POSTED BY Buzz ON Sep 21, 2011 AT 19:29 IST ,  Edited At: Sep 21, 2011 19:29 IST

A letter dated March 25, 2011 sent by the finance ministry to the Prime Minister office (PMO), over a month after former minister A Raja was arrested and had to step down from the Department of Telecom (DoT), has brought out the UPA's worst kept secret: a war within between its two seniormost ministers, home minister P. Chidambaram and finance minister Pranab Mukherjee.

The 14-page letter, written by Doctor PGS Rao, a deputy director in the finance ministry and addressed to Vini Mahajan, joint secretary in the Prime Minister's office (PMO) at that stage, was part of the factsheet on 2G submitted by Mr Subramanian Swamy at the Supreme Court today.

The revelations come a day after the CBI strenuously opposed Mr Swamy's plea for probing then finance minister P Chidambaram's alleged role in the 2G spectrum scam case.

The March 25 letter, which specifically mentions "this has been seen by the finance minister" [Pranab Mukherjee], says that if Mr Chidambaram , who was Finance Minister in 2008, had "stuck to his stand," spectrum could have been auctioned, instead of being given at throwaway prices on a first-come-first-serve basis.

The letter claims that had the finance ministry continued with the correspondence that it had initiated before the grant of licenses on 10 January 2008, arguing the entry fee of Rs 1651 crore was too low and that the 2001 prices should have been revised, the DoT would have had no option but to accede to the finance ministry's contention. Failing which, the letter says, the licences could have been cancelled.

According to the October 2003 Cabinet decision, the finance ministry is the ultimate authority in the spectrum pricing. These charges of Mr Chidambaram's complicity in the 2G scam had hitherto been made by the opposition, but now it seems that the feeling is shared by the current finance minister himself, who at least seems to be pinning the responsibility on the then finance minister.


This is not all. As the Pioneer's J Gopikrishnan, the journalist who broke the 2G Spectrum Scam story, reported today, even the government’s claim that minutes of the meeting between former Telecom Minister A Raja and then Finance Minister P Chidambaram on January 30, 2008 were not maintained has turned out to be totally misleading. They were prepared and signed by none other than then Finance Secretary D Subbarao:

The meeting, which took place 20 days after the controversial allotment of spectrum by Raja, reveals that Chidambaram said that there was no need to “revisit” the mode adopted by Raja for spectrum allotment.

“FM (Finance Minister) said that for now we are not seeking to revisit the current regimes for entry fee or revenue share,” said point No: 5 of the ‘hushed up’ minutes of the meeting between Raja and Chidambaram.

This observation of Chidambaram clearly shows that he had overruled the then Finance Secretary who had issued directions to stay the allotment of telecom licences and spectrum at the entry fee of Rs 1,658 crore, a price fixed seven years ago. The Finance Secretary had directed the stay on the spectrum allocation on November 22, 2007.

Incidentally, on January 15, 2008 Chidambaram wrote to PM Manmohan Singh to treat Raja’s dubious spectrum allotment as a “closed chapter”.

As the Pioneer story goes on to point out:

On deposing before the Public Accounts Committee, the then Finance Secretary Subbarao said that he had informed Chidambaram, before issuing directive to stay the spectrum allocation. The minutes of the meeting between Raja and Chidambaram shows that Finance Secretary’s objections were overruled by Chidambaram. Perhaps that is why the Government always claimed no minutes was prepared at all.

And now with Mr Swamy's fact-sheet submitted to the SC today, which includes the finance ministry's recent March 2011 note to the PMO to the SC, it is clear that the current finance ministry, under Mr Pranab Mukherjee, is making no secret of what it thinks of Mr Chidambaram's role.

The earlier story of the current finance minister's office being bugged assume additional significance in light of today's revelations and also explain some of the skirmishes between the UPA's two senior-most ministers.

POSTED BY Buzz ON Sep 21, 2011 AT 19:29 IST ,  Edited At: Sep 21, 2011 19:29 IST
Follow us on Twitter for all updates, like us on Facebook for important and fun stuff

Post a Comment
Share your thoughts
You are not logged in, please log in or register
Must See
Daily Mail
Sep 29, 2011
02:09 AM

 BTW, where is the "game changer" Rahul Gandhi? All he has to do is to give a speech and it will be a game changer. It will turn the tide favorably towards the govt. 

Sonia has lost control over the Andhra Congress. She has lost control over Pranab. No is in control of this govt anymore. Only the Messiah Rahul can step in and change the situation. Where is he? 

Sep 29, 2011
02:04 AM

 "Pranab for PM!!"

There is a distinct possibility that Pranab might not survive as a member of Congress-much less a minister. And PM?????? A very tall order.

Sep 29, 2011
02:03 AM

"Agree with Shyamal.... Pranab for PM!!"

I donot think he has energy to run for it. But he is certainly the most capable minister in UPA cabinet. He was instrumental in resolving Anna crisis after the uncultured/uncouth leaders like Diggi Raja were sidelined.

NJ, United States
Sep 29, 2011
01:48 AM

Agree with Shyamal.... Pranab for PM!!

The Irreverent Indian
Online, India
Sep 28, 2011
11:31 PM

Pranab da, who rushed upon his return from NY via N. Delhi to his native village in Bengal to perform the ritual of Pitri-Tarpan praying for his late father's soul to R.I.P., must owe his loyalty to the Mother-Nation, and not to an individual or a party. If he does not stand against the wrong doing of others against national good, his place will be at the same Raja's and other's.

Pranav da, let the truth come out. You have maintained your integrity, so do not compromise come what may. Let Chidu and MMS suffer for their wrongdoing.

Btw; in the event of Chidu and MMS implicated and forced to resign, you will be the front runner for the post of PM, and fulfill the dream of eight crore Bongs of Poschim-Bongo since independence.


Shyamal Barua
Kolkata, India
Order by
Order by
Short Takes
click for more
recent tags
Arts & Culture
Madhavi Tata
Moral Police
A. Sanzgiri
Boria Majumdar
Dr Mohammad Taqi
Freya Dasgupta
G. Rajaraman
K.V. Bapa Rao
Landing Lights
Maheshwer Peri
Namrata Joshi
Omar Ali
Our Readers Write Back
Outlook Web Desk
Outlook Web Desk
Prarthna Gahilote
Shefalee Vasudev
Srishti Gupta
Sundeep Dougal
Sunil Menon
recent comments
During the eighth edition of the Ramnath Goenka Excellence...
Poll Started on: Nov 24, 2015
Belgium may be famous for its chocolate, beer and for...
Srishti Gupta


OUTLOOK TOPICS:    a b c d e f g h i j k l m n o p q r s t u v w x y z  0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9   
Or just type in a few initial letters of a topic: