AFP (From Outlook 25 February 2013)
What’s the score? Six in six months
Afzal guru
No Commuter, This President
Pranab Mukherjee’s reign will go down in history as a trigger-happy one
COMMENTS PRINT
opinion
An execution carried out to thundering war clouds
Arundhati Roy
Afzal guru
The fate of Kashmir’s trust in India is writ. Death by asphyxiation?
Showkat A. Motta
Interview
The co-accused in Parliament attack case, who was acquitted by the Supreme Court, on why he is shocked by the Afzal hanging
Panini Anand
Afzal guru
Jail staff didn’t mind the man given to books, poetry
Chandrani Banerjee, Amba Batra Bakshi
congress
Has the Congress lost its core values? In this new strongman avatar, is it becoming BJP lite?
Saba Naqvi
jump cut
Due to their own victimisation, Muslims may start viewing this as state vengeance....
S.N.M. Abdi

The President of India acted like a home secretary, says constituti­o­nal lawyer Rajeev Dhavan. At a time when the highest office of the land and the executive were totally in sync—playing a swift, active role in sending a man to his death—stinging appraisals can perhaps be expected.

Did Afzal Guru get a chance to app­eal against Pranab Mukherjee’s decision to reject his clemency plea? No. On February 9, he went to the gallows without knowing he could have made one last appeal—a proviso the courts of the land have upheld, to allow a man on death row to avail of every opportunity to save his life. The right to life is sacrosanct, says India’s Constitution. Even the state cannot take it away. And even the President’s rejection (or assent) on a mercy plea is subject to judicial review.

Post facto, questions are now being asked about the Afzal hanging. Could the President have acted otherwise? Could he have commuted the sente­nce in light of the fact that Afzal had already spent 11 years in prison, over seven of them on death row?

Old home ministry hands say the president has several options—death is the last of them. The death penalty is often seen as the remnant of a model of retri­butive justice that should have no place in a modern democracy. Yet, the law of the land thinks it fit to take away life in the rarest of rare cases—with the courts defining what such cases are. The President’s clemency power, and its subjection to judicial review, is part of the provided checks and balances.

Maybe Pranab deemed Afzal a fit case for hanging after weighing all options laid out by the law officers. Maybe, like the courts, he too was convinced the “collective conscience” had to be assuaged. But does Kashmir have a stake in the collective conscience? “The President has to weigh all the consequences of his action,” says Dhavan. Says ex-attorney general Ashok Desai, “The review of a death sentence is among the most solemn duties Presidents perform.” But he feels terrorism calls for a certain res­ponse—“a transparently fair trial,  but stern punishment for the guilty.”

Normally, when a mercy petition is filed, the home ministry sends it to the state government for comments. After factoring these in, it sends its recommendation to the President. In Afzal’s case, did home minister Shinde ask for CM Omar Abdullah’s comments? If so, what did he say? Did Shinde work against Omar’s comments? The home minister’s recommendations are binding on the President. The latter can request him to reconsider his advice once. But if the minister reiterates it, the door closes. Pranab did send the file back for reconsideration. When it came back to him the second time, he signed the death warrant. What he also did was not exercise the other Indian option: sitting on the file.


By Anuradha Raman in New Delhi

COMMENTS PRINT
opinion
An execution carried out to thundering war clouds
Arundhati Roy
Afzal guru
The fate of Kashmir’s trust in India is writ. Death by asphyxiation?
Showkat A. Motta
Interview
The co-accused in Parliament attack case, who was acquitted by the Supreme Court, on why he is shocked by the Afzal hanging
Panini Anand
Afzal guru
Jail staff didn’t mind the man given to books, poetry
Chandrani Banerjee, Amba Batra Bakshi
congress
Has the Congress lost its core values? In this new strongman avatar, is it becoming BJP lite?
Saba Naqvi
jump cut
Due to their own victimisation, Muslims may start viewing this as state vengeance....
S.N.M. Abdi
Follow us on Twitter for all updates, like us on Facebook for important and fun stuff

Translate into:
 


Post a Comment
You are not logged in, please log in or register
If you wish your letter to be considered for publication in the print magazine, we request you to use a proper name, with full postal address - you could still maintain your anonymity, but please desist from using unpublishable sobriquets and handles

PublishedDaily Mail
ABOUT US | CONTACT US | SUBSCRIBE | ADVERTISING RATES | COPYRIGHT & DISCLAIMER | COMMENTS POLICY

OUTLOOK TOPICS:    a b c d e f g h i j k l m n o p q r s t u v w x y z  0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9   
Or just type in a few initial letters of a topic: