POSTED BY Buzz ON Jun 28, 2011 AT 22:28 IST ,  Edited At: Jun 28, 2011 22:28 IST

It started with what seemed to be an off-the-cuff, common-sensical remark, or so one would gather from the agency report carried over the week-end, in which the minority affairs minister Salman Khurshid was reported as having said in Chennai:

 

"Sachar Committee report is not Quran. It could be wrong and its recommendations and observations need to be looked at with a critical eye. The recommendations should not be seen as a special thing given to Muslims" 

Mr Khurshid was delivering a lecture, ‘Minorities of India: Issues and Challenges,’ at the Justice Basheer Ahmed Sayeed College for Women, last Saturday

Mr Khurshid apparently also asked the gathering why the Muslims were limiting themselves to community-centred issues and "also exhorted them to think on larger issues like corruption, human rights and Naxalism: “Why are Muslims silent on the Lokpal issue or on the issue of freedom for Binayak Sen." 

Some Muslim groups were quick to take offence, joining issue with his invocation of the Quran and terming it as "blasphemy, (behurmati)":

Salman Khurshid must quit the Government and the Congress

Regarding the non-inclusion of vital recommendations of Joint Parliamentary Committee on Waqfs and the Prime Minister's High Level Committee on Muslims (Sachar Committee) in Waqf Amendment Bill 2010 drafted by his ministry, Shri Salman has said in Chennai on 25 June that Sachar Committee Report is not Quran. This is blasphemy, (behurmati).

Earlier, in a letter to Zakat Foundation of India, Shri Salman said that the Joint Parliamentary Committee on Waqfs and the Sachar Committee cannot claim monopoly to wisdom (though he did not mention that he is weighing their wisdom against whose).

Does this mean that the Congress and UPA have been making fool of the Muslims for five long years in the garb of Sachar Report? Also, by saying this Shri Khurshid has opposed the Prime Minister and the Union Cabinet who approved the Sachar Report in 2007 and made the Ministry of Minority Affairs as nodal ministry to monitor implementation of the Sachar Report.

Shri Khurshid has also over-ruled the pivotal recommendations of the JPC on Waqfs without giving any reasons thereof while presenting the Waqf Bill in Parliament. Thus, he has violated the privileges of both the Houses of Parliament by showing down the Joint Parliamentary Committee (JPC) on Waqfs and hiding his non-compliance of JPC. Shri Salman has gone against the Congress and UPA policy regarding Muslim interests and against the collective responsibility of the central government which is the cornerstone of our sacred Constitution. Thus, he must resign from the Government and the Congress. Also, the Government, the Congress and the UPA should clarify their position vis-a-vis Shri Salman's statement committing blasphemy against the Holy Quran and rejecting the recommendations of the JPC on Waqfs and the Sachar Committee (most of which overlap).

As Seema Chinsti reports in the Indian Express today, the minister's remarks have also upset, among others, Dr Abusaleh Shariff, the economist who oversaw the writing of the Sachar Commission report, who has written an open letter to the minister, stating among other things:

“The Minister has a lot to answer as to how will he eliminate large deficit in achievement levels which Muslims have encountered during the last 60 years or so. This has occurred mostly due to discriminatory practices followed by successive governments including the Congress governments both at the Centre and the many states. Sachar recommendations are sensitive to mainstreaming and...points to the areas in which discrimination has occurred and Muslims have suffered.”

Shariff, who has been critical of the BJP and even Left-ruled states in the past, has written that “reservation” policy in India is discriminatory and keeps Muslims out of its ambit at the national level and in most states. “So are access to higher education and even primary schools. (On) public employment, the Centre is the most discriminatory. The banking sector has almost removed the Muslims from its programs.”

In something which may embarrass the government, he adds: “Pl(ease) note I am using the word discriminatory too frequently in this note but the Sachar report ...consciously avoided using this word, just to save the face of the government in power and we used some diplomacy; otherwise this report very clearly highlight the discriminatory practices. My new research is strong in highlighting how mainstreaming is not pursued by governments themselves and how public spaces are denied to minorities. Let the Minister come out with a strategy to bring diversity in public spaces (Schools, Universities, Urban Living spaces, government employment ...) which this ministry is silent about (for the) past five years.”

On his blog, Dr Shariff provided the following additional comments [carried unedited]:

When a politician is cornered, this is how he will speak - unintelligent and illogical.

He is facing the heat and practically boiled in 100 degree centigrade on the Wakf issue. But his general direction that Muslims should get going on mainstreaming and reaching out to other departments is in fact Sachar Philosophy and directions. Note that many Minsters have told me that indeed Sachar Report is used as a Bible for charting out pro-poor, pro-deprived and minority empowerment strategies.

Note his (Salman Khursheed’s) comment on EQC [Equal Opportunities Commission] - this is also Sachar recommendation, then how can he be so critical in the beginning, this is an example of double standards. Salman bhai will have a lot to explain.

The Minister has lot to answer as to how he will eliminate large deficit in achievement levels which Muslims have encountered during the last 60 years or so. This has occurred mostly due to discriminatory practices followed by successive governments including the CONGRESS governments both at the Centre and the many states. Sachar recommendations are sensitive to mainstreaming and as it does that, it points to the areas in which discrimination has occurred and Muslims have suffered.

The reservation practices in India are discriminatory and have almost removed Muslims from its ambit at the national level and most states. So are access to higher education and even primary schools. Public employment, the Centre is the most discriminatory. The banking sector has almost removed the Muslims from its programs. Note that I am using the word discriminatory too frequently in this note, but Sachar report - the committee consciously avoided using this word, just to save the face of the government in power and we used some diplomacy; otherwise this report very clearly highlight the discriminatory practices. My new research is strong in highlighting how mainstreaming is not pursued by governments themselves and how public spaces are denied to minorities. Let the Minister come out with a strategy to being diversity in public spaces (Schools, Universities, Urban Living spaces, government employment ......) which this ministry is silent about since past 5 years.

Note that I am marking a copy of this email to Salman bhai. I hope he will garner enough courage and seek support from his cabinet colleagues so as to officially sponsor a comprehensive evaluation of the 5-years after Sachar which will lay bare the truth. Note also that unintelligent reviews will begin appearing both in media and discourses during the next two years, and they will damage the credibility of the Congress Government. Therefore, it would be in the interest of the people of India, to come out with officially sponsored but independent review of the inclusive development reforms in India which have been undertaken during post Sachar.

I am also making this email to Just. Sachar and other members whose email I have retained in my address book.

Mr Khurshid explains his stand thus:

“ Sachar committee remains the central part of our minority manifesto. But there are some aspects that were not found feasible to implement even before I came to this ministry. Other aspects like the EOC that I believe is the next generation equality and equity instrument I am struggling to build a consensus within government. But each aspect has to be implemented in a manner that contributes to national bonding rather than a self driven separation. My assessment might be wrong but I have as much right to initiate debate as anyone else. Debate not dictation must be our approach. The attempt to stifle debate speaks ill of us. 

Mr Khurshid, while maintaining that "several Sachar recommendations were being followed,"  points out that the debate is: 

about how to approach the issue of helping Muslims. He underlined that he was against looking at just Muslims as the minority and not others.

“Exclusive delivery to Muslims as against ensuring equitable share amongst all citizens,” was not something he supported, he said. “In that context, I have requested a critical appraisal to ensure these are not used for ghettoization. It’s in this context that I said, for Muslims only the Quran cannot be questioned. All other books and documents are subject to critical scrutiny.”

Elsewhere, at Firstpost, R Jagannathan lists six reasons why Khursheed is right and Sachar and Shariff wrong:

  1. the lower economic status of Muslims is related to where they are located, and not (usually) their religion
  2. you cannot build a case for discrimination only by looking at areas where the numbers are stacked against the community.
  3. you cannot build a sense of empowerment among Muslims without talking about their success stories
  4. the Sachar data is highly biased.
  5. as Nitish Sengupta, points out, the lower economic status of Muslims in India was the result of partition
  6. Sachar completely ignores the internal factors that may be holding back Muslims.

Read more at Firstpost.

What do you think?

POSTED BY Buzz ON Jun 28, 2011 AT 22:28 IST ,  Edited At: Jun 28, 2011 22:28 IST
Follow us on Twitter for all updates, like us on Facebook for important and fun stuff
TRANSLATE INTO:


Post a Comment
Share your thoughts
You are not logged in, please log in or register
Must See
Daily Mail
Digression
34/D-47
Mar 23, 2012
02:41 PM

"A Parliamentary Standing Committee has pulled up the government for mere lip service to the recommendations of the Justice Rajinder Sachar Committee. The panel had been set up in 2005 by the government to study the status of Muslims in India.

