Sunday 28 August 2016
facebook.com/Outlookindia twitter.com/outlookindia digimag.outlookindia.com instagram.com/outlookindia youtube.com/user/OutlookMagazine

'It Is For The Benefit Of The People'

On the role of judicial activism.
A simple postcard was enough for former chief justice of India Prafulchandra Natwarlal Bhagwati to convert it into a public interest litigation. It was 1985—a time for change in the Supreme Court and the beginning of judicial activism, as we know it today. Bhagwati retired in 1986. A decade later, when the role of the judiciary is a subject of great debate, Bhagwati spoke to Lekha Rattanani about this development. Excerpts.

Would you agree with Chief Justice Ahmadi that an activist role has been thrust upon the judiciary?

There are two theories about the functioning of the judiciary. One believes in judicial restraint and the other in judicial activism. When a constitutional issue comes before the judge, he has to make a choice dictated by his social philosophy. There are some like me who believe that the judge has to invest the law with meaning and content to advance human rights jurisprudence. When the executive fails to discharge its constitutional or legal duties and the legislature does not act, the judiciary has to step in. Though the judiciary is not elected, it is accountable to the people and committed to justice.

Is this increase in judicial activism a temporary phenomenon?

Judicial activism started in the early '80s when Justice Krishna Iyer and I delivered several judgements. It is not necessarily a temporary feature. But its intensity depends on the extent to which the executive or the legislature fail to perform its constitutional or legal duties.

You used to convert postcards and letters into public interest litigations. Is that where it all began?

I started public interest litigations in India and even entertained letters from social action groups. This was to vindicate the rights of the weaker sections because I found that justice was totally denied to them by our legal system. Today, when there is tremendous corruption and total misuse of power by politicians and the bureaucracy, the judiciary is the only bulwark and it has to act actively to maintain democracy and the rule of the law.

Of late, the judiciary has taken some decisions which are the purview of the legislature or executive, leading to criticism that judges have crossed the line.

There may be a few cases where the judiciary has strayed into the executive or the legislature's territory. If judges feel that democracy is in peril, I would excuse them if they exceeded their legitimate powers because what they are doing is for the benefit of the people. But a word of caution is necessary—for though the cause may be worthy, judges should not stray too far in a field not allocated to them under the Constitution, because that can become counter-productive and defeat the purpose of judicial intervention.

What corrective measures do you suggest?

The only solution is to develop people's power. The people must learn to assert themselves.

READ MORE IN:
AUTHORS: Lekha Rattanani
SECTION: National
SUBSECTION: Cover StoriesInterviews
OUTLOOK: 06 March, 1996
Download the Outlook ​Magazines App. Six magazines, wherever you go! Play Store and App Store

Post a Comment

You are not logged in, please Log in or Register
  • Daily Mail
THE LATEST ISSUE
CLICK IMAGE FOR CONTENTS
OUTLOOK ON TWITTER
POLLS

In 1999, India and France entered into a $3.5 billion deal for the supply of these submarines. The first of the 6 subs is out on sea trials for the last three months and is to be commissioned later this year. At this stage, a newspaper in Australia has revealed secret data on the submarines, plausibly stolen from India. Indian Defence authorities have ruled out any pilferage of data from India.

POLL STARTED ON: Aug 26, 2016
Quiz
Brazil’s Rio de Janeiro is hosting the 31st Olympic Games from August 5 to 21. This is the first Olympics being held in South America and is going on even as a majority Brazilians are unhappy with their rulers. Here’s a quiz on some random Olympic facts and related trivia.
QUIZ STARTED ON: Aug 11, 2016
Advertisement