Order by Previous days letters
D-78/17
Sep 30, 2014
03:27 PM

Much of what Noorani says in Frontline is simply Nehru thinking aloud in the presence of his secretary. CAIR pracharak

So Nehru fantasized that Dulles, Bulganin and others offered India a seat at the Security Council, and that he turned it down? You have no evidence of this but even we accept this crap, what does it say about JackassLal that he had fantasies of turning such an offer? Only a fool would fantasize such things. 

Once again, we see the fanaticism, irrationality and dishonesty of CAIR pracharaks and their sickos buddies like bint Parrot. When your whole life is based on a lie - in one case, the Religion of Peace and in the other case, Marxism - lying becomes such a habit that they lie even when they don't need to.

Janwaar Bibi, BibiSarai
D-77/84
Sep 30, 2014
02:45 PM
R. Saroja
Bombay, India
D-76/2
Sep 30, 2014
02:38 PM

Sickos' love for Pakistan is unrequited too but it never seems to stop them from kissing paki ass every chance they get.

Janwaar Bibi
BibiSarai, Iraq
D-75/11
Sep 30, 2014
02:37 PM
Mohan
Adpur, India
D-74/36
Sep 30, 2014
02:36 PM

It all appears so contrived some publicity gimmick for the book why on earth would anyone start trending on twitter after a personal attack than report the matter to conerned authorities the twitter handle  running parallel to modi madison -the press fraternity seems divided coz didn't hear any of it from rival channels don't know what to make all of this 

bharati, Mumbai
D-73/7
Sep 30, 2014
02:36 PM

>> "Only apologists and obfuscators fail to see the connection."

>>>>>> "Only hate-filled morons fail to make a distinction!"

The onus of explaining the distinction between Islam and Islamism falls on the love filled intellectuals. 

D.L.Narayan
Visakhapatnam, India
D-72/3
Sep 30, 2014
02:34 PM


DLN,

>> "some petty minded people can't help nitpicking."

There are more nits to pick than have been picked yet. Let the Moditards celebrate for now! 

Anwaar, Dallas
D-71/1
Sep 30, 2014
02:05 PM

Quieter and less polluting Deepavali this year in TN.

R. Saroja, Bombay
D-70/2
Sep 30, 2014
02:04 PM

" "Kem chho?" is a good gesture, but MMS got a much bigger dinner party in the White House."

Maybe he was not given a big dinner party but Modi would not have had more than a sip or two of warm water.

It is beyond doubt that the new PM has had a great impact in the US. There were many who expressed apprehensions that his lack of fluency in English might impact negatively on his ability to interact with world leaders.

He has proved his detractors wrong repeatedly. His visit to the US so far has been an unqualified and unprecedented success yet some petty minded people can't help nitpicking.

D.L.Narayan
Visakhapatnam, India
D-69/10
Sep 30, 2014
01:47 PM

>> Post by WIAN - 2D says it all

Thanks.

Whats InAName
San Francisco, United States
D-68/6
Sep 30, 2014
01:29 PM


DLN,

>> "Only apologists and obfuscators fail to see the connection."

Only hate-filled morons fail to make a distinction!


 

Anwaar, Dallas
D-67/5
Sep 30, 2014
01:26 PM


>> " Islam is Islam and that’s it." Erdogan"

True! ISIS and Al Qaeda are not Islam. It is best to call them "Jehadism".

Anwaar, Dallas
D-66/9
Sep 30, 2014
01:22 PM

If slogan shouting in favour of Modi provokes a journalist, its time the journalist stop pretending as one and quiet  the profession!

madhukar nikam
Hyderabad, India
D-65/2
Sep 30, 2014
01:17 PM

Good vision statement.

Anwaar, Dallas
D-64/1
Sep 30, 2014
01:13 PM


"Kem chho?" is a good gesture, but MMS got a much bigger dinner party in the White House. In fact it was the first state dinner of the Obama presidency.

Anwaar, Dallas
D-63/5
Sep 30, 2014
12:46 PM


126 Muslim scholars present religious rebuttal to Islamic State


(Reuters) - Over 120 Islamic scholars from around the world, many of them leading Muslim voices in their own countries, have issued an open letter denouncing Islamic State militants and refuting their religious arguments.

An array of Muslim leaders and groups have publicly rejected the Islamist movement since it imposed its brutal rule over large areas of Syria and Iraq this summer. Five Muslim nations have also joined a U.S.-led military campaign against it.

The 22-page letter, written in Arabic and heavy with quotes from the Koran and other Islamic sources, is just as clear as those groups in condemning the torture, murder and destruction Islamic State militants have committed in areas they control.

"You have misinterpreted Islam into a religion of harshness, brutality, torture and murder," the letter said. "This is a great wrong and an offense to Islam, to Muslims and to the entire world." (Reuters)

(Nihad Awad of the Council on American Islamic Relations (CAIR), presented the letter in Washington on Wednesday.)

www.reuters.com/article/2014/09/25/us-syria-crisis-islam-scholars-idUSKCN0HK23120140925
 

Anwaar, Dallas
D-62/35
Sep 30, 2014
12:38 PM

" Also please note this headline. I would be happy if someone could enlighten me as to which TV channel Sardesai anchors after resignong from  CNN-IBN."

Welcome back, Bonita.

Rajdeep Sardesai is now with the Headlines Today group. Do not know where he stands in the hierarchy vis-a-vis Shekhar Gupta and Rahul Kanwal.

D.L.Narayan
Visakhapatnam, India
D-61/16
Sep 30, 2014
12:36 PM

I've said it before and I'll say it again. The editors of Outlook seem to be suffering from severe schizophrenia. One week they publish articles claiming Modi is an RSS puppet and the next, we have pieces like this claiming he and the RSS are on a collision course.

Please Outlook please. Make up your minds.

Bonita
Chennai, India
D-60/34
Sep 30, 2014
12:06 PM

The clip posted by Mohan clearly shows that there was NO physical contact till Rajdeep turned around and first caught the gent in yellow's hand and then pushed him. After Anwaar's knee jerk response to call the Modi fans BJP goons and fascists he has strangely gone silent. At least Saroja has had the grace that it was Rajdeep who started the fight.

Also please note this headline. I would be happy if someone could enlighten me as to which TV channel Sardesai anchors after resignong from  CNN-IBN.

Bonita, Chennai
D-59/21
Sep 30, 2014
11:59 AM

Ganwaar,

[[Banalities from two losers!]]

What can be more banal than "Islam is a religion of peace"?

Ganwaar
Ganwaarpur, India
D-58/1
Sep 30, 2014
11:57 AM

Agree with Mr. Mehta that our media's hoopla and hype in covering Modi's visit to US is completely over the top. 

Mohan
Adpur, India
D-57/8
Sep 30, 2014
11:53 AM

Post by WIAN - 2D says it all. No matter how many evidences are put in front of them, but these sickos will shamelessly brazen it out by repetetive lies. 

Mohan
Adpur, India
D-56/7
Sep 30, 2014
11:26 AM

Amazing level of propaganda being carried out by our discredited media. Even after the facts are out in the open, they are trying to brazen it out. These media feudal lords still don't get it that there is a social media now to expose them.

http://deshgujarat.com/2014/09/29/rajdeep-sardesai-attacked-a-person-his-fellow-media-persons-attacked-truth/

RSM
Delhi, India
D-55/8
Sep 30, 2014
11:05 AM

Did he bring a pair of J's slippers to keep on the throne ?

K.Suresh, Bangalore
D-54/7
Sep 30, 2014
11:00 AM

@Himanshu - "18 years for Jayalalita to get justice."

Sonia heaves a sigh of relief. Doesn't have to lose sleep over National Herald.

K.Suresh, Bangalore
D-53/5
Sep 30, 2014
10:56 AM

Looks like these congressmen won't rest till Modi converts to christianity. They should well remember what happened to Indian 'congressmen' in May 2014.

K.Suresh, Bangalore
D-52/3
Sep 30, 2014
10:53 AM

"Vindictive politics?"

Does it bring back to you nostalgic memories of UPA rule ?

K.Suresh, Bangalore
D-51/101
Sep 30, 2014
10:40 AM

And no surprise, his article has been endorsed by that white mughal Darlymple.

RSM
Delhi, India
D-50/100
Sep 30, 2014
10:38 AM

The Economist article by the idiot Patrick Foulis is downright racist and obnoxious. Some of these morons still think India is a colony ruled by them.

RSM
Delhi, India
D-49/4
Sep 30, 2014
10:22 AM

" Only morons fail to make a distinction between Islam the religion and Islamism of the terrorists."

Only apologists and obfuscators fail to see the connection. Religion inspires both saints and sinners. The focus should be on getting powerful and influential theologians and religious authorities to categorically clarify those scriptures that seem to inspire violence and thereby dissuade the gullible from drawing undesirable inferences. Ambivalence is not going to help. 

D.L.Narayan
Visakhapatnam, India
D-48/33
Sep 30, 2014
10:17 AM

- I am the guy assaulted by Rajdeep. My account @ http://t.co/fwlGYHarJX  #RajdeepSlapped #RajdeepExposed http://t.co/EeV4TYWHpI

Mohan, Adiiipur
D-47/6
Sep 30, 2014
10:17 AM
Once Panneerselvam set the ball rolling and the tears flowing, dare will there be any of the ministers following who will not do the obligatory duty of bawling like babies, wailing, lamenting and chest beating?

Woe to them for that will be perceived as the ever so little sign of disrespect and disloyalty to Amma and of course the oath reading paper seized from their hands even as they marched their way to hopefully exercise it.

Disgraceful and degrading circus of the ultimate kind which has put all of the previous TN sycophantic dramas to utter shame.

Non Fanatic, London
D-46/1
Sep 30, 2014
10:01 AM

They won't wail like this even if one of their own in their own family died....  Such a shameful circus....

Non Fanatic, London
D-45/1
Sep 30, 2014
09:56 AM

Modi, and India, take their place on world stage, writes David Cohen in this excellent commentary on Modi in US.   http://t.co/CKLbwgEbV5

http://t.co/CKLbwgEbV5

Mohan, Adiiipur
D-44/4
Sep 30, 2014
09:52 AM

JDU trying to regain the lost ground which they have lost after they parted with BJP.  Bringing up castism is the best way to day this. Modi in foreign lands is talking about development, prosperity and uniting everyone, whereas politicians in India want to drag our country backward through caste and religious politics. 

Mohan, Adiiipur
D-43/32
Sep 30, 2014
09:43 AM

Sagarika Ghose was beaten up by a diplomat's wife http://t.co/zte9uw197B | Interesting anecdote"

t.co/zte9uw197B

Mohan, Adiiipur
D-42/1
Sep 30, 2014
09:25 AM

To beget utmost satisfaction and pleasure,
journey through oneway road of Giving.
 

V.N.K.Murti Pattambi
PATTAMBI, India
D-41/3
Sep 30, 2014
09:00 AM

"Only morons fail to make a distinction between Islam the religion and Islamism of the terrorists." Janwaar

"These descriptions are very ugly, it is offensive and an insult to our religion. There is no moderate or immoderate Islam. Islam is Islam and that’s it." Erdogan

Janwaar Bibi, BibiSarai
D-40/2
Sep 30, 2014
08:17 AM

>> Was the Post a act of Nationalism

I have no idea what this means. Can anyone make sense?

Harun is fast becoming the Pappu/Bilawal of this forum. He only needs to start talking about women's empowerment/Kashmir to be upgraded to one of these "young" leaders.

Whats InAName
San Francisco, United States
D-39/3
Sep 30, 2014
08:17 AM

It is fine to criticize or mock; but The Economist came out as stunningly racist in this article.
One good come-out is that we all learn that no matter how much one pretend, the racism is not too deep; scratch a bit and it is out in open.


Just to underline the reality of our times, Indian External Affairs Minister was surprised when someone asked her view on possible breakup of Britain. Just goes on to show that how re-unimportant Britain has gone.

Santosh Gairola
Hsinchu, Taiwan
D-38/2
Sep 30, 2014
08:14 AM

The frenzied audience at the Madison Square Garden event had won tickets in a free ballot.

 www.huffingtonpost.co.uk/2014/09/29/narendra-modi-new-york-madison-square-garden-john-oliver_n_5898584.html

R. Saroja
Bombay, India
D-37/4
Sep 30, 2014
07:59 AM

The same "Editors Guild" that was begging Modi few days ago to let them in?

What a fall!!

Santosh Gairola
Hsinchu, Taiwan
D-36/6
Sep 30, 2014
07:39 AM

Standing by Rajdeep for what?
Abusing and brawling?

After this he-said/she-said thing, hope some 'media', not 'news-traders' (as he called it) publish his version.

Reflecting, rather than standing will make you realise that Rajdeep might be in prison if this guy file charges.
I doubt if there is any VIP treatment for an Indian journalist in US jails of soaps and bendings:

http://rajdeepthenewstrader.blogspot.tw/

When Rajdeep assaulted me
I write this for two reasons: to add context to what is evident from the Zee News video clip https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=54xGasucqAc ; to avoid a Rashomon like state and rebut Rajdeep Sardesai's attempt to paint himself the victim. He a big fish and has friends in the media, so he may succeed, but my job is to stand up.

Bored standing in the long line to get into MSG, I took a quick stroll and saw much media coverage, including the likes of Chaubey, Sawant and Sardesai. I noticed Rajdeep taunt a group of young Indians: He asked them 'Did Modi teach you to do this?..." i.e. shouting Rajdeep Murdabad.
Watch this video to see how Rajdeep was essentially trying to continue his 12 year hate-work in trying to tarnish the PM. http://indiatoday.intoday.in/video/rajdeep-sardesai-modi-crowd-frenzied-modi-fans-new-york/1/393219.html. Unable to get the 'negative' answers he's looking for, Rajdeep says 'So what you guys are saying is that the "Media" was unfair to Modi' (this part is not on videos I have seen). I immediately picked up his spin and shot back: Not the media, it is NewsTraders like you who are unfair. And I called him "NewsTrader No.1". This seems to have made him lose his mind: He removed his jacket, and walked over to me (this is the part in the zee news video) and started verbally abusing me ("arsehole" and other threat-cum-abuse). I was surprised at hearing the abuse and his threatening body language given his ever-cool studio self. I retorted with the same epithet. This led to his turning around and attacking me - grabs my collar and shoves me (guess its his privilege in his un-Modified India). I was left with no choice but to push him back.

I would urge people to note 4 things:
1. Rajdeep indulges in unprovoked tarnishing and demeaning of the Indian PM on foreign soil and Indians living there https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7F1XP9I49Fw
2. Rajdeep starts the verbal abuse / intimidation
3. Rajdeep starts the physical assault
4. Rajdeep turns around and spins victimhood - 'frenzied Modi fans abuse him'.

Is it even remotely acceptable for a senior Indian journalist to engage in unprovoked insulting of our elected PM on foreign soil while he's on an important diplomatic tour, and wilfully trivialize a unique event (by continuing his political battle with the PM) that allowed the NRI community and the Indian Govt to build a stronger bond?

I believe you just cannot carry your personal battle with your PM onto foreign soil and cause harm to the country.

