The Sherlock Christmas special was released on New Year’s Day and thankfully sufficient time has passed for it to be fine to write a review with a few spoilers: I am working under the assumption that most (if not all) Sherlock fans have acquired this episode by now, whether with iPlayer or dubiously-sourced downloads.
Of course, it is entirely possible to write a review without spoilers. However in this case, the plot is so strange (arguably bordering on non-existent) that any discussion of why this special fails so spectacularly at everything it sets out to do needs a foray into the final bit of the episode.
Mediocre, flashy and dreadfully pretentious all at once, the plot shuttles between 1885 and present day as Sherlock tries to solve the case of a murderous bride who resurrects after her suicide to kill her husband and then decides it’s too much fun to stop. Her name is Emelia Ricoletti – a name that immediately reminds one of both Emilia in Othello as well as Emmeline Pankhurst, the militant 19th century suffragist raised by a radical socialist (another group that a Victorian Watson panics about without the least bit of irony). Natasha O’Keefe is appropriately melodramatic and wooden as the bride: it is appropriate because it is constantly clarified that no one takes the story seriously, least of all Sherlock.
But once the corpse bride with a ‘crimson wound’ of a mouth shoots her husband dead, things start going downhill. The slew of metatheatrical jokes about narrative, plot and characterisation sound like a list of boxes being ticked for possible entry into New Media modules. Mrs. Hudson’s irate line, “I am your landlady, not a plot device” is the only one that got a grin. The rest were so saccharined up by the Holmes-Watson bromance and repetitive (enough with the deerstalker already) that it was all more tedious than funny.
And finally, an unfortunate project: trying to make Sherlock a feminist enterprise. The effort was half-hearted and almost an afterthought. For one thing, the high point is when a man explains feminism to a room full of dangerously competent women. He lectures. They listen with the occasional angsty glare and quip. Meanwhile his direct audience is Mary Watson who has “put herself in danger” by discovering a bunch of militant feminists in (quite literally) the male imagination. Such a grand feat of patronising lite feminism could only come from someone like Steven Moffat.
Of course, Amanda Abbingdon, who plays Mary, has already defended the politics saying it that since all of it happened in Sherlock’s head, it is fine. This is a bit hard to swallow since the ‘real’ events – Sherlock sitting on a jet, incoherent from substance abuse, being bratty and brilliant-- do not take up more than fifteen minutes in a one-and-a-half-hour long show. And, most importantly, it is not even a lot of fun to watch. No one wants empty political correctness to dilute a good story, but it is unforgivable when lazy politics passing for sensitivity leads to an expensive costume drama and nothing better.
Honestly, if this is what a Christmas present from BBC looks like, I would much rather wait till 2017 in fervent hope that they will have time to create better written episodes for this once-beloved adaptation TV adaptation of the Sherlock Holmes saga. Since that has not happened, perhaps it is better fill the time with rewatches of McKellan’s majestic performance in Mr Holmes (2015) and Johnny Lee Miller’s frantic and credible Sherlock in Elementary.
Read Full Post
Director: Mahesh Manjrekar
Cast: Nana Patekar, Vikram Gokhale, Medha M Manjrekar…
Natsamrat, the movie is based on the play of the same name, a Sahitya Akademi winner, written by Jnanpith awardee Vi Va Shirwadkar, about twilight years of Ganpatrao Belwalkar aka Natsamrat (Emperor of actors), who is treated badly by his children after he gives away all his wealth to them, loses his devoted wife on the streets and dies deeply disillusioned but still in love with theatre.
It is one of those movies where the script, setting, set designs and the supporting cast, all seek to overwhelm you through just one character, the protagonist. And perhaps its biggest strength is also its weakness. The play, which has been staged several times by stalwarts such as Dr Shriram Lagoo, makes comparisons inevitable. The unavoidable problem then, is of raising the pitch higher than the previous production. Cinema as it is magnifies and amplifies drama on the screen and Nana Patekar, though extremely sincere and committed to the role, tries to take it a notch higher all the time. While one feels deeply for Belwalkar, an eccentric, foul-mouthed, drunkard but a caring genius, one wonders if the soliloquies from Shakespeare and other monologues, poems that are belted out one after the other, are in fact counter-productive at times.
The movie has been faithful to script except for two things – one, addition of several characters, scenes and locations, which may not have been possible in the play, to help the story unfold as on a cinema screen and secondly, addition of Vikram Gokhale’s character, a friend, co-actor and a mirror to Patekar. Gokhale outshines Nana in the few scenes that he has and this is one cinematic liberty that must be upheld as a brilliant stroke by writer, director. Medha M Manjrekar deserves a mention for her subtle and consistent performance as the devoted wife.
The trend of making iconic plays into movies may bring these classics to today’s generation but the beauty and success of it would lie in what is highlighted and what is not. Many of the problems faced by the characters and their reactions may seem a bit contrived for 21st century, a necessary bane for any revival of classics. Watch Natsamrat for what it represents; writer's brilliant depiction of a successful actor's downfall owing to betrayal of children, but whose subconscious simply refuses to let go of theatre. And yes, it is Shakespeare who rules. Always.
Read Full Post
Sooraj Barjatya is not done with cinema-going audiences yet. His next venture Prem Ratan Dhan Payo starring Salman Khan and fashionista Sonam Kapoor is set for release this coming Diwali. Those who are waiting for the movie with bated breath are regaled by yet another "all new" video song almost every day. But looks like something completely different, not to forget bizarre, is entertaining Barjatya fans today.
Read Full Post
It's been 20 years since Dilwale Dulhaniya Le Jayenge hit the movie threatres to leave its indelible mark on the audiences.
Read Full Post
Anisha Acharya, a student from Odisha, has made India proud by winning gold at the prestigious 2015 Student Academy Awards in the Narrative category. Having graduated from NIFT Bangalore with a degree in Accessories Design, she has now completed her Masters in Film Editing from the American Film Institute (AFI).
Read Full Post