POSTED BY Buzz ON Jun 03, 2014 AT 22:27 IST ,  Edited At: Jun 03, 2014 22:27 IST

Thanks to Manoj Mitta's piece in the Times of India yesterday, Akshardham attack case: Decoding the other verdict of May 16, we revisit the SC verdict in the September 2002 Akshardham temple attack case.

As Mitta points out, 

While acquitting all the six persons who had been convicted by Gujarat high court , the Supreme Court has brought out many curious aspects of the investigations in its May 16 verdict

It is worthwhile reproducing and highlighting some of the concluding portions of the SC's judgement in extenso:

The investigation process post Akshardham attack happened as under: 

  • The incidence of Akshardham happened in the intervening nights between 24.09.2002 and 25.09.2002. An FIR was registered by PW-126 on 25.09.2002.
  • According to the instruction of Superintendent of Police, the investigation of the complaint was handed over to Police Inspector Shri V.R. Tolia (PW-113).
  • The investigation was then handed over to the Anti Terrorist Squad on 03.10.2002.
  • The investigation was thereafter handed over to the Crime Branch which was assigned to PW-126 on 28.08.2003 at 6:30 p.m.
  • The statement of PW-50 was taken at 8 p.m, on the same night of 28.08.2003, after receiving verbal instruction from higher officer-D.G. Vanzara in the morning.
  • A-1 to A-5 were arrested on 29.08.2003.
  • POTA was invoked on 30.08.2003.
  • The I.G.P. Kashmir sends a fax message to I.G.P. operations ATS Gujarat state on 31.08.2003 regarding A-6 being in the custody of Kashmir Police and that he has stated that he was involved in the Akshardham attack.
  • A-6 was brought to Ahmedabad on 12.09.2003 and was arrested at 9:30 p.m.
  • A-1 and A-3 confessed on 17.09.2003.
  • A-2 and A-4 confessed on 24.09.2003.
  • A-6 confessed on 05.10.2003.
  • A-6 was brought to Ahmedabad on 12.09.2003 and was arrested at 9:30 p.m.

A careful observation of the above said dates would show that the ATS was shooting in the dark for about a year without any result. No trace of the people associated with this heinous attack on the Akshardham temple could be found by the police. Then on the morning of 28.03.2003, the case is transferred to Crime Branch, Ahmedabad. This was followed by D.G. Vanzara giving instructions to the then-ACP G.S. Singhal (PW-126) about one Ashfaq Bhavnagri (PW-50). PW-126 was thereafter made in charge of the case on the same evening at 6:30 p.m. and the statement of PW- 50 was recorded at 8 p.m., i.e within one and a half hours. This shrouds our minds with suspicion as to why such a vital witness- D.G. Vanzara, who discovered the link to the accused persons, was not examined by the Special Court (POTA). The courts below accepted the facts and evidence produced by the police without being suspicious about the extreme coincidences with which the chain of events unfolded itself immediately that is, within 24 hours of the case being transferred to the Crime Branch, Ahmedabad.

The Supreme Court also raised questions about "the alleged letters" in Urdu that were said to have been found in the pockets of the blood-stained and bullet-ridden bodies of the two fidayeens:

102...Further, the post mortem report of the fidayeens (Ex.492) stated that all their clothes were stained Crl.A.Nos.2295-2296 of 2010 -204-with blood and mud and all clothes bore multiple tears and holes due to perforation by bullets. In such a case, the fact that the letters remained clean, without any tear, soiling or stains of blood and soil is highly unnatural and improbable.

103. Therefore, we cannot accept the recording of the High Court that the secret behind the crease-free unsoiled and unstained letter lies in the divine philosophy of “Truth is stranger than fiction” for this renowned epithet by the author Mark Twain comes with a caveat that says, “Truth is stranger than fiction. Fiction must make sense”.

Mitta concludes his piece by pointing out:

The case would not have gone to trial with such infirmities had Gujarat's home department — a portfolio then held by Narendra Modi — denied the necessary sanction for prosecution under POTA. KC Kapoor, who was principal secretary, home, admitted that that in the material placed before him for sanction, he had not seen any papers suggesting compliance of the statutory conditions. As a corollary, the SC said that the sanction was neither "an informed decision" nor was it on the basis of "an independent analysis of fact in consultation with the investigating officer".

