First Person
An Encounter With Delhi Police
An American journalist "walked literally into the middle of an altercation between at least four Delhi Police Officers, in uniform, beating a person". The police says he was drunk and trying to steal a taxi.
 
A few weeks back, P.Chidambaram, the home minister, asked
Delhi-ites to mend their ways before the Commonwealth Games. "We must behave as citizens of a big, good international city," he said. Clearly, Delhi Police thought it was not included. Joel Elliott, an award-winning American freelance journalist, working as a staff writer at Caravan magazine in Delhi since May this year, has  charged "six to seven hours of beating and torture" by Delhi Police, for intervening while the cops were thrashing another man. Delhi Police, on its part, insists that Elliot was drunk, trying to steal a taxi, and had beaten up a couple of police men and an elderly driver. Even if we go by the Delhi Police version, what  does it say about the rule of law in India's capital city and the way its police metes out instant justice? Following is the full text of the signed statement of Joel Elliott about the night of Oct. 5 and the morning of Oct. 6.

Background:
I am a journalist working for The Caravan, a narrative journalism magazine run by Delhi Press. I also freelance for a number of publications, including The New York Times. The Christian Science Monitor. San Francisco Chronicle and Global Post. I hold a Bachelor of Science degree in Journalism from Toccoa Falls College in Georgia, USA. My work has won a number of state, regional and national awards in the United States.

Narrative:
On the evening of Oct 5, I visited the home of Kate Webb and Ryan Fletcher, two freelance journalist friends of mine who were flying out to London at 5 the next morning. My own flight, to the United States, would leave in a few days hence, and so we wanted l" spend one more evening together as we three would not see each other again for quite Some time. Their home is in Jangpura Extension, as is mine. We are separated by some six or seven blocks, perhaps eight.

I became tired sometime around 2 a.m. Oct 6, and set out on foot, atone, to my home As I was walking in the darkness, I came around the comer of a building and walked literally into the middle of an altercation between at least four Delhi Police Officers, in uniform, beating a person beside the street. As I had not been paying attention, one police officer's baton struck me, perhaps by accident, while he was beating the other person on the ground. Startled. I shouted. When I realized what was happening to the person on the ground, I shouted again. The police officer closest to me turned and advanced, shouting something in a language I did not understand. I shouted back, saying they couldn't just beat people in the street. In the middle of the exchange, the officer swung his baton and struck me in the left upper arm area and began to raise his baton to strike again. I struck him in the jaw, and as he reeled back, turned and fled, turning off of the way to my home, as the officers were in the way. They gave chase, but I had somewhat of head start, and it was quite dark, so I was able to evade their line of vision for a time. It took me a few moments to find my way back to a road that I recognized. The problem was that they could easily catch me in their mobile command post. I began searching for a hiding place, and the most obvious places were in the row of cars parked along the left hand side of the road. I slowed to a fast walk, trying door handles to see if one were unlocked. I was hoping I could hide inside one of the cars until the polite passed, since I was afraid they found me. Door after door I tried, to no avail. The last Car I tried was an Ambassador cab -- I had been particularly hopeful about this car, because it had darkened windows. However, I had apparently chosen a car near Bhogal Marker that was parked next to a guard, or a driver, because someone came out of the shadows shouting. I tried to explain I wanted a hiding place, not to steal a car (after all my home was only five or six blocks away - why would I need a taxi?) But the man was shouting in a language I did not understand, and apparently did not understand me, either. His shouts alerted the police, who were already in pursuit, as was mentioned before, and they arrived quickly and surrounded me. Advancing quickly, they began beating me with their batons. In self-defense, I swung at, and connected, with a few of them, but I quickly went down beneath a rain of blows on my head, back, arms, thighs, shins, buttocks and ankles. The beating continued for some time after I had fallen.

They shackled my arms behind my back, so tight that to this date I have drastically reduced sensation in my left thumb. Then they shackled my ankles together and threw me bodily into the back of the mobile command vehicle. Three officers climbed into the rear compartment with me and resumed beating me, this time with their fists. They also slammed my face into the seat and into the floor, which action I was unable to resist, since my hands were shackled behind my back.

After some rime we arrived at what I later learned was the AIIMS Hospital. At the time, however. I was not aware of location, became the officers had continually slammed my head do»n and I was unable to see out of the windows for some time. They threw me from the rear of the truck and I landed on the asphalt hard, without being able to catch myself. Unable to walk, I found the skin being removed from my knees and lower body as the officers hoisted me up by my arms behind my back and dragged me into the hospital entry way. Again, at this point I had no way of knowing where I was; I believed I was in the police station. When a nurse emerged with a hypodermic needle, I began screaming for help and for someone to call the US Embassy. After the officers' rough treatment of me, I was afraid of what the syringe contained As far as I knew. the woman was an employee of the polite department. No one explained to me in English what was happening. I struggled, the officers held me down, and I finally was forced to be injected by an unknown substance -- one that later turned out to be a sedative. When the injection was complete, the officer again picked up my upper body and dragged me across ihe concrete floor and parking lot back lo the truck.

Once inside the truck, the three officers in the rear continued to strike mc in ihe fate and head as we rolled to the police station.

At ihe police station, the officers hauled me out of the rear of the truck and tossed me to the ground, still shackled. I began again streaming for someone to call the US Embassy to report this beating and continued torture. I lay like this for perhaps two hours.

After 15 or 20 minutes of my shouting for help, an officer came out and began kicking me, apparently angered by my calls for help. He did this one or two more times, as I still continued calling for help. After an hour or two had passed, several officers came out and dragged me into the police station, still scraping my lower body across the concrete. They threw me into a holding room with a concrete floor. I lay like this for perhaps a couple of hours, still shouting for someone to call the US Embassy.

Two officers came in two or three times and kicked me while I was lying on the floor, apparently to make me be quiet. In between these instances, they targeted the other person in the room, a young Indian man of perhaps 17 who had been sitting quietly near a table along the wall. One two or three occasion, two officers entered the room, and one held him down on the table while the other beat the soles of his feet with a baton. The young man screamed, but the beating went on and on

I am not sure whethcr this was the same young man I saw being beaten earlier in the morning.

Around 9 a.m., the polite asked for my street address and called for my flatmate to come and get me. At no point during the six or seven hours they had held me did they offer me any food or water. At no point did they offer me the Opportunity make a phone call. At no point until my release did they unshackle me. At no point did they contact the US Embassy, according to the Embassy itself. The police are required to notify the US Embassy the moment a foreigner is arrested.

My flatmate took me to the hospital for treatment. I was covered in blood from head to toe from the police beating. My pants, which were still on me. were torn to shreds, and covered in blood. My shirt had been torn from my body. The hospital staff, concerned about the gaping wound to the side of my head and blood clots in my right eye, combined with the massive bruising across the whole of my body, kept me at AIIMS Hospital for two days and one night. I received five stitches to my eyebrow

Conclusion:
I request a thorough inquiry into the six to seven hours of beating and torture I endured at the hands, feet and batons of Delhi Police. I request that the police officers responsible be removed ftom their positions

Further, I seek $500,000 US dollars in compensation for pain and suffering and mental anguish the Delhi Police inflicted upon me.

Date: October 8, 2009
Time: 4 p.m
Place: New Delhi

India address:
Second floor, N-31 B, Jungpura Extension, New Delhi

 

 
Daily Mail
COLLAPSE COMMENTS :
HAVE YOUR SAY
Oct 13, 2009 04:34 PM
10
All this only show, that you need to be a westerner, at least a fair one, preferably a woman, to get the sympathy you deserve from the Indian press, and through them, the Indian public.

If you were a native, black male, who will listen to your woes?
Partha persistent spammer
chennai, India
Oct 13, 2009 01:42 PM
9
What happed to joel was wrong. It is embarrassing for all of us, but really, expectable. This is india today.
everyone just complains about the police in delhi/india. no one looks at the situation/country/world from their point of view to try to understand what they have to deal with/what they are faced with, daily.
Many years ago my wife was arrested for not paying a bribe to an electricity junior engineer. Every six months the cops would come with an arrest warrant. We kept forgetting to get her bail renewed. It habitually cost us 500 rupees to have them go away. This was also, Nizamuddin. This went on for 3 years. Finally, we had to pay 3000 rupees to the judge, to get the case dropped. What a crazy screwed up system.
many years ago, while i was in ny, 6 guys broke into my house in nizamuddin, tied up my wife and child, and robbed us of everything. when my wife finally freed herself, she called the thana, and the police immediately responded. for the next 6 weeks we were visited daily by the officer assigned to the case with progress reports, and requests to go to other police stations around delhi, to try to identify the thieves. the new york police would not have been so diligent.
3 years ago i had to spend 15 hours in the nizamuddin police station. the police live and work under totally abysmal conditions. they are on duty for ridiculously long stretches of time, and seldom get to see their families. i was treated courteously, and what i consider professionally, by all: fed, and brought tea constantly. I just wished they would build a decent toilet there.
the nizamuddin police station is on the edge of the nizamuddin busti. the major issue they were dealing with the day I was there, was that one of the constables had been kidnapped by some busti dwellers, who would not release him until someone who had been arrested for stealing was first released from jail. this, of course, never made the delhi papers.
the real problem is the judicial system in india, which just does not work in any reasonable/efficient or effective fashion. let's not blame the cops for trying to cope with a set of antiquated laws inefficiently enforced and poorly administered. we complain about corrupt cops. i suggest we start by paying them a liveable salary, and then come down hard on corruption. Today, their salaries are a joke.
i am not justifying what happened to joel elliott. i am only suggesting that this is not a black or white world out there. we really cannot expect much from the police when the public, the judicial system, and the laws create an environment wherein it is just not possible for them to be professional law enforcement officers. We once had a really great cop: Karen Bedi. Look what our system did to her. The system sucks, not the police.
I have probably had as much actually contact with the police as anyone else reading Outlook: in Delhi, in Ghaziabad, in Moradabad, in Jhunjhunu District, Rajasthan. Some of our cops are ok, some are damn good, and some are just as bad as those they are supposed to be arresting. If I bumped into a cop in the middle of the night in the dark, in NYC, he probably would have also turned around and hit me, as happened to Joel. Joel was at a farewell party. He probably did have a drink(s). If you bump into a cop, and then hit him, you can be damn sure he will retaliate. I think Joel was living in a dream world if he expected anything other than what happened. Not justifiable, but expectable. T.I.I. Just remember what was on the back of blue line buses for years: BE INDIAN, BUY AN INDIAN.
joel waldman
new york, United States
Oct 13, 2009 04:42 AM
8
I wanted to say this for a long time.

Dedicated to Delhi Police

Jat ray Jat Solah Dooni Aath
JayKay Chraborty
Kolkatta, India
Oct 12, 2009 09:50 PM
7
dear sandilya r u admiring the sarcasm of waldman or feel he is praising the police and denigrating his countrymate.the arrogance of delhi police is known nationally and now after this incidence internationally.did they file a chargesheet or just thrashed him to satisfy their ego.hats off to the reporter for fighting and trying to escape from the goons in uniform.the encounter specialist who was murdered in a property dispute was the role model for the delhi police and its fortunate for the reporter to have not been encountered and become a militant to fetch rewards in plenty for the great delhi daredevilry police.
ganapathi
chennai, India
Oct 12, 2009 05:23 PM
6
yes, we must be fair. just think, it was day time, and the cops could see joel, they never would have done their duty. he would have been treated with kid gloves. we should be pleased that our police are blind at nite to any skin or nationality differences. one justice system for all, not the dark.
joel waldman
new york, United States
Oct 12, 2009 05:01 PM
5
Joel is lucky he was let off by the Police after 6-7 hours. Innocent people is his country are arrested/held in prisons for months and years without any recourse to legal assistance.

Delhi police too shouldn't have taken matters in their hands literally, Joel should have been subjected to whatever punishment courts may have decided for his unsolicited intervention in Delhi Police affairs.
Rajiv Malhotra
Aligarh, India
Oct 12, 2009 01:20 PM
4
joel waldman

I appreciate your moral standing and fairness.
sandilya
Chennai, India
Oct 12, 2009 01:07 PM
3
i think we are siding with, the wrong side here. the police were just doing their duty. they should be praised for great police work, not criticized for brutality. they were only doing what they have been trained to do. why was he out after 8 pm? why didn't he watch where he was going? why did he try to interfere in police business? he owns a bullet motorcycle. why did he try to steal a taxi? why did he hit back, and not just take it as all of us would have done? Why does he think he is special: just because he is a white american reporter? why did he continually piss off the police? why couldn't he just sit quietly in the police station like all of us would have done, and take our deserved punishment for misbehaving with men in uniform? i am embarrassed by my fellow american: when in india, buy an indian (policeman). justice will take its usual, (slow) course. we should decide to issue an interpol red corner, and bring him back with Q, in another 25 years. who does he think he is suing for $500,000? why should he get any more than a bhopal gas victim's family did from union carbide? he is not dead. shame on him for not learning and adapting to our desi culture. shame on us for pretending to be embarrassed by our world-class police force which is so adept at protecting us all from terrorists, criminals, and politicians. this is all, just shameful.
joel waldman
new york, United States
Oct 12, 2009 07:58 AM
2
Beware ppl arriving for commonwealth games this is the kind of hospitality you would get.
JayKay Chraborty
Kolkatta, India
Oct 12, 2009 12:01 AM
1
>>I shouted back, saying they couldn't just beat people in the street.

you are not in kansas, anymore. this is everyday fare for the "world's largest democracy" and its uniformed thugs.

>>Elliot was drunk, trying to steal a taxi,

cops must have been too busy beating the crap out of him to take a blood sample for toxicology testing...

stealing an Indian taxi....I am still laughing at the explanation......what these uniformed and uncreative thugs in concocting a calumny they make up in brutality...
Augustus AAA
Pune, India
COLLAPSE COMMENTS   
Post a Comment
You are not logged in, please log in or register
ABOUT US | CONTACT US | SUBSCRIBE | ADVERTISING RATES | COPYRIGHT & DISCLAIMER | COMMENTS POLICY