The Wrong Turn: Trivialising Dec 16 Rape
The photographs were published on Raj Shetye's Behance page on July 26 but have since been taken down:
This is how it came to be.
To those who saw it, the series seemed not just to be at least loosely based on the December 16, 2012 incident in New Delhi when a paramedic student was brutally gang raped on a moving bus, an incident that shook the whole country, but also to be trivialising the serious subject.
So when news broke on social media today, the reaction on Twitter was overwhelmingly one of outrage:
No dearth of morons, a fashion photo shoot 'inspired' by the Nirbhaya gang rape.How seriously we take rape & human dignity in this country.— Gayatri (@Gayatriwrites) August 5, 2014
Also, whosoever came up with the Nirbhaya gang rape based fashion shoot , I hope they die a slow death.— Schrödinger'sCat (@stuffednstarved) August 5, 2014
Did i just see a fashion-spread depicting the Delhi gangrape of Nirbhaya? Disgusting!I hope all associated, die of shame! Insensitive swine!— VISHAL DADLANI (@VishalDadlani) August 5, 2014
How disgusting, a photo shoot "inspired" by the notorious Delhi gangrape. http://t.co/PUg8ObemAW. Page taken down since.— Samar Halarnkar (@samar11) August 5, 2014
Are we now glamourizing rape by doing a photoshoot inspired by Nirbhaya? My stomach just churned. https://t.co/OdtgMPG4ZP— Agratha Dinakaran (@Agratha) August 5, 2014
A Nirbhaya-inspired fashion shoot, themed: "Gangrape in a bus." CAN YOU BE MORE INSANE?? UNBELIEVABLE!!!!! https://t.co/jpfiD1sF2y— Aarti Madan (@AartiMadan) August 5, 2014
"It is not based on Nirbhaya," the photographer, Raj Shetye, insisted to Buzzfeed, referring to the fictitious name given to the Delhi braveheart.
The similarities, as many commentators pointed out, were too difficult not to notice, and when asked about the similarities, he told Buzzfeed:
“But being a part of society and being a photographer, that topic moves me from inside,” he continued. “I stay in a society where my mother, my girlfriend, my sister are out there and something like this can happen to them also.”
“Being a photographer, the only medium I can communicate in is photos. For me, its as simple as that. It’s art. Making movies, writing articles, making a poem — these are all ways of addressing the topic. Being a fashion photographer, this is what I can do best.”
“This is in no way meant to glamorize the act, which was very bad...It’s just a way of throwing light on it.”
In a telephonic interview to IBNLive, Shetye said,
"I wanted to throw light on Indian patriarchy and a male dominated society. I actually was using the photoshoot to highlight women's empowerment and lack of safety in India. It's not true that I used the Nirbhaya incident to create awareness. This is my depiction of the current situation using a medium I know and can communicate well in. Consider this. I did with photography what a writer would do if he had to write about that incident."
This is the official explanation by the photographer of the Nirbhaya shoot (Raj Shetye) as sent to a friend on FB. pic.twitter.com/qJveHT907K
— Suprateek Chatterjee (@SupraMario) August 5, 2014
But, of course, there was no explanation for why the series was tagged thus:
Despite this, Shetye managed to sound very righteous to Buzzfeed:
“On a personal level, too, I got many reactions. On my Facebook, from my friends. It makes me feel satisfied about my work — at least the work I did is so impactful that I’m able to shed some light on this. I don’t feel happy, but it makes me feel satisfied. That whatever I’ve tried to communicate is being communicated.”
It was only when the outrage made other media channels chase him down that the photographs were finally taken down, and he told the CNN-IBN:
"I did not want to glorify the Nirbhaya incident, this isn't even about that incident. I am a responsible person. Why would I do something that is in bad taste?...I admit this has taken a wrong direction and we are now doing damage control."
Jitin Gulati who features in the photo series apologised on Twitter on behalf of Shetye:
(1/3) This test shoot was done by Mr. Raj Shetge and the brief and intention was not even remotely to glorify an intolerable act like 'rape'— Jitin Gulati (@jitin0804) August 5, 2014
(2/3) I have removed these pictures from all public platform and the photographer has done the same. I sincerely apologise if this has..— Jitin Gulati (@jitin0804) August 5, 2014
(3/3) hurt anyone's sentiments.— Jitin Gulati (@jitin0804) August 5, 2014
In the end, as a Twitter user succinctly summed it up:
If until yesterday you hadn't heard of Raj Shetye but you know of him today, the object of his Nirbhaya photoshoot has been fulfilled.— Nigel Britto (@NigelBritto) August 5, 2014
- SC Seeks EC's Response
- Indian Woman, Son Found Murdered in US, Probe Launched
- Should Sidhu Be Allowed to Multitask?
- Aadhaar Not Needed For Mid-Day Meals
- Wonderful, Precise And Very Cool: How Do Our Money Up-Chucking Machines Work?
- "I'm Only Passing Through" 10 Leonard Cohen Songs That You Must Listen To
- Blackout For NDTV Stirs The Media
- Daily Curator: The Dominion Of Misunderstood Men Over Headlines
- Daily Curator: Of Holes Being Poked Into The Bhopal Encounter And The Origins Of Chyawanprash
- Watch: Viral Video Has Man Lighting Up A Line Of Crackers Attached To His Mouth
- Govt Staff in Bareilly Barred From Wearing Jeans, T-Shirts at Work
- Release Funds to State Bodies for Holding Matches: SC Tells BCCI
- 1984 Riots: SC Asks Govt to Give Files of 199 'Closed' Cases
- Counter-Terrorist Operations Claimed 92 Soldiers in J&K Since 2015: Govt
- PM Modi Calls Up Theresa May Over Terror Attack
- Dr Randeep Guleria Appointed New Director of AIIMS-Delhi