There are other questions too but it relates to their disability. Do the deaf and mute get adequate opportunities to defend themselves? And do the wheels of justice really move when they tug at them? "The answer' unfortunately' is no'" says Gyanendra Purohit of the Indore-based Anand Badhir Sangathan' an organisation dedicated to the deaf and mute.

Frustrated with the state of affairs' and desperately wanting to do something positive to change the status quo' Purohit and his friends lobbied with the police to find ways and means to sensitise law enforcement agencies to the problems faced by those who can neither speak nor hear. Quite a few doors were shut on their face but they were undeterred. One day' a window of hope opened. The police began to see and hear. Some cops and officials reacted with surprising compassion. Now' whenever the deaf and the mute knock' they get a patient hearing and their concerns are addressed.

However' old stereotypes die hard. Initially' the seminars and workshops had but a fleeting impact and attempts to teach the cops the basics of sign language only invited derision. "They made fun of us'" says Bobby Khatri' who runs a printing press.

"People often ask that if the deaf and the mute cannot speak or hear' why don't they use pen and paper to communicate with the world. The answer is that an overwhelming majority'almost 90 per cent of them'are illiterate'" says Purohit. Sign language is their only door of perception. And the cops' short on patience and time (even normal' educated people find an encounter with the police a patently unpleasant experience)' could hardly be expected to make the extra effort to comprehend what they are saying. "It's a fact that the deaf and mute often commit crimes against their own' similarly handicapped brethren'" says Kamlesh Dongre' who has not allowed his physical handicap to stop him from taking up photography as a profession. Cases involving the deaf and mute from all over the state are registered at this police station. Coordinators have been appointed in the big towns to help them deal with the police. After registration' cases falling in the jurisdiction of other thanas are transferred there but follow-up continues. "India got its freedom 50 years back' but thanks to communication difficulties and the way society mocked at us' we didn't attain freedom till 2002'" says Saju Stephen' the coordinator for Bhopal.