Opinion
Diwali In Kalyug
The religious dimension has gone missing. We seem to have reduced it to commerce, chaos, and the fog that envelopes the city. Most Indians, living on the margins, are excluded from this bonfire of consumption.

I love lighting my house on Diwali, the daughter tried her hand at rangoli, the maid was delighted with her gifts, mithai boxes were distributed, I prepared and lit traditional oil diyas at a friend’s house, lost a modest sum of money at cards, and developed a respiratory allergy by the time the evening ended. 

It was Diwali as usual.

But watching the fire-crackers light up the sky, the wanton manner in which noise and air pollution continued in Delhi (all in the spirit of the festival of course) I have come to the conclusion that if we were industrially as advanced as western countries we would be one of the worst polluters in the world.

We are getting all indignant and self righteous about the climate- change debate and the idea of putting a cap on Indian industry. Good luck to our negotiators who must protect what they see as the national interest, but I do believe that we are not at the forefront of polluting the world only because we can’t do it. We just don’t have the power capacity and are not a developed society. But hey, we are trying our very best!

Our sloth and general lack of civic values would make us terrible polluters if we were a truly industrialized nation. And we would do so without taxing our conscience and not carry any burden of guilt. The entire climate- change debate is based on saving the globe for future generations. We are people who do not bat an eyelid before dumping our garbage in front of the neighbours home. We do not look beyond our own front porch, let alone the world or the future of the globe.

As for Diwali, besides the fact that it mucks up the environment, I also believe that we have devised an entire festival that is based on wanton consumption and destruction. Don’t get me wrong, I mostly enjoy festival season and the great sense of community that comes with it. But let’s look at the manner in which the so called celebrations have evolved. At one level, isn’t Diwali a wonderful cover to give and accept bribes, small and large, in the form of gifts?

The economy is supposed to be down, we are all bearing the brunt of the slow-down, yet there were traffic jams across the city in the week preceding Diwali as people shopped and zig zagged the city delivering gifts. With my own resources depleted and prices hitting the roof, I must confess to thinking resentfully: Who are the people who have so much money to shop? 

In Delhi, the huge hike in government salaries would certainly have dramatically improved the purchasing power of the large community of bureaucrats and government employees. But the main reason for the crowded markets, I suspect, is black money. There is still so much of it going a round that it has kept the economy afloat. In a country where a parallel economy thrives and no deal is signed without a kick-back, is it not in the natural progression of things that we have evolved a festival that legitimises bribe-giving and taking?

I know there is a religious dimension to the entire celebration. But, ultimately, shouldn’t all religion be about compassion? Most Indians still live on the margins and are excluded from this bonfire of consumption. Doesn’t true faith and devotion only come from simple living and high thinking? Surely not from a wild shopping spree followed by a reckless bursting of crackers? 

I love shopping, getting gifts and celebrating with friends and family. But see no higher purpose to the entire tamasha. There is only commerce, chaos, and the fog that envelopes the city.

 
Daily Mail
COLLAPSE COMMENTS :
HAVE YOUR SAY
Nov 10, 2009 01:54 PM
31
The author has rightly observed that Diwali is an opportunity to give bribe in the form of gifts in addition to the menace of noise and sound pollution. I personally feel that DIWALI is a fantastic opportunity to become DIWALIA(Bankrupt) for those who manage to save pennies for the occasion and golden moment for the poor and the down trodden to reduce their longevity. The occasion of DIWALI prompts me to rethink if the nation in which i am living is a developing or a developed one.
ANOOPAM MODAK
DELHI, India
Oct 27, 2009 11:45 PM
30
It is unfair for Saba to single out Diwali. It is true with all the religious festivals like Ganesh Festival, Navaratri/Durga puja, Id and Christmas, We have this issue with non-religious festivities like New year celebrations.
Maha
NJ, United States
Oct 27, 2009 08:28 PM
29
-25th Dec-
Drinking, partying,singing
shopping(Calcutta glitters in Park Street, Esplanade). Welcoming this intemperance is common in everywhere - celebrating this day.

