Fareed Zakaria: "Straight Up Lying" About Plagiarism
For those who came in late: Fareed Zakaria: New Plagiarism Accusations.
Fareed Zakaria has responded to the recent, new charges of "rampant plagiarism":
In August 2012, CNN, Time and the Washington Post separately conducted extensive reviews of my commentary. As one part of this process, they ran my columns and cover stories (which span over 20 years) through software programs designed to detect plagiarism. All three informed me that the reviews cleared me fully.
Two anonymous bloggers today have alleged that there are 11 cases in my writing where I have cited a statistic that also appeared somewhere else. These are all facts, not someone else’s writing or opinions or expressions. For example, in one column, I note that the national debt tripled under Ronald Reagan. The bloggers point out that this is also in Wikipedia’s Reagan entry. But it is also in hundreds of other articles, studies, and reports — just Google the phrase. Until today, I had never read the Wikipedia entry for Ronald Reagan. As it happens, it is incorrect. (There is a difference between “public debt” – Wikipedia’s words — and national debt.)
My usual procedure with a piece of data that I encounter is to check it out, going as close to the original source as is possible. If the data is government generated (GDP, spending on pensions, tax rates, defense spending, etc) then I often don’t cite a source since it is in the public domain. If it is a study or survey produced by a think tank, then I usually cite the institution that conducted the survey. In many of these cases, there was a link in my column to the source. This was not always possible, however, because Time magazine, for example, did not always allow for links. My columns are often data-heavy, so I try to use common sense, putting a source into the text when it was necessary.
In many of the columns cited by the bloggers, I found the data they refer to in a primary source not the secondary one that they highlight. For example, in my column that mentions Greece’s debt, I noted that “one estimate” suggests that Greece has been in default for half of its existence since its independence. The bloggers found a Businessweek article that had the same fact. But I didn’t get it from there; I never read that article. The “estimate” I refer to is in the scholarly book by Carmen Reinhart and Kenneth Rogoff, “This Time It’s Different” – which I did read. The Businessweek article, incidentally, does not cite the Rogoff book or any source at all for the same fact Does that mean that the Businessweek author was claiming that he was the source for it? No, of course not, because it was a fact in wide circulation at the time.
There is one additional case – the 12th — that involves, not a piece of data, but a quote from Richard Holbrooke that also appeared in a George Packer essay in the New Yorker. I got that from a direct conversation with Holbrooke in person several months before he died. He had made that particular comment to me many times. I asked him in this case if I could quote him. He agreed. I put it into my notebook, marked, “for attribution.”
However, the statement was immediately rebutted by the two bloggers @blippoblappo & @crushingbort who had levelled fresh charges of "rampant plagiarism" against Zakaria yesterday.
In a new post titled How And Why Lying About Plagiarism Is Bad – A Response To Fareed Zakaria And Fred Hiatt, the duo accuse Zakaria of "straight up lying"
The duo do not stop at pointedly rebutting each and every point made by Zakaria but go on to promise that they would "have more extensive examples of plagiarism by Fareed Zakaria later this week."
Watch this space.
- ‘If The British Behaved Like Hyderabad Police, They Would Have Shot Bhagat Singh In Encounter’
- 4 Accused In Telangana Vet Rape-Murder Case Killed In Police Encounter
- 'Her Soul Must Be At Peace Now': Telangana Vet's Family Thanks Police
- 'Happy With Punishment': Nirbhaya's Parents Back Telangana Cops After 'Encounter' Of 4 Rape Accused
- Hamara Bajaj: Going Where Few Dare To Go These Days
- How Naveen Patnaik Is Playing The Games To Make Odisha A Soft Power
- A Precursor To 'Resort Politics' That Began In 1984 As NTR Foiled Indira's Bid To Dethrone Him
- Given Opportunity, BSNL Can Emerge As Top Telecom Company From Turmoil
- One Hundred Days Of Solitude In Kashmir’s News World
- How T. N. Seshan's Poll Clean-up Operation Actually Helped Lalu Yadav In Bihar
- Domestic Violence Can Be Isolated, Repetitive Or Even Span Generations
- People Hail Encounter Death Of 4 Rape Accused In Telangana
- Trump Impeachment To Go Ahead, Says House Speaker Pelosi
- Tussle Between Bengal Guv And Mamata Govt Touches New Flashpoint
- What Chidambaram Talked About After Spending 106 Days In Tihar
- Govt Calls Sheikh Abdullah ‘Great Leader’, But Imposes Sec 144 At His Grave
- Kashmir On Way To Register Longest Internet Shutdown?
- AS Roma, Inter Milan Ban Italian Newspaper For 'Black Friday' Headline
- IND Vs WI, 1st T20I: Focus On Rahul, Pant