Opinion
No Centre In The BJP
Once the party figures out who the high command is, and where it is located (Delhi or Nagpur) it can perhaps also try to make a few decisions. Till then the party simply withers away.

Every day I get calls from people expressing concern about the once mighty Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) withering away. Certainly the party has given way at the Centre. It now only survives in various forms in the states where it is in power. This week Sushma Swaraj admitted that “the BJP was going through a very bad phase” but expressed faith that they party would soon come out of it. 

Actually, the national leadership of the BJP is at sixes and sevens and has no clue what the future holds. Some paint a doomsday scenario, others blame the RSS for the paralysis, a few just get on with the day to day affairs of the party and, most disastrously, there is a group that is apparently busy making profitable deals, as long as it can. Perhaps the operators, petty favour seekers, ticket purchasers will be the last men standing in the party that once claimed to be “different”. Their stories are all pretty sordid and unprintable. 

The political reality is that if things continue as they are the brand equity would take a further beating and one should start considering the possibility of strong chief ministers forging regional parties on the ruins of the BJP. After all so many regional parties are off-shoots of the Congress during its years of decline. If the national image of the BJP takes a beating, is it so impossible to think of Narendra Modi running a successful regional outfit in Gujarat?

It certainly made sense for a politician like Modi to see the BJP as a vehicle for his national ambitions. But that moment has passed, and the national party may soon be more a liability than an asset for him. Similarly, Raman Singh in Chattisgarh is a solid politician who survives on his own merit although the base of the party there has been built brick by brick by years of work by Sangh parivar outfits. But politics is about taking things to the next level and Raman Singh has certainly managed that efficiently.

In Madhya Pradesh, Shivraj Singh Chauhan may be seen as too timid to ever consider a break from the parent organization the RSS or BJP, but given the state of affairs anything is possible. Currently, Jharkhand is the next state where the BJP is in with a good chance when the assembly elections take place in little over a month. But reports from the state suggest that there is a strong lobby in the party that is tempted to hawk and sell tickets in order to extract whatever it can from the golden goose. If that happens, the metaphorical goose will be slaughtered and no golden eggs will remain.

The bad news comes in relentlessly. Electoral disasters in Maharashtra and Haryana polls have starkly underlined the decline in the decision making and election management process in the BJP. Now the BJP government in Karnataka is being held to ransom by the infamous Bellary brothers who operate a huge mining empire spread between Congress ruled Andhra Pradesh and Karnataka. It’s all one big mess that is certainly not helped by the fact that the BJP is now so diminished at the centre.

Ironically, it is the Congress high command that will decide the fate of the BJP government in the critical southern state. If the Gandhis want to, they can give an indication to the Reddy brothers to pull the plug on the BJP regime in the state. But at the time of writing the Congress national leadership is also handling a tricky situation in Andhra Pradesh after YSR’s sudden death and would not want the Reddy bothers to have unchecked powers in two critical states. The fate of the Yeddyurappa government in Karnataka is therefore delicately poised.

As for the BJP, once the party figures out who the high command is, and where it is located (Delhi or Nagpur) it can perhaps also try to make a few decisions. Till then the party simply withers away.

 

 
Daily Mail
COLLAPSE COMMENTS :
HAVE YOUR SAY
Nov 06, 2009 05:30 PM
19
The long term solution will be to do away with the present parliamentary system and adopt the system proposed by Tagore and later endorsed by Aurobindo.
Ganesan
Nj, USA
whats the system dear kindly spell out
ganapathi
chennai, India
Nov 04, 2009 02:43 AM
18
' would give people lecture on rss.. '

Who runs the RSS?

The Marwadi money lenders, who are spread all over India, including the remotest hemlets lending money at the rate of ten rupees for hundred rupees for everry month. They take away the interest of the first month beforehand and they just give 90 rupees as loan
ahmad pasha
long island, United States
Nov 03, 2009 10:47 PM
17
Now Moaist marauders from WB like Jay Chakraborti would give people lecture on rss.. what is this aorld coming too
Anil Kumar
Toronto, Canada
Nov 03, 2009 09:21 PM
16
it surprises me that saba writes all the time on the bjp,and its problems. we are all aware of these.

for that matter many parties are faceing problems ie
the communists, lalloo ram, mayawati, jayalaltha.

muslims do not have a party of their own and they do not know whom they should support to obtain maximum gains.

it is laughable that saba instead of being interested
in her own community is happy takeing jibes at the bjp.

where are good muslim journalists,writers and other
good folks. the muslim community is badly in need of
inspirational figures. muslims need to stop wailing,
and do something for themselves. its clear that there are no outsiders who will rescue them from the hole they have dug for themselves.

what are the principle concerns of muslims. is it
to compete and get ahead or is to slide backwards
into the 7th century.

the situation on the ground shows that there is no
one around amongst muslims who can lead. and those
few who can,have no followers.

saba you should write about this. stop boreing us with
your petty jibes at the bjp.
gayatri devi
delhi, India
Nov 03, 2009 09:07 PM
15
Abhishek kayan
Lucknow, India

Hi Buddy

I see you are from Lucknow. What happened to that monkey who was made the head of the department of IT about two years back?
Is he still clinging to the chair or kicked off to the jungle?
ahmad pasha
long island, United States
Nov 03, 2009 08:56 PM
14
Abhishek kayan
Lucknow, India

Hi Buddy

You missed the first part. Read it again.

