Is Democracy Worst Form of Govt? Panelists at JLF Debate
send via whatsapp

Is Democracy the worst form of government? What form of democracy does the entire world respect? Can any country's democracy really be participatory in true sense? Do we need the existing form of democracy or not?

These questions came up as panelists at the annual Jaipur Literature Festival held discussions on democracies in India and abroad, during the debate 'Is democracy the worst form of government?' at the concluding session of the five-day festival today.

In conversation were advisor to the Bihar Chief Minister Pawan Verma, BJP leader Murli Manohar Joshi, AAP leader Shazia Ilmi, first female president of a registered political party in Bhutan Lily Wangchuk, Bangladesh writer K Anis Ahmed, foreign correspondent and author Peter Godwin and journalist-author Indrajit Hazra.

"I am a proud beneficiary of democracy which was gifted to us by our king in 2008. The story of democracy in Bhutan is unique one. The anarchy that Bhutan has witnessed, with this gift, we have nothing to complain about," Wangchuck said.

"Now that we are dealing with challenges associated with democracy, we know there will always be difference in a democracy that is gifted and a democracy that is fought for.

There is no system that is completely perfect but there always bad and worse things, so democracy will be the bad one anarchy the worse," she added.

Peter said, "I have witnessed two strong examples that are the best arguments in favour of democracy-- the end of Soviet Union and the end of apartheid in South Africa.

The thing to discuss is what happens when there is a lack of democracy? It is often ugly, rude and loud but it is undoubtedly the best way of managing a transition.

Stating that India's democracy is an example which even the countries abroad look up to, Peter said, "If democracy will collapse in India, what will happen in other countries which look up to India's democracy as one of the strongest examples.

Aam Aadmi party leader Shazia Ilmi supported the views, but advocated that there is need to relook the methods of participation in our democracy.

"Democracy unrealised, democracy unfulfilled, a democracy which is not real will become a tragic democracy in years to come. The required symbol of democracy is not franchise but protests," she said.

"One third (members) of the Indian parliament has serious charges of corruption, and one third of the parliament has people who are there because of feudal dynasty politics so there is bound to be a conflict of interest? So, are we democratic in true sense?", asked Shazia.

"We no longer need enraged citizens, we need engaged citizens to fill the divide between the political class and the common man," she said.

Pavan Verma supported Shazia's argument, saying that we are taking democracy for granted.

"We have started to take democracy for granted and we have forgotten that it came through a process," he said.

However, BJP leader Murli Manohar Joshi said that no wonder how many defects are there in democracy, he likes it as it is.

"If it is wrong, we fight for it. When Emergency was imposed in 1975, we fought for it and democracy was reimposed. I like it, I respect it and will fight for it," Joshi said.

Emerging story. Watch this space for updates as more details come in
Read More In:

Follow us on Twitter for all updates, like us on Facebook for important and fun stuff
Translate into:
© Copyright PTI. All rights reserved. Republication or redistribution of any PTI content, including by framing or similar means, is expressly prohibited without their prior written consent.
send via whatsapp

Post a Comment
Share your thoughts
You are not logged in, please log in or register
Must See
Daily Mail

Jan 22, 2014
10:55 AM

Why do they call it a "Literature Festival" ?

K.Suresh, Bangalore
Jan 22, 2014
10:51 AM

Let same Literary guest visit North Korea and organise debate on "Is Dictattoship is worst form of Govt"?And lets see will all Guets return back safely to there home land?

Jaykumar, Ahmedabad
Jan 22, 2014
02:53 AM

Democracy gives away responsibility for governance, to 'scoundrel class', that is not accountable.

Misogynist, Chennai
Jan 22, 2014
01:28 AM

"We no longer need enraged citizens"

As far as Delhi is concerned, we only have a mentally deranged CM. No one, including Kejriwal, has the slightest clue what Kejriwal would do at any given time.

BTW, why did his wife come today morning? They posed for some nice photos but really what was the point in her coming?

Rakhal Chandra Ghosh, Tomball
Jan 22, 2014
01:15 AM

Democracy is vulnerable to misinformation and the big lie due to plutocratic corruption. For example people in USA shun deficits even though it is the source of money for the private sector. Everybody is for "cut the deficit". 

DEFICIT- NET IMPORT = NET PRIVATE SAVINGS, is simply unknown.When I tell people that govt deficit = private NON- deficit, nobody believes it. Also they think national is unsustainably large, whatever it means. 

This is verified graphically by Prof. Stephanie Kelton using published US data in
You have to open the link in a new tab to see the US data which is also another monetary sovereign.

Parthasarathy Shakkottai, Long Beach
Order by

Order by

Order by


OUTLOOK TOPICS:    a b c d e f g h i j k l m n o p q r s t u v w x y z  0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9   
Or just type in a few initial letters of a topic: