The Delhi police has moved a court here seeking copies of the CDs pertaining to the illegal 2005 phone tapping of Rajya Sabha member Amar Singh to ascertain if it has any link with eminent lawyer Shanti Bhushan's CD case.
Chief Metropolitan Magistrate Vidya Prakash issued notices to various accused of the 2005 case of illegal phone tapping of Singh and sought their replies to the police plea.
Police made the plea to the court as Bhushan had alleged that his name has been dragged into the controversy by lifting some part of conversation from Amar Singh's CD.
He had also alleged that CD containing his purported talks with Samajwadi party chief Mulayam Singh Yadav and Amar Singh on managing a Supreme Court judge was a "cut-and-paste job" to discredit the campaign for a strong anti-graft Lokpal Bill.
"Issue notice of this application to accused persons facing trial in FIR 152/2005
(Amar Singh CD case) with Special Cell," Chief Metropolitan Magistrate Vidya Prakash said.
The court also asked the investigating officer of Amar Singh's phone tapping case to file a reply on the plea.
The court order came on an application by the Special Cell of Delhi police investigating the Shanti Bhushan CD case of 2011 and seeking the copies of the three CDs recovered in the Amar Singh phone tapping case.
"During course of investigation, it was revealed that in FIR 152/2005 (Amar Singh CD case), three CDs were recovered at instance of accused Bhupinder Singh, which were sealed by the IO and the same were deposited in the
malkhana. Copies of those three CDs are required for investigation of the present case
(Shanti Bhushan CD case)," the police said in its plea to the court.
The police also told the court that during arguments against its closure report on Bhushan's complaint that the CD is fabricated, it was submitted by his counsel that part of the conversation in Bhushan's CD was lifted from conversation recorded during illegal tapping of Amar Singh's phone.
Former Union Law minister Shanti Bhushan had lodged a complaint in 2011 alleging that the CD having his purported talks with Samajwadi party chief Mulayam Singh Yadav and Amar Singh on managing a Supreme Court judge is fabricated to malign him.
The police had in January this year filed its closure report in the court of CMM saying the CD is genuine.
The court had rejected the police report for closure of the case saying it had not investigated the matter fully and had asked it to expeditiously probe the motive behind producing the CD.
Following this, the police had made a plea to take voice samples of Shanti
Bhushan, Mulayam Singh Yadav and Amar Singh for further probe into the case and the same was allowed by the court.
The persons who are accused in the Amar Singh phone tapping and CD case are Bhupinder Singh, a private detective, Vijay, Kuldeep Singh and Anurag Singh.
They have been booked under the Indian Penal Code for offences of cheating, forgery, criminal conspiracy and also under the Indian Telegraph Act.
A case was registered by the Delhi Police Special Cell on December 30, 2005 after allegations that Singh's phone was tapped by some unscrupulous elements. The conversation that was tapped was later recorded in three CDs.