The committee has pointed out that the government was not attending to the "crux of the problems" brought out in the report."
 

www.rediff.com/news/slide-show/slide-show-1-panel-blasts-govt-over-sachar-report-on-muslims/20120323.htm

Secu said since BJP opposes the implementation of Sachar Report so Congress is afraid 'derr jati hein ' to implement it .But Khursheed  has let the cat out .Let us see what this Govt will do on the report of the Panel .

a k ghai
mumbai, India
33/D-109
Jul 06, 2011
07:47 PM

Ghai,

>> Seems there is some thing seriously wrong with the Muslims themselves.

One would think so, but then one reads the bitter hate rants that you write, and one concludes that maybe the Muslims did opt for the lesser of two evils after all!

Anwaar
Dallas, United States
32/D-72
Jul 06, 2011
12:38 PM

Sachar report is the best thing which has ever happened in India. Its recommendations on education and reservation are outstanding. Its proposal of Equal Opportunity Commission is my passion."

Faruki

May be the best Report ever happened BUT BEST REPORT NEVER implemented,nor will ever be implemented and there is no will at all to implement .The Report is gathering dust since 2006 .

Fraudulent reason advanced by the Seculars like you is that
'Kaya karein Sanghi Report Lagoo nahin karney datey .Ham majboor hein ji bahoot majboor hein ji"

 On other hand they say Baba Ramdev is the Makhota of BJP and RSS .And Secus attacked with Lathis and Tear Gas appx  1,00,000 sleeping mass of children,women,old and infirm who were the supporters Ram Dev and RSS Sangh supporters .
 CONGRESSIS WERE NOT AFATAID OF BJP OR RSS while Hindus were were brutalized by their drunk Police men

Strange Muslims been trusting these lairs for the last 63 yrs.
Seems there is some thing seriously wrong with the Muslims themselves that
they are gullible to be hoodwinked for decades together by the Secus' false promises.Most of the Muslim leaders and intelligentsia are only self seekers.

"and then have the gall to say that the programs did not achieve their goals because the seculars had been paying only lip service! What nerve! "

Take this to Head of Raja Acedmy and a few more Muslims who have seen through the games of the Secus and have coined this "Appeasement by Lips only"
Only those who have closed their eyes ,minds have mortgaged their minds to Secus will not see it.

SIX YEARS BACK REPORT CAME NOT IMPLEMENTD YET !!!
 

a k ghai
mumbai, India
31/D-56
Jul 06, 2011
10:54 AM

Ramki,

>> " Sachar report is the best thing which has ever happened in India. Its recommendations on education and reservation are outstanding. Its proposal of Equal Opportunity Commission is my passion."

The above was said by Salman Khurshid, not me.

Anwaar
Dallas, United States
30/D-28
Jul 06, 2011
09:07 AM

Anwaar >> Sachar report is the best thing which has ever happened in India. Its recommendations on education and reservation are outstanding. Its proposal of Equal Opportunity Commission is my passion

Interesting to see someone talk about Equal Opportunity. Let us first start with Sachar commission. Why dont we have a Sachar Commission like equivalent for all religious, linguistic and leading caste groups? Let equal opportunity begin with equality of opportunity to have a state sponsored fact finding mission for every caste, religion and language group. Every caste, religion and language group has its own set of legitmate or illegitmate grievances, all need to be examined. Why stop with one religious group?

Ramki
Delhi, India
Order by
Order by
PhotosNewsBlogsLatest
Short Takes
click for more
recent tags
26/11: Terror In Mumbai
Children
Faiz Ahmed Faiz
Indo-Pak
Lashkar-e-Taiba
Media
Pakistan
Pakistan: Terrorism In
Peshawar
Taliban
Twitter
Zakiur Rehman Lakhvi
 
bloggers
A. Sanzgiri
Boria Majumdar
Buzz
Dr Mohammad Taqi
Freya Dasgupta
G. Rajaraman
K.V. Bapa Rao
Maheshwer Peri
Namrata Joshi
Omar Ali
Our Readers Write Back
OWD
OWD
Poster
Prarthna Gahilote
Shefalee Vasudev
Sundeep Dougal
Sunil Menon
ARCHIVES
Go
SMTWTFS
123456
78910111213
14151617181920
21222324252627
28293031
recent comments
Delhi government has banned all operations by private...
Poll Started on: Dec 09, 2014
More...
Alfred Nobel signed his last will and testament on...
Buzz
More...


ABOUT US | CONTACT US | SUBSCRIBE | ADVERTISING RATES | COPYRIGHT & DISCLAIMER | COMMENTS POLICY

OUTLOOK TOPICS:    a b c d e f g h i j k l m n o p q r s t u v w x y z  0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9   
Or just type in a few initial letters of a topic: