What Is Download Nation
Every night, Subir Singh comes home from work and gets down to business. While his family sleeps, the 23-year-old graphics designer switches on his PC (he assembled it with a friend a year ago) and starts surfing his favourite internet websites. Tonight Subir is looking for the latest jazz in Europe, for Japanese graphics that might inspire or amuse him and his colleagues at work, and for an American or Asian documentary. “It’s not an addiction,” he says. “I’m online only a couple of hours a night.”
Yes, only an hour or two, and then his computer takes over.
Subir is one of the 30-40 million young Indians who are staying up nights trawling the internet’s hottest fashion statement: file-sharing websites. BitTorrent, desitorrent, limewire, KaZaa, iMesh, DCTorrents, SoulSeek, Gnutella, Overnet, Morpheus and hundreds of other such oddly-named websites that are nothing but millions of computers exchanging large quantities of data. They are such a rage that in two January 2010 reports, India was declared the fourth-largest illegal downloader of content after the US, UK and Canada. The reports were commissioned by a lobby group for the six major Hollywood studios in India, one of the many businesses that say they are being harmed by the download culture sweeping across India.
“Even if the movies and games I download were easily available here, I would download from the net as they would be expensive.” Shantanu Malhotra, 23, Technical support, Dell, Panchkula.
In a tiny room in the house that he shares with his family, a couple of parrots and a few budgerigars also sit Shantanu’s PC and a laptop. Three terabytes of storage space bottle up 500 movies, 6,000 songs, 600 GB of games and 100 GB software. “If a game is seriously good, I buy it,” he says, though exchanging stuff online is a “social tool of sorts”. He spends anything between three and 10 hours online every day. “I was living alone and lonely. So I bought a laptop, and a friend taught me how to download movies.” Life hasn’t been the same ever since.
To see it for yourself, you just have to visit a cyber cafe, or steal a glance at your neighbour’s computer. Chances are that you will find at least a couple of downloads in progress. It could well be a software package, a music video, computer games, e-books or the latest Hollywood or Bollywood blockbuster. Almost everything you want is online, and available for download. “Yes, they are downloading away,” says Mahesh Murthy, who heads search-marketing firm Pinstorm. “In just the last one year, there has been a 60 per cent increase in people searching for (free) downloads. Largely, the surge is fuelled by the young and the very young.”
Sure, as any geek will testify, downloading from the net has always been around, from news groups a long while ago to irc to Napster, which ultimately got shut down. But over the past couple of years, fuelled by cheap broadband and the ease of use of new file-sharing tools like BitTorrent, downloading has gone mainstream in India. To understand where the real demand for downloads is, imagine a young, working professional in a city like Raipur or Vijayawada, where shopping malls and multiplexes are relatively rare and internet access is both a novelty and a much-needed window to the world.
The Torrent School Of Downloading
A torrent uses a file that can be split into smaller pieces and tracked across many computers. Each such torrent filename usually ends in “.torrent”. It's useful to transport large files, such as movies, games or software, across the internet.
“It’s addictive. And come on, let’s face it, I download because the download is free and accessible.” Ishita Ghosh, 26, Software developer, Calcutta
Ishita loves music, and so she downloads songs. Then she transfers them to a pen drive or CD. It’s addictive. “When I start surfing and downloading, it’s hard to stop,” she says. Quite naturally, her budget to purchase music, movies and books has shrunk. What worries her, though, is if she “inadvertently violates some security norm”. But then she reasons, it is very difficult to steer completely clear of violations. Her friends exchange notes on what to download: many of them “cannot even imagine” a time before downloads.
For businesses perhaps, all this file-sharing business is one enormous headache. But for many others, the pirate websites and file-sharing are just a sign of India’s internet story coming of age. “India definitely has a new breed of internet users, and they are progressively more tech-savvy, increasingly young, upwardly mobile, and living in smaller towns and cities,” agrees Savio D’Souza, the secretary general of the Indian Music Industry (imi). Earlier this year, the Internet Service Providers’ Association of India found 6.9 lakh songs adrift on 113 pirate websites. Of course, D’Souza says, the music industry is contemplating strict action, including shutting down the pirate sites.