-Eid-
Celebration goes on for min 5 days here with some mad mad spendings. Price hike of food items is a must during Ramadan here! There is a term called 'Eidi' (money given as a token of blessing)when younger people render Salam to their elders during Eids (remember, that's not bribe, Naqvi ji). Crackers are on in the nights of Shab-e-Barat.

Really love those days of festivals.
I think Naqvi is feigning too much anxiety about Diwali.
dip
Dhaka, Bangladesh
Oct 27, 2009 09:44 AM
28
The very intended caption of her story itself tells us what this Sabha Naqvi is made up off.But its not surprising for having mocked a Hindu festival calling it as Divali in Kalyug.This is part of a wider conspiracy to tarnish all Hindu festivals and its cultures.Earlier on Ganesh idol immersion in rivers and seas these kind of noises like that makes water pollution.The vested interests behind the conspiracy includes the white collared pseudo secular media,the notorious christian missionaries, the communists and the multi national companies.In order to help sell their stuffs cards and gifts on valentines day/fathers day/mothers day etc etc these multinational companies organise media debates to dig at the Hindu activists and call them as moral police and what not so that the younger generation of Hindus can be pulled out from its strong cultural roots.
Saba has no business and jurisdiction to poke her nose in any damn Hindu cultural events.why pick up Hindus alone as reasons for sound and water pollution.Are her brothers not polluting the atmosphere five times a day with those raised decibels.Its easy to advice the Hindus as they are peace loving and tolerant.
vijay
Bangalore, India
Oct 26, 2009 06:08 AM
27
Does Saba Naqvi have the guts or honesty to complain about noise pollution from calls to prayer from mosques?

Or the blocking of roads and throughfares by crowds spilling out of mosques?

I challenge her.

As always in India, people dare to whine about the disruptions and discomforts caused by religious observances and celebrations ONLY when these are Hindu. Rarely, rarely otherwise. And certainly NEVER in the case of the dishonest tribe that sports the name of "secular".

But this has nevertheless been a good week for the Hindus.

Uri Avneri has pointed out that Israeli archaelogy, no less, has debunked the historical claims of the Old Testament. No Exodus ! No Moses ! No David ! No Solomon.....!!!

Then what is left of Jesus and Mohammed, their supposed successors?

And Naqvi's article, dripping with malice and dishonesty in every line, proves that Hindu India is a truly liberal country: here Hinduism, the religion of the majority, canm be mocked and condemned. Who can do that without being torn to pieces in any counyry where Islam, Naqvi's religion, has the majority?
Momeen Rashid
Delhi, India
Oct 26, 2009 12:43 AM
26
Saba ji how about a all religious conference telecast by our secular doordarshan

The participants be allowed to speak without interruptions

Participants should be
Iman of Jama Masjid
Dalai Lama
Mrs Jaya row of the Vedanta vision
Swami Sukhboananda
Head priest of Akal Thakat
Dr Zakir Naik of the peace TV
A Representative of church of India

Telecast at prime time

That would clear many minds
aditya chopra
chandigarh, India
Oct 24, 2009 11:07 AM
25
Saba talk reflects her attitude,she seems to have no zest,spark for life,such are the people who can never appreciate the idea of walking barefoot shirtless in rain ,or taking a swish at the bhang of holi,gamble once in a while,burst or view a firework once in a while or walk aimlessly once in a while.Festivals are just a holiday the rejuvenate.The Hindu festivals are not like the festivals of her ilk where killing,eating and praying are the modes of celebrations
aditya chopra
chandigarh, India
Oct 23, 2009 09:54 PM
24
Saba
Your views are completely urbancentric.
Go to the villages and see how India celebrates it's festivals.
Ashok Mathur
Delhi, India
Oct 23, 2009 06:14 PM
23
Undermining everything HINDU is the favorite past time of SECULARIST and OUTLOOK publish all such rubbish.

The ulterior motive is CONVERSION. The Christians claim that Jesus is the only GOD and the Church wants the whole world to convert to CHRISTIANITY. Muslims "shout from the roof top five times a day, every day" that ALLAH is the only GOD and want to convert the world to ISLAM. If the CHRISTIAN and MUSLIM GOD (it is the same GOD- the god of ABRAHAM) is "so powerful"- why should mortal human beings in the form of PREACHERS and TABLIGHIS need to "convert" people??? Why doesn't their "all powerful GOD" convert all human beings to their religion???? After all "conversion" is just a change of mind involving NO MIRACLE LIKE CURING CANCER, WAKING UP DEAD etc. If CHRISTIAN/MUSLIM GOD can't even "influence the mind of people without preaching by "mortal human beings" - PREACHERS and TABLIGHIS- how can they save the human Kind???
Akil
Bangalore, India
Oct 23, 2009 01:17 PM
22
I really dont know what Saba is going to achieve by writing what she did,Is she planing to advice the pakis about how they should be conducting themselves as they have been proving to be a sham on the very faith they claim to be defending.It would be better for Saba to stop acting as a gaurdian of secular ethos by hitting below the belt.The nation faces so many crisis as a responsible journalist the least she could have done was to highlight the abuse of female rights among the muslims.
drharun
chennai, India
Oct 23, 2009 08:34 AM
21
suneet jain
memphis, United States

Probably you have read Saba Naqvi's only story so far.Please go through the list and you would find her as an exclusive anti BJP and Sangha parivar writer employed by OUTLOOK only to prove its secular credentials.She is known to have devoted nine of her ten stories only to dig at the BJP,Sangha Parivar,Hindu culture etc.She pretends herself as any modern and liberal Muslim only for public consumption but when her stories are read and understood she stinks of a an upright fanatic and a jealous Muslim.
Is only Hindu society,its culture have weaknesses and drawbacks.Is there no problem amongst her own community.Regarding the issue of the so called her courage raised by its not so but the fact that Hindus are religiously tolerant,liberal ,secular and broadminded and would digest insults and taunts.Imagine what would have happened to her if your sister Saba Naqviji would have ventured to poke her nose in the religious practices of the Muslims.She would have meted out with a similar treatment your another sister Taslima Nasreen had.
I agree that any religious celebration should not be converted into an extravaganza.But why pick up a Hindu festival alone.Its now known that there is a conspiracy behind all these attempts by the urban white collared, self styled liberal and secular class to dub every Hindu festival as creating pollution.Earlier there were heated media debates over Ganesh idol immersion to be causing water pollution and now the sound and smoke pollution of the crackers during Divali.Let Saba Naqvi look first into her own society which is invariably disturbing the peace of the surroundings five times a day.Is this too not a sound pollution where the decibels are raised deliberately.Are hundreds of animals not sacrificed on their holy day.Why try to paint divali in black simply because a few people are spending too much on that day,some are firing crackers distubing the peace and tranquility of those white collared apartment dwellers.Are we not spending money on fathers day,mothers day,valentines day when these are alien to us.If its freedom of expression then celebrating diviali according one's own wish and style too is freedom of expression.There is definitely a missionary hand behind all these media exercises.Time alone will reveal.
memphis, United States
vijay
Bangalore, India
Oct 22, 2009 06:14 PM
20
It never ceases to amaze me how the Jehadi Muslims and Fundie Christians never miss an opportunity to find some excess or some deficiency in one aspect or the other of the Hindu way of life be it worship of cow, burning crackers, infatuation with false gods and such other mundane things

So far as I can remember, I had known about the arrival of Diwali in the last five years or so from the ‘secular’ press- Indian Express, to be precise- by looking at the large photograph it invariably carries on its front page of school children in some Delhi or Ahmedabad based Christian fundie school carrying placards or wearing T-shirts with the message “We Hate Crackers” or some typically Christian fundie message warning you of impending damnation if you dare to think about Diwali.

In addition, you will be entertained with some write up by some person who claim himself or herself to be an educationist with a second name like “Adam” telling you about how these children have succeeded in educating their ignorant parents about the vile nature of these heathen merrymaking, not to leave the asthma aspect Naqvi also mentions because of pollution.

Similarly I come to know Diwali has gone by seeing the images of the morning fog and the trash strewn over everywhere .It is a surprise how the photographers reach the spots even before the Municipal sweepers

And what I have seen during either Christmas or some Muslim festival in the front pages? Oh, it is completely beautiful and’ peaceful’ picture. People kissing and hugging each other praying in churches and mosques that those who don’t believe in the true gods may be damned eternally

. I have never seen the picture of the heaps of the plucked feathers of the chicken and turkeys, the blood and gore of the slaughtered animals, not even any allusion to of the horrible screams of the stuck pigs.

Finally, if Naqvi could develop mild asthma during Diwali which is only once in a year event what must be her plight if she has been living in Iraq or Afghanistan? May Allah preserve her from asthma.
c p narendran
nagpur, india
Oct 22, 2009 05:18 PM
19
dr harun

i am sceptical of most indian journalists.

common trait amongst them is that they partial to
the left, congress, antiwest and ofcource very anti bjp.

looking from my place of residence in denmark, i feel
these people are antimodernists and at times very irrational. they are completely out of touch with the
mainstream thinking in the western countries.

indians are very upbeat compared to pakistan, but i dont see any great achievments ahead.

india has suffered from the population explosion of
the poor,deprived people- they blame those indians who have done better- if possible some of these morons would pin the blame for the poor monsoons, floods also on the middleclasses.

saba has nothing sensible to write- she is caught in
the familiar position of some muslims- helplessness, despair, and there after takes to hitting out at her preferred opponents.never any introspection .

i think muslims in pakistan are beter off. despite their bad situation in various things,they are at least free of the paronia from which many muslims suffer.

most of the deprived classes have given up. they are now content with blameing others.it will not do them a damn bit of good, as anyone with sense would know.
gayatri devi
delhi, India
Oct 22, 2009 04:53 PM
18
Gayathri
Just wrote what i felt about the article by Saba.She needs to get her facts right.The whole article was retrograde and smacked of insenstivity to fellow humans beliefs.At the same the sense of outrage is understandable ,may be Saba will exercise restraint when she uses her pen the next time.
drharun
chennai, India
Oct 22, 2009 12:58 PM
17
While "RELIGIOUS DIMENSIONS" in HINDU festivals are vanishing rapidly it is adequately compensated by the "increased fanaticism in everything Islamic".

Aren't the millions of animals sacrificed all over the world on "ID" not the creation of ALLAH?? Why must these animals die to please ALLAH who MUSLIMS claim propounded the ultimate religion of peace- ISLAM!!!!!!
Akil
Bangalore, India
Oct 21, 2009 10:36 PM
16
I salute you-Saba Naqvi. Very incisive and to the point. I admire your courage but at the same time dream of an India when a muslim journalist won't have to mention celebrating Diwali when she/he wants to criticize (and rightly so) the gaudy excessiveness that has penetrated such a beautiful tradition.
People like you keep me hopeful for a better and more compassionate India.
Jai Hind!
suneet jain
memphis, United States
Oct 21, 2009 07:56 PM
15
Saba this article stinks of biased and negative opinion against Hinduism.
It is very sad to know that literate people like you stoop down to such levels and misuse your freedom of expression.
Please write some thing negative about your religion or proclaim that there is nothing negative about your religion.
How old are you? I mean mentally.
Nandkumar Bhujbal
Mumbai, India
Oct 21, 2009 09:57 AM
14
Saba
I am surprised to see your insensitivity to others in writing this article.Is opposing every relegion or relegious practice called freedom of speach? There are a million things we can do to protect the environment or uplift the poors.Where is the wisdom of writing,the tolerence and feelings for others.Are you promoting harmoney by writing this or trying to get a few threats to ultimately have some security cover for you

Your article is in bad taste at wrong time and is offensive as these objectives could still be persued without a reference to Deepawali
Zakir Rehman
Sydney, Australia
Oct 21, 2009 08:00 AM
13
Saba Naqvi is right, 200%. We spend enormous amount of money for nothing.
Let’s talk about climate. The fireworks create instant issues with people suffering from asthma and other respiratory disease. The sound from fireworks is terrible. Every time the firecracker goes off, I miss a beat. Seriously I used to dread this time of the year. I used to stay in colony where these crackers make tremendous noise. I could not understand why we cannot restraint ourself.
Other things to consider about the child labour. Child labour is used for making firecrackers because they have nimble fingers. These people are paid measly for their labour.
I leave in Australia and we still celebrate Diwali, without burning firecrackers. For us burning sparklers marks the celebration. Offcourse we have get together. We do not play cards, neither have we given expensive gifts. Yet Diwali is still in our hearts and minds.
Pinaki Basu
Sydney, Australia
Oct 21, 2009 06:48 AM
12
Vivek Chatterjee
CALCUTTA, India
You are now a well known Hindu adversary and you find enough grass to relish in stories vented out by a masked and selective secular's like Saba Naqvi who is being paid only to dig at BJP,Sangha Parivar and what ever that is Hindu on a media like OUTLOOK.For the media she may be a secular jewel but for a ordinary Indian citizen people like her are no better than a side kick of a fanatic politician.
If any one rewinds all her stories they will find nine out of her ten stories being dedicated only to dig something or the other at the BJP and Sangha Parivar alone.Its a different issue altogether however that she has to answer a lot of the so many of the social ills her community is increasingly facing.
Its only a part of a larger conspiracy by vested interests working against India and Hindus in particular to raise the bogey of pollutions of various kinds arising from Hindu festivals.These are the cries of those white collared apartment dwellers.We have seen earlier how such craps raised their voices against Ganesh idol immersion accusing it as causing water pollution.
Communist like you invariably are attracted to anything that is against the Hindus as you guys propagate that Hindu means Brahmanism and that is against the oppressed.But why find fault alone with Hinduism.May be because Hinduism has the ability to stop the march of the Naxal and Maoist lumpen elements.
In a democracy every one has a right so is bound by the responsibility and accountability.In the name of freedom of expression your uncle that Mad.Fraek Hussein better known as a perverted artist made such deliberate attempts to denigrate Hinduism through his wicked and weird art forms.What would have happened to his arms and limbs if he had drawn something on his very Prophet like he did of Hindu goddesses.You may not want to describe that ugly and unpleasant incident if he went ahead with doing that.Every one has the same democratic right in the same vehement to protest when one's religious sentiments/beliefs are also hurt.
The communists like you now have tasted the craps of those evil jihadis and the notorious christian missionaries bait thrown in thin air at you.So you will stand by them to dig at the Hindus and pointing out those as Bhajrangis who protest in the same way as you are defending ant Hindus.When jihadis are attacked on a forum like this remember you idiot that its not directed against the Muslims.Its pity that you have a very thick skull.
vijay
Bangalore, India
Oct 21, 2009 02:00 AM
11
It was unwise of the author of this article to have rained on a Hindu parade, especially one as meaningful as Diwali.

Aside from some abusive posts, the objections raised by Hindu posters are quite valid: the stench from Id celebrations, the pollution from jihadi attacks, the waste of lives and the economy by the jihadi attacks on India, the poverty of some of Ms Naqvis co religionists etc.
Dr. Vijaya Rajiva
Montreal, Canada
Oct 20, 2009 07:15 PM
10
dr harun

you are one of the few thinking bloggers in this forum.

i have experience wrt environment and pollution from¨
my ngo -i started it- for 2 years in delhi.

i could not convince my own families to sort out rubbish in two containers, or do anything else.

high govt officials expected to be wined and dined
when meeting were held. politicians did not give a damn.

i got a lot of honest flak from foreign experts.

" why is india so dirty, asked the danish ambassador"
the experts in world health organisation were frustrated and disgusted.

" who the hell are you to teach us,they asked me"
it was 2 years of work down the drain.

your comments are rational and sensible. some of the
bloggers here are cretins. how can india progress with
such people.

it can not.
gayatri devi
delhi, India
Oct 20, 2009 06:47 PM
9
Well Saba is at it again.Relating Diwali to urban pollution is nothing but bull shit.Why were the cities any better before they got worse after Diwali.Its plain unfair if parallels are drawn between what has been a chronic problem with a acute one.Saba please do not invite unnecessary ridicule by drawing relationship between customs and urban chaos.Its no big deal if pollution increases on Diwali ,there a lot of efficent docs to take care of the sick.
drharun
chennai, India
Oct 20, 2009 06:21 PM
8
All religion is BS folks. Just accept it and move on
Vic Sangha
Toronto, Canada
Oct 20, 2009 05:31 PM
7
Leave Diwali alone. The writer is too naive & has fallen flat. No takers for such a gross attempt at grabbing attention/publicity. The least you have do is to Leave Diwali alone.

Any festival is about tradition, heritage. It is supreme & has an everlasting sanctity. You don't talk about wantonness, logic & reason. It does not have to evolve because teh basics are solidly in place. The very premise of this article is fallacious & it is lamentable, a credible name like Outlook India has fanned the idiosyncracies of a writer who seems to have very elemnetry notions about culture & tradition.

