Few Bland Men

In terms of scholarship, compared to the centenary year, the 150th year of 1857 draws a spectacular blank.
Revisiting 1857: Myth, Memory, History
By Boria Majumdar
Edited By Sharmistha Gooptu
Roli Books Pages: 218; Rs: 295
Anniversaries apart, 1857 doesn’t seem to hold much attraction for historians. There are perhaps only three living experts on it in the world. The field is thus wholly open to outsiders. The pitfall is that instead of researched books and monographs, one is more likely to find articles. Further, in moving away from the old debates about mutiny vs rebellion or local vs national, we have now moved beyond the event itself to its afterlife in various forms, even though there is still much to be learnt about it.

This collection has two earlier articles put together by the same editors, and some articles I’ve already heard of before. Apart from the mandatory historiographical essay, there are seven articles outlining how it has been remembered, written about or represented. That is not to say that the essays are not rewarding. Majumdar’s essay on contestations on the cricket field and Projit Mukherjee’s article on Scottish and English ballads are an illuminating read. What one misses in this, and other similar seminar-led collections, is a sense of advancement of our understanding of what the whole damn thing was about. All the dozens of seminars and hundreds of small papers have not been able to compensate for one big book by William Dalrymple; perhaps that is why a single quote from him appears in three different parts of this book. In terms of scholarship, compared to the centenary year, the 150th year of 1857 draws a spectacular blank.

Next Story : Exotic Toxins
Download the Outlook ​Magazines App. Six magazines, wherever you go! Play Store and App Store

Post a Comment

You are not logged in, please Log in or Register
THE LATEST ISSUE
CLICK IMAGE FOR CONTENTS
REVIEW
Review
Amjad Ali Khan’s recollections of 11 great classical musicians do have well-known details, but his anecdotes are lit up by a sense of ‘ethereality’
MAGAZINE May 25, 2017
Review
An anatomy of demonetisation, with little empirical data, sums up well, also directing the Centre’s eyes to issues nearer black money
MAGAZINE May 25, 2017
Review
This engaging history of the RBI—rich in events and tales of conflict over policy—effectively ends in 1981. What brings up the rear is biased, tepid stuff.
MAGAZINE May 18, 2017
Review
Getting into Jayalalitha’s shoes, Outlook’s Tamil Nadu correspondent reviews a book that seems to be only a poor caricature of Amma.
MAGAZINE May 18, 2017
Review
Sonal Mansingh’s metier enveloped her soul. At the forefront of a renaissance in performing arts post 1947, this is a celebration of a life danced to the full.
MAGAZINE May 18, 2017
read more>>>
Advertisement

OUTLOOK TOPICS :

A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9

or just type initial letters