But what would be the point? When one pirate falls, hundreds rise to take its place. Besides, there are also websites outside India, such as songs.pk, a Pakistani site hosting thousands of Indian songs that Indians adore. Whether surfing for porn or hunting for music hits, the online activities of Indians are so varied that they are increasingly difficult to monitor and control. To boot, their online ethic is increasingly permissive: the new Indian internet user will sidestep the rules as long as he gets his way. He might occasionally look over his shoulder to check if the law is watching, and then resume the download, because it isn’t.
“I don’t see free access on the Net as harmful at all…I believe that information exists to be shared.” Kasturi Rangan, 25, Gaming Consultant, Hyderabad
For a young entrepreneur who plays games all night, listens to music online, and downloads freeware software/movies/music, Rangan’s clear on two things. He can’t tell you the sites he downloads from. And he’s willing to pay for content, but “price it right”. “I wouldn’t dream of making rock stars richer by getting poorer,” he says. Information should be free, or have a nominal subscription.
Kasturi Rangan, a Hyderabad-based game consultant, typifies this clarity of thinking. “Think about it, if all that we do every day wasn’t as free as it is now, most of us would be illiterate in computer technology,” says the 25-year-old who won’t say where from he shares files online. That’s typical as youngsters such as him are not just cagey about being banned but also that file-sharing websites, whether free or paid-for, are so much in demand that subscriptions are often closed to new members, or are only by invitation.
It is the thought of thousands like Rangan, with their new-fangled ideas on access to information, that is giving the content industry sleepless nights. Rajiv Dalal, managing director, Motion Picture Dist Association, says that forensic examination shows nearly every Hindi title is camcorded within the first few days of its release in theatres. It’s just that online file-sharers have taken up where physical piracy left off.
“I download at home for several hours a day but can’t do the same at work, where access is not allowed.” Anish Chaudhary, 25, BPO employee, Delhi
Aquintessential service sector employee—young, hip, globetrotting—Anish started downloading simply because he had nothing better to do. “I started filling up my time with pursuing my interests online,” he says. Downloading content for free doesn’t worry him. “File-sharing or swapping isn’t commercial,” he says. And he knows enough not to download too large quantities.
And it’s not just the business moghuls who are worried at the trend. Tamil superstar D. Sarath Kumar actually chased two video pirates this January through the narrow lanes of Vyasarpadi, a city slum, for over a kilometre—and no, it was not a shoot for some film. He caught one and handed him over to the trailing police cars. Kumar’s heroics led the cops to a den of pirates no larger than Salman Khan’s shirt closet. Inside, 10 men were found making copies of his new movie, Jaggubhai. The film hadn’t even made it to the theatres, but it was already on the net.
Of course, finding “innovative strategies to make money from content online” is the holy grail for the industry. But then people accustomed to getting stuff for free are unlikely to pay for it now. “To an extent, industry is responsible for free downloads,” says Sanjay Tiwari, director, JuxtConsult. “What is the music or film industry’s online strategy? It hardly exists. They’ve been letting people access information for free.” Tiwari’s own survey found that half of regular internet users listen to music online. Not that all of this is illegal: it’s a mix of paid-for and free downloads, but no one knows how much is which.
“You have to see a film like Avatar in a movie theatre. But it’s more convenient to download most other movies.” Abhilash P. Methal, 24, Student, Chennai
Abhilash has heard about torrents but hasn’t downloaded anything with them because “iit has restricted their use”. Still, he spends several hours online a day and has free access, courtesy iit. He mostly downloads research journals, study material, free e-books and free code. The Kerala boy is curious about the Malayalam film scene, but if there’s an interesting clip, he’ll download it “irrespective of language”. He doesn’t download pirated videos or copyright content.
Saying Indians are cheap and don’t want to pay online is also a waste of time. Aren’t millions of Indians paying to access job and matrimonial websites? Aren’t they downloading billions of rupees worth of mobile phone games and ringtones? Guess which website churned $1 billion in revenues (the highest in all of South and Southeast Asia) last year? None other than the Indian Railways’s ticket portal, www.irctc.co.in. And who is buying millions of rupees worth of flights online? Clearly, there are other reasons why music, movies, TV series and software are downloaded and not bought.
“Indians believe in conserving their energy as well as their wealth,” says Dr Harish Shetty, Bombay-based psychiatrist. “Besides, Indians download all the time because of the joy of doing it in their private space.” It’s also a generational thing. Murthy cites the case of his 12-year-old son, who downloaded software manuals and, in a matter of weeks, surprised him by mastering a new package without any formal training whatsoever. “With formidably intelligent people like him all around,” the proud father says, “record labels, musicians, actors, directors, producers and software programmers will have to find new ways of making money. It won’t do to keep punching out CDs in the hope that consumers like him will keep buying.”
“Some of the material I downloaded was illegal or copyright-protected and I had an ethical dilemma.” Gurneet S. Anand, 22, Web marketing, graphics designer Chandigarh
Gurneet started downloading when he was so young that by the time he reached Class 10, he was over the movie and music craze, and had switched over exclusively to his passion—high-quality graphics, templates, art works, fonts and logos. He has a collection of around 50,000 photos, his image bank. He avoids copyright images, but wouldn’t buy pictures even if they were available. “Getting it free beats everything,” he says.
The music, movies and software industries know only too well that they cannot afford to be complacent. They are trying to cope by rejigging strategy. There are a variety of legal online options for people to buy from, be it CinemaNow, Vongo, ifilm, Movielink and others. There’s also a change in the mood and tone. Do we hear less strident talk of legal consequences? “Many states and companies are realising that the perceived cost benefit of piracy is eroded over time. And true, you can’t just rely on enforcement. You also need education and awareness. Cost is also an issue,” says Lizum Mishra, who heads Business Software Alliance, an international anti-software piracy lobby group.
One clear reaction is lower prices for original products. When Microsoft launched Windows 2000 in India (in 2001), it was priced at the international level—$200 a pop. Now, prices have dropped to around $22. In gaming, the popular Age of Empire now ships in a combo pack for Rs 999, three times less than two years ago. “Breaking price barriers is a simple and effective tool to encourage people to buy. Marketers are coming to terms with it,” says Prasanth Mohanachandran, most recently ED, digital services at OgilvyOne Worldwide.
“You can’t call it pirating because it is only sharing. We don’t sell (downloaded content) and make money.” Manjunath K., 24, Engineering graduate, Bangalore
Rip is a word that pops up regularly in Manjunath’s conversation. International docus and sitcoms, car shows, movies, music and sound-editing software are his favourite downloads (which he then rips on to his hard drive). This happens from 2-8 am, the time his isp allows free downloads. On an average, he downloads 4GB a night. “Earlier, I’d stay awake all night; now I’ve programmed my comp.”
But downloads are changing more than just prices. They are forcing industry to accept, bit by bit, that users will not buy content along expected lines. Take Rajjat Barjatya (of the famous Bombay film family). His four-year-old rajshree.com now hosts 1 lakh hours of free and paid-for content from his family’s production stable. Around 2 million free videos are viewed every month on the site. Rajjat’s strategy is to support free views with advertising, and charge users $9.99 to buy newly released movies ($4.99 for older releases). Still, Rajjat’s paid-for content has precious few takers—no more than 1,000 a month, he confesses, and mainly NRIs.
“I love watching streaming videos of all things that interest me. For the rest, I depend a lot on my friends.” Harshvardhan Sharma, 25 MBA, Mumbai
Harsh’s online adventure started in school when his family’s 3kbps dial-up slowly dredged up wallpapers and widgets. Now he uses broadband, which brings down 4-5 GB of open source software, video, images, movies and games a week. He and his pals share their acquisitions: some of them download 11-13 GB a week (more than 10 movies each). He mostly targets science, space and nature-related documentaries, stuff he “can’t necessarily access here”.
But at least he has demonstrated a new model, one that beats film star Sarath Kumar’s heroics. Meanwhile, across India’s cities, big and small, millions of computers are on, hard at work, late at night, downloading away.