The apex court added, "This would go to show clear non-application of mind by the Home Minister in granting sanction." The stricture on Modi didn't end with that. The Supreme Court said that there was "perversity in conducting this case at various stages, right from the investigation level to the granting of sanction by the state government".

The judgment acquires greater significance as it was delivered on the very day Modi-led BJP won the Lok Sabha election.

Read Manoj Mitta's piece at the Times of India: Akshardham attack case: Decoding the other verdict of May 16

Read the full Supreme Court judgement:

Crl. Appeal No.2295-2296of 2010

POSTED BY Buzz ON Jun 03, 2014 AT 22:27 IST ,  Edited At: Jun 03, 2014 22:27 IST
Follow us on Twitter for all updates, like us on Facebook for important and fun stuff
TRANSLATE INTO:


Post a Comment
Share your thoughts
You are not logged in, please log in or register
Must See
Daily Mail
Digression
4/D-5
Jun 05, 2014
12:16 AM

 Looks like Gujarat Govt haven't heard the words transparent governance or justice. 

himanshu
New Jersey, United States
3/D-74
Jun 04, 2014
06:32 PM

"The apex court added, "This would go to show clear non-application of mind by the Home Minister in granting sanction." The stricture on Modi didn't end with that. The Supreme Court said that there was "perversity in conducting this case at various stages, right from the investigation level to the granting of sanction by the state government".
 

Welcome to the guj-'rat' model of governing and criminal justice system under the then home minister modi which will be now implemented in the rest of the country.  "Those who do not remember the past are condemned to relive it"

T. Nayak
Washington, United States
2/D-49
Jun 04, 2014
03:20 PM

 His findings on the Haren Pandya murder case also sent several innocent Muslims to prison until they were set free by the Gujarat High Court

To be fair, the Muslims were given the option of getting implicated in Haren Pandya murder, Akshardham case or Godhra. (Gujarat model of police investigation)

Now back to the question of Akshardham attack- Were the two men who were killed by the commandos the only ones behind the attack? How did they manage to get weaponry? Why was there no proper investigation?

Similarly, in the Godhra case, we know that for whatever reason, no one from the mob was arrested in the first two days kafila.org/2014/03/15/the-fiction-of-fact-finding-modi-and-godhra/#comment-83884 

Already propaganda has begun to "dress up " Ishrat Jahan case. Those who value Truth & Justice should monitor the activities of this govt. In the first week of its existence, note the Special attention list -

https://pbs.twimg.com/media/BpH_2JOIEAARUjq.png:large

R. Saroja
Bombay, India
1/D-11
Jun 04, 2014
03:24 AM
Vanzara, the favorite police officer of Amit Shah and Modi, is at the center of so many fake cases, sending innocent Muslims to prison or subjecting them to fake encounters. His findings on the Haren Pandya murder case also sent several innocent Muslims to prison until they were set free by the Gujarat High Court.
 
 
Anwaar
Dallas, United States
Order by
Order by
PhotosNewsBlogsLatest
Short Takes
click for more
recent tags
Arnab Goswami
Bachi Karkaria
Constitution
Education
HRD - Human Resources Development
Indian Languages
Languages
Levity
Music
Rape
Schools
Sexual Harassment & Misconduct
Smriti Irani
Subramanian Swamy
Swapan Dasgupta
Tarun Tejpal
Tehelka
Twitter
 
bloggers
A. Sanzgiri
Boria Majumdar
Buzz
Dr Mohammad Taqi
Freya Dasgupta
G. Rajaraman
K.V. Bapa Rao
Maheshwer Peri
Namrata Joshi
Omar Ali
Our Readers Write Back
OWD
OWD
Poster
Prarthna Gahilote
Shefalee Vasudev
Sundeep Dougal
Sunil Menon
ARCHIVES
Go
SMTWTFS
1
2345678
9101112131415
16171819202122
23242526272829
30
recent comments
The three-language formula of the central government...
Poll Started on: Nov 21, 2014
More...
The United Nations just turned 69. How well do you...
Rimme Dirchi
More...


ABOUT US | CONTACT US | SUBSCRIBE | ADVERTISING RATES | COPYRIGHT & DISCLAIMER | COMMENTS POLICY

OUTLOOK TOPICS:    a b c d e f g h i j k l m n o p q r s t u v w x y z  0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9   
Or just type in a few initial letters of a topic: