BBC, Northern Ireland, And Kashmir – Where Shekhar Kapur Got It Wrong
Northern Ireland is not split into two as Kashmir is between India and Pakistan. And the division between Ireland and Northern Ireland is also not as watertight.
Shekhar Kapur might have slipped in his grasp of history and language when he questioned the BBC why it was not referring to Northern Ireland as British-Occupied Ireland when it called Kashmir as Indian-Occupied Kashmir. The actor-director was apparently chaffed at the preface attached to Kashmir when no such thing qualified Northern Ireland, which is part of the United Kingdom.
The director of the 1998 film “Elizabeth” would not have made the comparison if only he had cared to find out how prickly the BBC is while referring to Kashmir or had researched a little about the history of Northern Ireland.
Firstly, the BBC refers to Kashmir as either India-administered Kashmir or as Indian-controlled Kashmir. Similarly, it is Pakistan-administered Kashmir or Pakistan-controlled Kashmir. See the following link to the BBC’s style guide with regard to Kashmir: https://www.bbc.co.uk/academy/en/articles/art20130702112133577
Only India and Pakistan and the media in these countries use the word “occupied” while referring to the respective parts of Kashmir under the control of the other country.
According to a senior BBC journalist, the channel has always taken to care to stick to its style guide whenever referring to Kashmir considering how sensitive the issue is. “Let us not forget that we have both Indians and Pakistanis living in England and would not want to spark a protest by using the wrong terminology,” he explained. So, while the language part is settled maybe it is time for some lessons on Northern Ireland.
Northern Ireland was created in 1921, when Ireland was partitioned between Northern Ireland and Southern Ireland by the Government of Ireland Act 1920. The reason was mostly religious as the six counties which formed Northern Ireland were dominated by Protestants like in UK while the minority Catholics there wanted a united Ireland independent of British rule. Southern Ireland (now Republic of Ireland) was and is a Catholic dominated country.
Ireland today is a republic, free of British control while England, Wales and Scotland (which together form Great Britain) and Northern Ireland are the four countries that make up the United Kingdom. However, the Catholics of Northern Ireland continued to fight for freedom from British rule and their armed struggle was spearheaded by the Irish Republican Army (IRA). At the height of the conflict, which claimed nearly 2,000 lives over three decades, there were over 100 peace walls that separated the Catholic and Protestant enclaves of Belfast, the capital of Northern Ireland. Today they are mere tourist attractions for their beautiful murals.
The ‘war’ between the IRA and the British government ended with the Good Friday Agreement of 1998 signed by British Prime Minister Tony Blair. The pact created Northern Ireland’s present devolved system of government and a number of institutions between Northern Ireland and the Republic of Ireland, and between the Republic of Ireland and the United Kingdom. The agreement was also backed by the then US President Bill Clinton under pressure from the strong Irish lobby in the US.
So, essentially, Northern Ireland is not split into two as Kashmir is between India and Pakistan though ‘Indian Kashmir’ is the larger entity and has its own state Assembly. And the division between Ireland and Northern Ireland is also not as watertight. In many sports Ireland fields a single team – also representing its Northern counterpart - except in football. Northern Ireland though competes separately at the Commonwealth Games, and athletes from Northern Ireland are free to compete either for Great Britain or Ireland at the Olympic Games. The present captain of the England ODI team Eoin Morgan had originally played for Ireland before moving to England.
So Shekhar Kapur’s comparison of Kashmir to Northern Ireland is historically not correct.
- CBI Quizzes Chidambaram In INX Media Case, To Be Produced In Court Shortly
- 'Broad Daylight Murder Of Law, Democracy': Cong Lashes Out At Govt Over Chidambaram's Arrest
- With P. Chidambaram's Arrest, His Anticipatory Bail Plea Before SC Rendered Infructuous
- MP CM Kamal Nath's Nephew Ratul Puri Moves Court To Surrender In AgustaWestland Case
- India's Fresh Challenge On Kashmir: Engage With Donald Trump But Without Opening Another Front
- Kashmiris Are Angry, Yet They Are Calm. Why?
- Indian Armed Forces, Civilians Continue To Bleed In Internal Conflicts, But Do We Care?
- On India's 73rd Independence Day, A Letter to Pehlu Khan
- The Valley Has Fallen Into Rigor Mortis
- BBC, Northern Ireland, And Kashmir – Where Shekhar Kapur Got It Wrong
- Euphoria On Abrogation Of Article 370 Is Wearing Off, Only Time Will Tell Full Meaning Of This Move
- INX Media Case: 20 Questions CBI Asked P Chidambaram
- Etawah 'Ragging' Case: Police, VC Deny Medical Students Were Forced To Shave Heads
- March To Delhi Temple Demolition Site Was 'Personal Decision': Dalit Body
- NDA Candidate Against Rahul Gandhi In Wayanad Arrested In UAE
- WATCH: Guns Fail To Fire Shots During Ex-Bihar CM Jagannath Mishra's State Honours Ceremony
- Oppn Protests At Jantar Mantar, Demands Release Of Detained J&K Leaders
- Kohli Hints At Four-Bowler Strategy Vs WI
- Live, 1st Test, Day 1: SL Win Toss, Opt To Bat First Vs NZ