While I reflect upon what next steps to take, I urge everyone to write to the India Today group condemning such dastardly behavior by their 'senior' employee. I request the media (i have no faith in NewsTraders) to take this message to their viewership.

I reflected much on this since then -- what explains Rajdeep's egregious, shameful and harmful behavior? A apt word in American local parlance sums it up best: He's a Hater.

Santosh Gairola
Hsinchu, Taiwan
D-35/5
Sep 30, 2014
06:47 AM

You are late. Rajdeep has been exposed and has gone in hiding. May be you can stand with him in the bunker

Maha
NJ, United States
D-34/3
Sep 30, 2014
06:46 AM

http://www.thehindu.com/news/national/bihar-chief-minister-claims-temple-was-purified-after-his-visit/article6458724.ece?homepage=true

"The Chief Minister’s remarks came during his address at a function organised in memory of the State’s first Dalit Chief Minister Bhola Paswan Shastri on Sunday. “During the by-poll in August, when I visited a temple in Madhubani district. My cabinet colleague Ramlakshan Ram Raman told me that the temple was cleaned and the deity washed after I left the place.”

Mr. Raman, Mines and Geology Minister, who too was present on the dais, immediately said he had not given any such information to Mr Manjhi at any point of time.

“I was not even present with the CM when he went to that temple. Neither have I given him any such information,” Mr Raman told The Hindu. “I do not have anything to say on this.”

Vinod Kumar Singh, Mr. Manjhi’s party colleague and MLC from Jhanjharpur in Madhubani where the Parmeshwari Devi temple is located, also disputed the Chief Minister’s statement.

“Nothing of the kind happened. I was present with the Chief Minister in the temple and stayed in my constituency for the next two days. There was absolutely no question of the temple being cleaned and the idol washed,” he said.

The temple’s priest, Ashok Kumar Jha, said the statement appeared to be politically motivated. “One cannot wash the deity, as she is made of mud,” he said."

**************************

This guy is crying "caste discrimination" in the same way that CAIR cries "Islamophobia" - they have an agenda and they will fabricate incidents as needed for their agenda. The mainstream press falls for it hook, line and sinker, and by the time truth comes out, people have moved on.

Janwaar Bibi, BibiSarai
D-33/1
Sep 30, 2014
06:39 AM

Was the Post a act of Nationalism

harun
chennai, India
D-32/2
Sep 30, 2014
06:29 AM

Wish every Babu or Neta charged for causing loss of 1 crore will have his property seized to make good the Loss.

For all this tall Talk,what has Modi done on the 71k crore loot in Maharasthra.

2.5K Crore Saradha has seen some specfic action.

How does one see his ED Action vindictive or plain accountability

harun, chennai
D-30/4
Sep 30, 2014
06:16 AM

Modi should say he will allow Christian Missionaries to carry out conversions, but only if they show that they are spending equal resources/spending equal efforts in converting Hindus, Muslims, Buddhists, Jains and Sikhs.  I have a strong feeling that Muslims, Sikhs and Buddhists would kill them.  Our religious freedom would satisfy Congressmen.  And we will get what we want.

P.B. Joshipura, Suffolk, Virginia
D-29/4
Sep 30, 2014
03:22 AM

Key weasel words here are "Then the pushing and shoving begins. A barrage of abuses follow." Notice that there's no mention about who's doing the pushing, shoving and abusing. Until then it was "Rajdeep is smiling" etc. but when it comes to the shoving, no names - why? Was it because it was Rajdeep started the pushing and shoving? He did, didn't he. It's quite clear from the video. Hence the weasel words to avoid saying that he started the physical altercation. Do you think he's not have directly named the other party if that gentlemen had started it?

Prashi
Mumbai, USA
D-28/4
Sep 30, 2014
03:17 AM

"What? Wow! That's a power move right there! Standing next to Wolverine and throwing out Star Wars quotes! Bear in mind, this guy was banned from entering the United States up until just four months ago for his role in the Gujarat riots! That's quite a turnaround for him!"

Hmm. He didn't try too hard it seems. Why should Modi quote from Hugh Jackman films? The event wasn't set up to honor Jackman! Only in such a case would this statement merit a thought. The rest of the stuff was just a series of non-sequitors. Stuff he said because he wanted to say it, not that it's relevant or funny. Fail, really.

Prashi
Mumbai, USA
D-27/2
Sep 30, 2014
03:10 AM

First time I've heard an unequivocal statement from the Indian govt. taking a firm stand with China. Just goes to show how weak Congress govts. and even the Vajpayee govt. was with China. None of them had the *you know what's* to make it clear where they stand vis.a vis China. Hats off to the Modi govt.

Prashi, Mumbai
D-26/3
Sep 30, 2014
02:07 AM

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=54xGasucqAc&list=UUIvaYmXn910QMdemBG3v1pQ

gayatri
madrid, Spain
D-25/3
Sep 30, 2014
02:00 AM

This is  an euphimism for allowing Christian missionary work in Tamil Nadu, Assam. AP etc. Details can be found in "Breaking India" by Rajiv Malhotra. Modi probably knows already.

Parthasarathy Shakkottai, Long Beach
D-24/2
Sep 30, 2014
01:50 AM


Shakkottal,

>> " Islam will not mind its own business"

Only morons fail to make a distinction between Islam the religion and Islamism of the terrorists.
 




 

Anwaar, Dallas
D-23/7
Sep 30, 2014
01:50 AM

@Saroja: It is better to stick with the truth even if you are a fan of Modi. An unplesant truth is much better than a plesant lie.

The economic balance is the difference (FISCAL DEFICIT - TRADE DEFICIT ) = NET PRIVATE SAVINGS and we want the left side to be maximized. This increases NET SAVINGS and FISCAL DEFICITS being free will promote skills and R&D for development and develop real can-do. Talking about skills won't develop any. Increasing FISCAL DEFICITS will. Can-do in rock concers will no-can-do to the real economy!

Parthasarathy Shakkottai, Long Beach
D-22/2
Sep 30, 2014
01:40 AM

And people claim that untouchability has been abolished!

Anwaar, Dallas
D-21/1
Sep 30, 2014
01:39 AM

If Goldman Sachs enters the fray, growth will stop. Look at Greece, Spain and Portugal.

Parthasarathy Shakkottai, Long Beach
D-20/1
Sep 30, 2014
01:38 AM

Interest rate cuts depress the economy. People on retirement will have to do with less income

and the economy will have less money to grow. This effect overrides the fact things will be cheaper for most consumers.

Parthasarathy Shakkottai, Long Beach
D-19/83
Sep 30, 2014
01:36 AM


DLN,

>> "What is communal about discussing historical figures like Mahmud Ghaznavi or Muizuddin Muhammad Ghori? Their glories have been well chronicled."

They were robbers who came to loot gold. You may keep yourself willfully ignorant of the glories of Muslim rule in India, but now you want to cynically tarnish it. But for a rabid hate-filled communalist like yourself this is not surprising.

Anwaar
Dallas, United States
D-18/2
Sep 30, 2014
01:32 AM

Nobody bases his vegetarianism on the fact that meats are not tasty. They base it on ecology and not killing living things.

Parthasarathy Shakkottai, Long Beach
D-17/1
Sep 30, 2014
01:28 AM

Whereever muslims live, they are afflicted with Jihad which is in their religion. Islam will not mind its own business but tamper with other peoples' religion and way of life.

Parthasarathy Shakkottai, Long Beach
D-16/16
Sep 30, 2014
01:28 AM


Much of what Noorani says in Frontline is simply Nehru thinking aloud in the presence of his secretary. Dulles and Eden must have known that there was no way China's SC seat could have been given to India, and Bulganin must have known that to have a sixth permanent member of SC a change in UN charter had to be made which the USSR had no power to do. The idea that the U.S. and the USSR would jointly work on the project of putting India in the SC is something that only simpletons like Fedup/Bibi would fall for. Remember this was the height of the Cold War!

Anwaar, Dallas
D-15/15
Sep 30, 2014
01:26 AM

The above excerpt from Prarthana Gahilote's piece proves 2 things.

1. She does not know what the Hindu growth rate means.

Where does Outlook find these idiots.

And what is the editor doing? Is he also unaware of the meaning and history of the term?

Whats InAName
San Francisco, United States
D-14/1
Sep 30, 2014
01:25 AM

Slow or fast, US will have to get out sometime and Taliban will be there and become India's problem. Pakistan should also worry. If you wrestle with a fellow who wallows in horse manure, you will also stink, as a proverb says.

Parthasarathy Shakkottai, Long Beach
D-13/3
Sep 30, 2014
01:24 AM

>> Rajdeep goes into hiding by claiming he wont answer such charges.

You mean Rajdeep has pulled an Anwaar?

Whats InAName
San Francisco, United States
D-12/3
Sep 30, 2014
01:23 AM

>>  Wow! Feku goes International!

Then why is pappu spending more time abroad?

>> Credit goes to the brigade of unpaid coolies, mostly NRIs.

Thank you.

>> The best they can come up with...

The coolies were able to do much better than some physicists, suffering from poor logic, dubious integrity, hatred towards the other, aversion to facts, and a propensity to run away from discussion when challenged.

Whats InAName
San Francisco, United States
D-11/2
Sep 30, 2014
01:19 AM

@1/D-11

Better than the tent burka (?) to be sure!

Parthasarathy Shakkottai
Long Beach, United States
D-10/2
Sep 30, 2014
01:18 AM

>> BJP/VHP psychpaths remain psychopaths even after they become U.S.citizens. They are like Islamist extremists. It must be in their DNA.

I have always appreciated the shamelessness of the sickos. The amazing ability to completely ignore all kinds of evidence, and brazen it out with repetitive lies in the high principles established by Goebbels.

This is an attitude we sanghis need to develop. We try reason and logic, provide evidence, engage in discussion, and more. Look at our Anwaars and Sarojas. They don't bother with these. Evidence, if they provide any, if often restricted to blogs of fellow travelers. They don't stick around to answer questions, engage in discussions, defend questions raised about evidence etc. They are experts in spitting, and then running away like cowards that they are.

Whats InAName
San Francisco, United States
D-9/1
Sep 30, 2014
01:13 AM


Modi is no Gandhi. He is just a poseur.
 

Anwaar, Dallas
D-8/1
Sep 30, 2014
01:09 AM

Vindictive politics?

Anwaar, Dallas
D-7/2
Sep 30, 2014
01:06 AM


Modi will respond with the same applesauce he gave to Fareed Zakaria!
 

Anwaar, Dallas
D-6/1
Sep 30, 2014
12:59 AM


BJP/VHP psychpaths remain psychopaths even after they become U.S.citizens. They are like Islamist extremists. It must be in their DNA.

Anwaar
Dallas, United States
D-5/15
Sep 30, 2014
12:18 AM

The well-known Sanghi A.G.Noorani quoting GoI minutes of Nehru's meetings with foreign leaders:

http://www.frontline.in/static/html/fl1902/19020810.htm

Nehru: "Informally, suggestions have been made by the United States that China should be taken into the United Nations but not in the Security Council and that India should take her place in the Security Council. We cannot of course accept this as it means falling out with China and it would be very unfair for a great country like China not to be in the Security Council. We have, therefore, made it clear to those who suggested this that we cannot agree to this suggestion. We have even gone a little further and said that India is not anxious to enter the Security Council at this stage, even though as a great country she ought to be there. The first step to be taken is for China to take her rightful place and then the question of India might be considered separately."

John Foster Dulles and Antony Eden (UK) asked Nehru if India was interested. He turned both of them down disdainfully.

***************************

The Russians would have supported us:

Bulganin: "Regarding your suggestion about the four power conference we would take appropriate action. While we are discussing the general international situation and reducing tension, we propose suggesting at a later stage India's inclusion as the sixth member of the Security Council.

Nehru: Perhaps Bulganin knows that some people in USA have suggested that India should replace China in the Security Council. This is to create trouble between us and China. We are, of course, wholly opposed to it. Further, we are opposed to pushing ourselves forward to occupy certain positions because that may itself create difficulties and India might itself become a subject to controversy. If India is to be admitted to the Security Council, it raises the question of the revision of the Charter of the U.N. We feel that this should not be done till the question of China's admission and possibly of others is first solved. I feel that we should first concentrate on getting China admitted. What is Bulganin's opinion about the revision of the Charter? In our opinion this does not seem to be an appropriate time for it.

Bulganin: We proposed the question of India's membership of the Security Council to get your views, but agree that this is not the time for it and it will have to wait for the right moment later on.

Given Nehru's refusal to even consider the matter, Russia moved on.

******************************

In short, the US, UK and USSR were seriously considering giving India the Taiwan seat. Only a jackass would have refused - and we were led by a jackass. Now we have CAIR pracharak and Saroja bint Parrot with their usual tactics - quote Nehru defending his own actions as "proof" that Nehru was not a jackass, and of course lies, distortions, and fabrications.

Janwaar Bibi, BibiSarai
D-4/5
Sep 30, 2014
12:16 AM

Total nautanki, saala..., Amma's remote control in TN politics....

K Sinha, Phoenix
D-3/1
Sep 30, 2014
12:15 AM

Modi, in turn, should raise the issue of safety for Sikhs. Sikhs do get killed in America, dont they?

Akash Verma, Chennai
D-2/15
Sep 30, 2014
12:07 AM

>> Yes let me name a few Pvt Medical Colleges which cater to discards from the US

You were talking about private ones, is it? Geez!

Before we continue, I want to see if you are any more than just a whiner. So, let's see if you answer my points about discrimination against outsiders, including NRIs that's unique to us.

Whats InAName
San Francisco, United States
D-1/14
Sep 30, 2014
12:05 AM

From the Sanghi Washington Post:

http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2010/11/08/AR2010110800495_2.html?hpid=topnews&sid=ST2010110402773

"India was offered a permanent seat on the council 55 years ago, in 1955. But that offer, made by the United States and the Soviet Union, was declined by India's first prime minister, Jawaharlal Nehru. Nehru said the seat should be given to China instead."

The offer was made to Nehru by John Foster Dulles during his visit to New Delhi. The US had realized that keeping Taiwan in the SC was increasingly untenable and was looking for alternatives that did not involve giving the seat to China. The Russians had their own motives - they wanted Taiwan out because it was strongly pro-US, but they knew the Americans would not acquiesce to giving the seat to China, so they saw giving the seat to India as an improvement over the existing situation. Antony Eden of the UK was OK with it and France did not particularly care one way or the other.

But in typical desi e-shtyle, Nehru turned down the offer contemptuously and told them to give it to China - after all, the Mahabharatha and Ramayan are full of filmi heroes making florid gestures of renunciation of worldly wealth and power to general applause and adoration (think Ram, Bharat, Bhishma, Ekalavya,...). The Americans and Russians probably rolled their eyes at the stupidity of the moron Nehru, the Chinese must have suppressed a smile, and the Pakistanis must have thanked their lucky stars they were dealing with morons who have learned nothing, no matter what terrible things are done to them by invaders over 1000+ years.

Today, we are out in the rain with our begging bowl in our hand, adopting the familair desi pose of righteous indignation and whiny self-pity, begging to be let in, while the Chinese block any move.

Janwaar Bibi, BibiSarai