The society / genext is coming of age. So are business & politics. India is booming. You'll find "excesses" almost everywhere. A festival is a only a conduit to give vent to one's exuberence - be it Diwali, Holi, X'mas or any other. Bottomline? Do well to leave Diwali alone!
Lopa
Dubai, United Arab Emirates
Oct 20, 2009 01:57 PM
6
Saba areal incidental article.
The point regarding price rise, noise, pollution and excessive consumption has very little to do with Diwali.
And can be addressed without reference to Diwali.
I suppose the hook to get outrage, reaction or perhaps even a read is why you have mentioned Diwali at all.
Seriously you me and my neighbor should go on eternal fasts and live in mud huts and never never switch on the lights in this suffering country if we wish to show solidarity.
The point about celebrating Diwali is an invalid one if we continue to live the high life on all other days.
And Hindu brethren, please stop this anger you feel. Everyone has a right to an opinion and Hinduism rather than Diwali is not under attack.
please. It is embarrassing to have name calling and so on.
Bindu Tandon
Mumbai, India
Oct 20, 2009 08:05 AM
5
It is always easy to write against the practices of the Hindus,by someone like Saba Naqui.But,how wonderful it will be if she wrote on the stench generated by illegal slaughter of hundreds of animals on Eid days.The stench pervades for several days and any comment on this will be considered religious interference.
S.S.Nagaraj
Bangalore, India
Oct 20, 2009 06:56 AM
4
Saba naqvi,
More appropriate would have been to call it as Kalyug's divali instead of calling it as Divali in Kalyug.Because divali is being practiced by the Hindus in India and elsewhere even since previous yugs.
vijay
Bangalore, India
Oct 20, 2009 06:53 AM
3
Saba Naqvi.
On the issue of compassion remember that the fire cracker industry is feeding the mouths of thousands of poor families through jobs in the town where its being manufactured like Shivakashi.Objections are raised only by white collared communities staying in apartments.
Its the industrial pollutants that are the main cause of the pollution.Why join dissimilar issues here.You are only trying to search for the worms in some one else's wounds.
So many things are happening in Kalyug.While the divali is being celebrated even since previous Yug's till today this world hardly seen some new and strange kinds of fire crackers and bombs unlike those fired by Hindus during the Divali.Your jihadi brothers are often firing bombs not delighting the people around but killing them.Then there are those unique Fidayeens or human suicide bombers who are sacrificial goats blasting themselves for some noble cause.Dont you think that the Muslim community is not concerned of the compassion element you were talking about here.Is the noise pollution and the smoke pollution caused by frequent bomb blasts a concern for you.Two wrongs do not make one right.But the right thing for any right thinking person is also to tell both the wrongs with equal vehemence.What could have been a revolutionary change had your Jihadi brothers spent the money they wasted on those assault rifles and explosives for a better cause like helping poor and needy Muslims .
Divali is celebrated once a year with or without fire crackers but we are tolerating the sound pollution coming up five times a day and the air pollution caused by smokes coming out through frequent bomb blasts.Is there a religious dimension to this campaign against innocent Hindus.
vijay
Bangalore, India
Oct 20, 2009 06:29 AM
2
Saba Naqvi,
It seems like an eighth wonder of the world that your this story this time around on Divali dosent carry anything to dig at the BJP or Sangha Parivar as we all know that you devote nine out of your ten stories only to please OUTLOOK for the favors you received.But that in no way could enhance OUTLOOK's credibility as a secular media.For this I may even be axed.No big deal.
Its part of a well knit conspiracy to take on the Hindu culture in one way or the other starting with the very existence of Ram trivial issues like fire crackers during Divali is one such issue raised by the white collared,self styled liberals and selectively secular communities.Earlier they used to raise the bogey of the Ganesha idols immersion as to causing water pollution.I want these anti Hindu forces to remember that they are living in a land of the Hindus where all religions are equally respected and allowed free and fair practicing of their own religions.The ugly nexus between the jihadi elements,the notorious missionaries the Naxals and Maoists when are increasingly becoming threats to internal security the pseudo secular media is joining hands with the vested interests like the multi national companies in helping them take deep roots here.And what a better way to do it other than denigrate local culture.Call the activists as moral police etc.
Every one is trying to preach to the Hindus how they should be living.As if the western culture alone can be the remedy.
Pollution problem is caused more by regular pollutants rather than rare ones like happening during the Divali season.You have given a reason that Divali is not an inclusive Hindu celebration.You can find the traditional oil lamps lighting up in the home of poorer amongst the poor Hindus.How shame that you are lying in a public media.Fire crackers are not the hallmark of the celebration.You are unnecessarily trying to vent your jealousy and anger against the Hindu cultural practices here like how a typical communists raises the question of socialism in every damn thing.Why dont you advice other communities like the Muslims and the Christians as well on compassion and simple living and high thinking.While Hindus are igniting fire crackers there are jihadis who blast bombs killing innocent people.How shame that you are calling the entire celebration as a Tamasha.Its a pity that we have to bear the brunt of pseudo secularism through small timers like you.
vijay
Bangalore, India
Oct 20, 2009 04:19 AM
1
saba

i agree with you, because i have gotten myself involved
in the climate issue.

my take is a bit different- india,s population has
gone up from 320 million to 1200 millions in 60 years, which is a staggering increase. in india atleast this is the cause of many issues and problems


filthy and dirty sorroundings
poverty
climate change.

celebrateing devali, or christmas is a tiny problem.

just go for it. india is beyond redemption.
gayatri devi
delhi, India
COLLAPSE COMMENTS   
Post a Comment
You are not logged in, please log in or register
ABOUT US | CONTACT US | SUBSCRIBE | ADVERTISING RATES | COPYRIGHT & DISCLAIMER | COMMENTS POLICY