Thursday 01 September 2016

Slaying Meghnad In Palashi

A study of the Bengali literary canon looks at pre-Tagore figures through both literary history and its historiography
The Literary Thing: History, Poetry And The Making Of A Modern Cultural Sphere
By Rosinka Chaudhuri
OUP | lxvi + 333 pages | Rs. 995

Perhaps no place on earth has spawned more poets than the lower delta of Bengal, and now­here has poetry been so intima­tely connected with the ideas of nation and nationality, culture and society. But the figure of Tagore has loomed so large over this landscape that other poets have often been consigned to the margins of this literary history. Rosinka Chaudhuri’s ambitious new study is an attempt to rem­edy this lack and throws light on early attempts to construct a Bengali literary canon.

The figures who constitute this canon are a group of poets of the mid-19th century: the prolific Ishwarchandra Gupta, the scholar-administrator Rangalal Bandyopadhyay, the nationalists Hemchandra Bandyopadhyay and Nabinchandra Sen, and of course, the trailblazing Mic­hael Madhusudan Datta. In the concluding chapter, the young Tag­ore’s waking to the ‘extraordinary dawn’ of Nirjharer Swapnabhanga (Awakening of the Fountain) serves as coda to this narrative. But as Chaudhuri points out, this is not an excursion into straightforward literary history. Rather, it tries to negotiate two parallel lineages: one of literary history and the other of the ‘history of literary history’—in other words, the first atte­mpts to write consciously about Bengali literature as an unbroken tradition which connected med­ieval poets such as Vidyapati and Mukundaram to those of the mid-19th century.


Chaudhuri’s choice of poets enables her to create a fruitful dialectic between these two narrative strands, and to argue for an understanding of Bengali literary modernity that goes beyond the standard formulation of western influence and res­ponse. One of the familiar tropes of post-colonial critical writing has been to read 19th century Indian literature as the empire ‘writing back’, a model in which western literary models are first absorbed and then retooled for local consumption.

In this study, Chaudhuri shows how much of early Bengali literary historiography was marked by an anxiety to disavow western influence and to identify a realm of ‘khanti bangali’ or ‘genuinely Bengali’ poetics. Several candidates are offered as exemplars of a pure Bengali style, notably the manuscript-era court poet Bharatchandra and Ishwar Gupta himself. Chaudhuri situates the Gupta-­kobi in a realm of demotic letters peopled by such figures at the composer Ramnidhi Gupta aka Nidhu-babu, and Mohanchand Basu, inventor of the half-akhrai. Rangalal emerges as the resolute champion of a new literary manifesto at the mid-century mark, in the introduction to his Padmini Upakhyan, written in resp­onse to an assertion that no good poetry could emerge out of Bengal. In this context, Chaudhuri could perhaps have looked at the role of the Vernacular Literature Society in the publication of the work. During the 1850s, for instance, the vls was instrumental in awarding cash prizes for original works of Bengali literature, and Padmini Upakhyan was among the first to win such a prize.

The case of Michael Madhusudan Datta is a tough knot to untangle. Mic­hael’s literary career is sui generis and forces Chaudhuri to read it in terms of a politics of remembering or ‘memorialising’, in which episodes in the poet’s life are mythologised as an “original event...a recurring, ceremonial date in the life of a nation”. It is not surprising that Chaudhuri devotes a half-chapter to the critical Marxist re-reading of Michael in the 20th century, part of a larger project to devalorise the so-called Bengal renaissance. Throughout the book, Chaudhuri moves productively between 19th and 20th century literary historiography, showing how concerns about authenticity, indigeneity and influence continue to be revisited in both. The last third of the book is chiefly devoted to Hemchandra and Nabinchandra, and their best-known works, Bharat-Sangeet and Palashir Juddha respectively. Both works are part of the incipient nationalist curriculum of the period, in which both poetry and prose become vehicles of a strategically reconstructed national history.


In her attempt to bring out the ‘local, political contingencies’ of the past, Chaudhuri manages to cover an enormous amount of ground, though she is silent about the impact of print on the construction of the modern Bengali literary sphere. In particular, it would have been interesting to examine how the socialisation of the printed book could have contributed to the consolidation of an incipient Bengali canon. But this is to take nothing away from The Literary Thing, a significant work of scholarship, and one that should spark fresh debates about the evolution of modern Bengali literature.

AUTHORS: Abhijit Gupta
OUTLOOK: 09 June, 2014
Download the Outlook ​Magazines App. Six magazines, wherever you go! Play Store and App Store

Post a Comment

You are not logged in, please Log in or Register
  • Daily Mail
These pacy thrillers put two southern cities on the crime map
MAGAZINE August 24, 2016
The dark world Harry & Co inhabit changes little after 22 years
MAGAZINE August 24, 2016
How a brutal LTTE directive was lost in the static of intelligence
MAGAZINE August 18, 2016
A RBI governor remembers his doughty fights, but cuts down on the math
MAGAZINE August 11, 2016
Book Extract
Abused by a relative at six, Laxmi saw how patriarchy tried to crush her femininity. And she made it come back to crush them, ‘those straight men with wives and kids’.
MAGAZINE August 10, 2016

In 1999, India and France entered into a $3.5 billion deal for the supply of these submarines. The first of the 6 subs is out on sea trials for the last three months and is to be commissioned later this year. At this stage, a newspaper in Australia has revealed secret data on the submarines, plausibly stolen from India. Indian Defence authorities have ruled out any pilferage of data from India.

POLL STARTED ON: Aug 26, 2016
Brazil’s Rio de Janeiro is hosting the 31st Olympic Games from August 5 to 21. This is the first Olympics being held in South America and is going on even as a majority Brazilians are unhappy with their rulers. Here’s a quiz on some random Olympic facts and related trivia.
QUIZ STARTED ON: Aug 11, 2016