A Broadsheet And Its Broadside

An interesting chronicle that reads in part like a diary and not a narrative of the sweep of history it witnessed
The Tribune, 130 Years: A Witness To History
By V.N. Datta
Hay House | Pages: 380 | Rs. 500

The Tribune is one of the few genuine newspaper trusts in the country, with no axe to grind by dint of ownership, community or ideology. Its founder, Sardar Dayal Singh Majithia, set out the credo in the paper’s first issue, published from Lahore as a weekly on February 2, 1881. It was to strive to serve the downtrodden and oppressed to build a modern, democratic, secular, egalitarian nation. Its trustees and successive editors have by and large fulfilled that mandate.

Advertisement opens in new window

Like its readers across the old Punjab, The Tribune suffered the trauma of Partition, and had to seek refuge in India—first in Simla, then Ambala and finally in Chandigarh. While driven by liberal, nationalist tendencies of the time, a rival view has it that Dayal Singh was concerned about the growing influence of those wishing to promote Oriental learning. He preferred to go with the new Punjabi elite who demanded an expansion of modernist English education, free of sectarian and caste influences.

The Tribune pleaded for a higher intake of Indians in the ICS, wrote of rural indebtedness and forest conservation at the cost of tribal rights, and sought the construction of the Bhakra Dam in 1937.

With the founding of the Congress in 1885, communal tensions surfaced. There were riots, Curzonian machinations such as the Partition of Bengal, the demand for separate electorates and rise of the Muslim League, though Punjab under the Unionists ran a broad Muslim-Hindu-Sikh administration. The paper was critical of the Congress’s tame policy of prayers and supplication.

Advertisement opens in new window

It protested Lajpat Rai’s deportation for “sedition”, rallied around Gandhi’s dynamic leadership post-1919 and articulated outrage over Jallianwala Bagh. The paper faced official wrath and censorship for its outspoken criticism. It opposed the idea of Pakistan, but with that fast becoming a reality, called for a modern state, free of religious bias.

The paper criticised the tame policies of the early Congress, supported Gandhi post-1919 and opposed Partition.

The Tribune was a casualty of Partition. Its editor had to flee and the paper compelled to close by August 15 to relocate in Simla to articulate the problems of refugee rehabilitation. It editorially accused “those whom Providence has made the architects of our destiny of being horribly unfair and unjust to the Punjabi Hindus and Sikhs, of accepting the Satanic two-nation theory and sacrificing them to it, of describing their unprecedented suffering as the price of freedom and then treating the payers of that terrible price as political lepers....”

In 1955, the Akalis launched a movement for Punjabi Suba. The Tribune backed Kairon in opposing what it believed could be another partition. But in 1971, it supported Fateh Singh’s demand for a purely linguistic Punjabi- speaking state. After the Allahabad High Court judgement quashing Mrs Gandhi’s election to the Lok Sabha, the paper called for her resignation. It later supported Operation Blue Star, but appealed to “Punjabiat” to heal the Hindu-Sikh divide. It deplored the destruction of the Babri Masjid and inveighed against the growing criminalisation of politics.

The book makes an interesting chronicle. However, it reads in part like a diary when it could have been a more absorbing, if selective, narrative of the sweep of history it witnessed.

Next Story : Pictures From His Mind
Download the Outlook ​Magazines App. Six magazines, wherever you go! Play Store and App Store

Post a Comment

You are not logged in, please Log in or Register
THE LATEST ISSUE
CLICK IMAGE FOR CONTENTS
REVIEW
Review
Lord Jagannatha’s Ratha Yatra is one of the great ritual showpieces in Hinduism. This meticulous study lists all, but leaves out the fascinating history.
MAGAZINE June 22, 2017
Review
The great Qurratulain Hyder could be wonderfully gossipy yet notoriously tetchy. Jameel Akhtar brings out the real person, her world and her creations.
MAGAZINE June 22, 2017
Review
One of India’s first female film editors, Patil’s story, shorn of self-pity, weaves personal and professional life and is also about breaking barriers
MAGAZINE June 22, 2017
Review
Arresting imagery and details bolster Salim’s realistic, sensual portrayal of the opposite pulls of small and big town life, as the Grim Reaper waits patiently
MAGAZINE June 15, 2017
Review
The horrific excess of the Inquisition in Goa is fertile ground for a writer. But this Konkani novel is an error-prone travesty at best.
MAGAZINE June 15, 2017
read more>>>
Advertisement

OUTLOOK TOPICS :

A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9

or just type initial letters