Mohammad's first wife,Khatija was a 40 year old twice widowed lady with children from previous marriages and he himself was a 25 year old bachelor.
And his second wife was also a widow, Sauda about 52 years of age and he was 53.

And regarding the marriage to Zainab, there is no concept of 'adoptation" in Islam. So he married this diovrced lady.
ahmad pasha
long island, United States
Nov 03, 2009 08:00 PM
13
Mr Pasha

Good that you told me, i will definitely read the book, right now i am busy reading various hadith, from where i come to know that Mohammed married a 6 year old girl called aisha, when he him self was 50+ and consummated that marriage when she was just 9 and also he married his mooh-bola son's wife named zainab.

Well this may not qualify as bed time stories, but my appreciation and regards for you ppl have gone really .. hahahah..

well also try to change your name, because next time u try to board a flight from US to any of the mullah-land u might end up being strip searched.. Hahahaha
Abhishek kayan
Lucknow, India
Nov 03, 2009 07:57 PM
12
My criticising the unwarranted reference by Saba Naqui to Nagpur,that is RSS,has sent this Harun into a tizzy.This should only be expected from him as a natural reaction.He calls my objection as a hate propoganda.Perhaps he may refer to me positively if i comment in glowing terms on organisations like SIMI or MIM.
S.S.Nagaraj
Bangalore, India
Nov 03, 2009 06:51 PM
11
We should not underestimate the power of 'liquor-barons'
ahmad pasha
long island, United States
Nov 03, 2009 06:47 PM
10
Abhishek kayan
Lucknow, India

Did you read the book,'Hindus-The Alternative History'?
Very interesting book, but very time consuming, you cannot skip a single line, leave alone a page.
Today I am on 264, where a Kashtriya kills the father of Purshuram and he retaliates by killing the 21 generations of Kashtriyas.

I read the story of Indira, who gets too drunked, and from his various body holes all the wild animals jump out.

Very good bed time stories,indeed.
ahmad pasha
long island, United States
Nov 03, 2009 02:52 PM
9
Mr Pasha

Seems like u have inherited a lot from you forefathers.. Was it babar or ghazni or ghori.. all great people right..

I feel so jealous looking at muslims world over, great achievers, contributing a lot to humanity.

Tell me one thing, "why every religion, every where in the world are u ppl hated", have u ever tried to look within..
Abhishek kayan
Lucknow, India
Nov 03, 2009 12:49 PM
8
My request to Vinod dont need Saba to write articles which vitiate ones mind.Just look at Nagarajs response the man just goes on and on with his propogation of hate.Is the author so dam naive that electoral fortunes and internal dissent is a part of everyday politics.Some take orders from Nagpur and others from Janpath.Whats wrong with that as long as they show some semblance of accountability.
drharun
chennai, India
Nov 03, 2009 09:08 AM
7
Saba Naqui's writeup is outright stupid.She has no knowledge about Karnataka politics.First,her hate filled mind thinks of Nagpur.But RSS thinks of only India,not like Number 10 Janpath which makes decisions to suit Vatican's strategies.The writer does not know the equations in Karnataka when she says that the Gandhis can pull the rug under BJP,if they want to.
S.S.Nagaraj
Bangalore, India
Nov 03, 2009 02:49 AM
6
Brahamin-Baniya Joint Party.

They have ruled and exploited Indians for thousands of years,that is enough.
ahmad pasha
long island, United States
Nov 03, 2009 02:40 AM
5
Proposed name for next mukhota "Bhartiya Janata Congress" and ideology ranging from Left to left-of-center(Not in reality just to fool ppl they would believe anything. They even believed that RSS stood for Swadeshi : ))
JayKay Chraborty
Kolkatta, India
Nov 03, 2009 02:37 AM
4
Like snake sheds its skin RSS has shed its mukhota from time to time. I believe the time is ripe for another shedding. Another feature has been that name has been changing to a more and more ambiguous form. Also at the same time the mukhota has been appropriating ideologies and Historical leaders left and right. Maybe this next one would appropriate Nehru(he is the only one left that has not been hijacked so far) and the one after the next one may appropriate Jinnah, everyone knows they are obsessed with him enough.
JayKay Chraborty
Kolkatta, India
Nov 03, 2009 02:19 AM
3
BJP's strength at regional levels and its weakness at the center suggest that good administration always trumps hindutva.
Anwaar
Dallas, United States
Nov 02, 2009 10:18 PM
2
The real question is "Is there a BJP?". And even more "Is the BJP required?".

I cannot honestly answer yes to above questions. What exactly does the BJP stand for? It stood for something when it governed. That is one side.

The other side is I do not see how a national party can emerge in India when the voting patterns are regional. The growth of too many regional parties hinders the growth of national parties. And contrary to the existing myth, Congress is not a national party either. They have better alliances at the state level. If those break, the party is as doomed as the BJP.


As long as national elections are fought over local issues, the very concept of national parties is meaningless. In such a scenario, I do not see any need for a BJP-with all its infighting and short sightedness.

The long term solution will be to do away with the present parliamentary system and adopt the system proposed by Tagore and later endorsed by Aurobindo.
Ganesan
Nj, USA
Nov 02, 2009 09:52 PM
1
Yawnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnn
Anil Kumar
Toronto, Canada
COLLAPSE COMMENTS   
Post a Comment
You are not logged in, please log in or register
ABOUT US | CONTACT US | SUBSCRIBE | ADVERTISING RATES | COPYRIGHT & DISCLAIMER | COMMENTS POLICY