Home »  Blog »   »  After Penguin, Aleph Too Pulls Out Doniger Book?

After Penguin, Aleph Too Pulls Out Doniger Book?


When news first broke of Shiksha Bachao Andolan Samiti (SBAS) also targeting Wendy Doniger's On Hinduism published by the Aleph Book Company, after its success with  getting Penguin Books India to withdraw her The Hindus: An Alternative History, Atul Kothari, co-convenor of SBAS, was quoted by The Sunday Express as saying, “We have been given an oral assurance by the publishers that the sales of the book will be stalled. The publishers have been given a week’s time to provide an assurance in writing, failing which, SBAS would move the judiciary.”  He had said that they would wait for a written assurance for a week, failing which the Samiti may take its next “democratic step” to ensure the book is withdrawn.

Co Publisher of Aleph Publications, Ravi Singh, however, had completely denied any such move to The Sunday Express: “We are not withdrawing the book and we are not terminating any contract.” 

But now the Times of India reports that the book has indeed been withdrawn from Karnataka: 

Confirming the move, an Aleph spokesman said, "We don't want to get involved in any controversy. Officials from our Delhi office sent a clear message to us — recall all copies of 'On Hinduism' we had sold across Karnataka. We got back about 100 copies till Tuesday evening."

'On Hinduism' was published in 2013 while 'The Hindus: An Alternative History' was published in 2009. Mayi Gowda of Blossom Book House told TOI that the publisher sought the return all copies of the book. On Monday, this bookshop had sold all 95 copies of the book following renewed interest in Doniger's work post- Penguin's withdrawal of 'An Alternative History'.

Another city bookshop, Bookworm, said it returned a few copies of the book Tuesday morning. The staff at different book shops said they got emails from the publisher seeking their cooperation.

Read the full story at the TOI: Another Wendy Doniger book pulled out, copies of ‘On Hinduism’ recalled from Karnataka

Also read: The SBAS's objections to On Hinduism: 'A Conspiracy Hatched By The Children Of Marx And Macaulay'

16 Apr 2014, 11:17:42 AM | Buzz

Anubhuti Vishnoi reports in The Indian Express: Modi effect: One publisher quits, other spikes

Ravi Singh, co-publisher of Aleph Book Company, has quit apparently in protest against the manner in which Aleph seemed to have yielded to those calling for a ban on Wendy Doniger’s On Hinduism. Sources said he also questioned the decision by Rupa — Aleph’s publishing partner — to publish a translation of BJP’s PM candidate Narendra Modi’s poetry during the election campaign...

Sources confirmed that Singh was “uncomfortable” with the way the publishing house was proceeding with the Doniger controversy and felt that it would eventually move in a direction where he would have no say at all. But when asked about his resignation, Singh told The Indian Express: “I’m happy that together with David I set up and nurtured a wonderful company but it’s time to move on now.”

05 Mar 2014, 06:24:07 PM | Buzz

Aleph and Rupa, the publishers of Wendy Doniger's On Hinduism have now issued this statement in response to the Times of India report:

‘This refers to the report by Rajiv Kalkod ("Another Doniger book pulled out") published in your newspaper today. We are not aware of any such thing except that we are looking forward to the right resolution of the situation.’

-Authorised statement of R T Das,
Rupa Publications,
Regional Manager,
South India.

Subscribe to Outlook’s Newsletter

Download the Outlook ​Magazines App. Six magazines, wherever you go! Play Store and App Store


Online Casino Betway Banner