tamil heavies! Me, an irreverent Northie!
- Lunch was to discuss World Classical Tamil conf 2b held in Kovai in June. Basically Kalaignar wants to upstage Anna. Dy CM fidgeted as usual
- Good lunch! Gracious host, tasty food, many bigwigs blowing dy CM Stalin! Key family members were not there. Must have been with CLB.
- Marriage Between Hindu Woman And Muslim Man Irregular, But Child Born Is Legitimate: SC
- EC Writes To Delhi Police Seeking FIR Against Man Who Claimed EVMs Can Be Hacked
- It's Unanimous! Virat Kohli Is The World's Best
- Modi Bachao, Advertisement Chalao: Rahul Gandhi's Jibe At PM's Key Campaign
- TMC Govt Has Done Nothing For Refugees In Bengal, We Will Give Them Citizenship: Amit Shah
- Liberal Beats Of Mumbai Dance Bars: Social Progress, Morality And Women
- Only Thing That Can Ground Naveen Patnaik This Time Is ‘Problem Of Plenty’
- What Will Be The Effect Of Alliances Against BJP Across India
- Two Mega Film Releases Trigger A Wave Of Crazy Fan Behaviour In Tamil Nadu
- Politics And Public Memory In Kashmir
- Sabarimala Issue May Help BJP Grow In Kerala But Social Reform Is Inevitable
- 56% Of 'Beti Bachao, Beti Padhao' Funds Spent On Advertisements: Minister
- Drunk Man Hijacks Plane In Russia, Gets Arrested
- Hindu Sena Marks Queen Victoria's Death Anniversary, Says She Freed India From Muslims
- 31 Rohingya Muslims Apprehended At India-Bangladesh Border Arrested
- Facing All Odds, TTEs Collect Rs 3 Cr Per Day From Ticketless Rail Passengers
- NZ Vs IND, 1st ODI Preview: Kohli & Co Face Kiwi Test After Conquering Aussies
- Rare Skin Disease Returns To Haunt Bangladeshi 'Tree Man'
- Fighting For Life, Jacob Martin Receives Blank Cheque From Krunal Pandya