By Pragya Sing with Chander Suta Dogra in Chandigarh, Dola Mitra in Calcutta, Arti Sharma in Mumbai, Sugata Srinivasaraju in Bangalore, Madhavi Tata in Hyderabad and Pushpa Iyengar in Chennai
Apropos of Torrential Reign (Apr 5), pirated dvds are available on the footpath for less than Rs 50, so why spend precious nights downloading? Okay, I understand the high prices you have to dish out otherwise, but there is also the cost you pay here in the shape of valuable time, which we Indians have still not taken into account. Kesra Ram, Hisar
What is wrong with downloading and seeing your favourite movie within a month or two of its US release? Nearly 65 per cent of the movies produced in Hollywood aren’t released in India. And why shell out 200 bucks in a jam-packed weekend multiplex? And it’s all there...every movie and music from every nook and cranny of the globe. The net is the global superbazaar. Download galore! Sanket Biswas, Calcutta
I and my friends were downloading using KaZaA, Torrents etc way back in 2004 (when I was in Chennai). I don’t understand the point of doing a cover on the subject in 2010. Or is it that your old fogey editors have been exposed to it now? Prasanth, Melbourne
The best way to increase download speeds is to get a top-flight windows utilities software like System Utilities 2010. My 256 kbps speed is now 520 kbps because of it. I give this software 5/5. Aditya Mookerjee, Belgaum
A very neat summary of the tech-it-or-leave-it products in India. Now if only the model had been “ware”ing the AsuseeePC instead of the HP Mini! Srinivas Shastri, Bangalore
We at Outlookindia.com welcome feedback and your comments, including scathing criticism
1. Scathing, passionate, even angry critiques are welcome, but please do not indulge in abuse and invective. Our Primary concern is to keep the debate civil. We urge our users to try and express their disagreements without being disagreeable. Personal attacks are not welcome. No ad hominem please.
2. Please do not post the same message again and again in the same or different threads
3. Please keep your responses confined to the subject matter of the article you are responding to. Please note that our comments section is not a general free-for-all but for feedback to articles/blogs posted on the site
4. Our endeavour is to keep these forums unmoderated and unexpurgated. But if any of the above three conditions are violated, we reserve the right to delete any comment that we deem objectionable and also to withdraw posting privileges from the abuser. Please also note that hate-speech is punishable by law and in extreme circumstances, we may be forced to take legal action by tracing the IP addresses of the poster.
5. If someone is being abusive or personal, or generally being a troll or a flame-baiter, please do not descend to their level. The best response to such posters is to ignore them and send us a message at Mail AT outlookindia DOT com with the subject header COMPLAINT
6. Please do not copy and paste copyrighted material. If you do think that an article elsewhere has relevance to the point you wish to make, please only quote what is considered fair-use and provide a link to the article under question.
7. There is no particular outlookindia.com line on any subject. The views expressed in our opinion section are those of the author concerned and not that of all of outlookindia.com or all its authors.
8. Please also note that you are solely responsible for the comments posted by you on the site. The comments could be deleted or edited entirely at our discretion if we find them objectionable. However, the mere fact of their existence on our site does not mean that we necessarily approve of their contents. In short, the onus of responsibility for the comments remains solely with the authors thereof. Outlookindia.com or any of its group publications, may, however, retains the right to publish any of these comments, with or without editing, in any medium whatsoever. It is therefore in your own interest to be careful before posting.
9.Outlookindia.com is not responsible in any manner whatsoever for how any search engine -- such as Google, Bing etc -- caches or displays these comments. Please note that you are solely responsible for posting these comments and it is a privilege being granted to our registered users which can be withdrawn in case of abuse. To reiterate:
a. Comments once posted can only be deleted at the discretion of outlookindia.com
b. The comments reflect the views of the authors and not of outlookindia.com
c. outlookindia.com is not responsible in any manner whatsoever for the way search engines cache or display these comments
d. Please therefore take due caution before you post any comments as your words could potentially be used against you
10. We have an online thread for our comments policy:
You are welcome to post your suggestions here or in case you have a specific issue, to directly email us at Mail AT outlookindia DOT com with the subject header COMPLAINT